Tuesday, February 28, 2012

Shameless Plug

So, this blog recently got nominated by readers of about.com as one of the Top Five Pregnancy Blogs this year.

I never quite know how to take something like this; I'm flattered, I'm embarrassed, and I have no idea whether or not to mention it on the blog.  Sounds too much like tooting your own horn to me, so I had decided I wasn't going to mention it.  If folks wanted to vote for me, I wasn't going to object, but I wasn't going to actively solicit votes either.  It's just a little uncomfortable.

I don't do a lot of self-promotion, and I constantly have people telling me that I need to be doing more social networking.  I'm a product of my baby-boomer generation, I guess, and I just find the whole Facebook and Twitter thing annoying and egotistical, not to mention being way too much of a time drain. I'd rather spend my all-too-minimal computer time doing something more substantive. Plus, these contests are often just a way to drive more visitors to the sponsoring organization's webpages.  It's very clever viral marketing, so I'm a bit cynical about participating in that.

And yet, I do feel it's an honor.  I know the author who runs about.com's pregnancy content, and she has consistently worked for women's best interests for years. She's not just out there trying to buy her way into more hits; she really cares about supporting women and giving them good information so they can make informed choices about their care.  This is one way of doing that.

So I got to thinking about this contest as a way to spread the word about the relatively unknown concept of Health At Every Size®, about the need for dignified and respectful treatment for women of size, and about important pregnancy and birthing issues we discuss here that apply to all women, regardless of size.  It's great to work on substantive issues, but it's even better when people actually read your messages about those issues.  It's the difference between preaching to the choir and reaching out to a whole new audience, some of whom may really need to hear those messages.

So it's with some embarrassment but also some grit-your-teeth-and-just-do-it determination that I'm letting folks know about the contest.  If you've found this blog useful at all and are so inclined, just click on the link below and go vote. You can vote now through March 21st. You can only vote once each day, but you can vote more than once.  Don't feel you have to vote, but if you want to, I thank you for helping to raise awareness of these issues to a whole new audience.  Here's the voting link:

http://pregnancy.about.com/od/readerschoiceaward/tp/Readers-Choice-Awards-2012-Blog-Finalists.htm

I really don't expect the blog to win, as we're up against some really outstanding and social-media-savvy blogs (personally, I voted for The Unnecesarean!). However, if we have a good showing, then perhaps more people who don't know my blog will come and check it out. That's all I'm aiming for.

Thanks for thinking about it.  Shameless-and-embarrassing plug over now.  We return you to our regular programming.

(And yes, I'm still holding my nose and considering the whole Facebook thing. I know you young whipper-snappers don't understand resistance to Facebook, but us old geezers just have a great distaste for the whole concept. Or at least this old geezer does! But I suppose it has its uses. I'll think about it....)

Friday, February 24, 2012

Breastfeeding Helps Lower the Risk for Maternal Heart Disease

Thanks to JC for sharing this picture
February is American Heart Month, a month to raise awareness about the frequency and impact of heart disease in U.S. society.  My colleagues over at the Association for Size Diversity and Health have a new blog post up about lowering your risk for heart disease, whatever your size.

But I have to add that there's one thing that women in particular can do to help lower their risk for heart disease, and that's ─ surprise! ─ breastfeeding, which brings it within the realm of this blog.

So, in honor of American Heart Month, let's discuss how long-term breastfeeding can help lower the risk for heart disease in the mother.

Research has traditionally focused on how breastfeeding may help lower the risk for various problems in a child as he grows up, but until fairly recently, there hadn't been a lot of data on whether it helped lower the risk for various heart risk factors for the mother.

Now, thanks to the Nurses Health Study, the Women's Health Initiative, CARDIA, and other studies, we know that breastfeeding is protective for the mothers as well, especially extended (or long-term) breastfeeding.

Below you will find the abstracts for a number of studies about how breastfeeding lowers the risk for hypertension, metabolic syndrome, diabetes, high fasting insulin levels, and high lipid levels.

Now, of course, there are some caveats to this research.  The overall effect for some factors is not huge, for example, and obviously many people who do breastfeed long-term go on to develop high blood pressure, diabetes, or heart disease.  There are multiple factors at work here, not just breastfeeding.

So it's important to remember that breastfeeding, even long-term breastfeeding, is not a guarantee against heart disease.  But even with these caveats, the findings are encouraging.  Here's something we can do that will really benefit both our babies and ourselves.

Notes on the Studies

Note that the length of breastfeeding time is an important variable which varies greatly among these studies.  Some studies looked at women who breastfed longer than 2 years, some at longer than 1 year, while others only looked at those who breastfed longer than 3 or 6 months.  There's likely a significant difference in risk between those who breastfed for only 3 months vs. those who breastfed for several years! So if anything, the effect might be even stronger.

Yet the 2010 diabetes study listed below only looked at women who breastfed longer than 1 month, and they still found an effect.  How much more of an effect might there be if they had followed women who had breastfed far more long-term?  THAT'S where this research needs to go in the future.

I'd also point out that this research is a pretty big condemnation of doctors in past generations discouraging women from breastfeeding.  That just goes to show that even with the best training, doctors can still be misguided, and the medical "standard of care" isn't always best for women or babies.  Doctors are human and sometimes they are misguided....and that can still be true today.

Even now, support for extended breastfeeding is still tepid among many physicians (like the one who told me there were no benefits to breastfeeding beyond about 6 weeks). There are far too many hospitals who only pay lip service to the idea of breastfeeding but whose policies actually impede it.  Much progress remains to be made in promoting breastfeeding, and that's even now, when we know how important it is.

Another vital point is that there is research not just on breastfeeding improving intermediate outcomes (risk factors for heart disease, like diabetes or hypertension), but also for it improving long-term outcomes (i.e., actual incidence of coronary heart disease, not just impact on risk factors).  As the press release for the 2009 study noted:
In their analysis of 89,326 parous women in the Nurses’ Health Study, Stuebe et al found that compared with women who had never lactated, women who had breastfed for 2 or more years had a 37 percent lower risk for CHD after adjusting for age, parity, stillbirth history, early-adult adiposity, parental history, and lifestyle factors. 
The authors note that this protective effect is characterized by a threshold effect at 2 years, as women had a hazard ratio (HR) of 0.87 for CHD if they had breastfed for more than 1 year versus no lactation, compared with 0.77 for 2 or more years. 
Considering the dose-response relationship they found, I wonder what the effect is for those of us who have breastfed far more than 2 years total?  Although my breastfeeding days are sadly over now, I spent about 10 years breastfeeding, cumulatively speaking.  Since I have significant risk factors for heart disease (what with the PCOS, insulin resistance, and a family history of CHD), I'm hoping this helps reduce some of that risk!

In the end, I think it's pretty darn conclusive that breastfeeding is not just good for babies, but for long-term maternal health as well.  We knew that was true for various cancers, but now we know it's true for heart health as well.

To lower the number of heart-related deaths, the CDC has joined together with several other organizations to promote the Million Hearts™ Initiative. They recommend the following ideas to help lower your risk for heart disease (and how refreshing is it that their recommendations are HAES-friendly!):
  • Get up and get active by being physically active for at least 30 minutes on most days of the week.
  • Know your ABCS:
    • Ask your doctor if you should take an Aspirin every day.
    • Find out if you have high Blood pressure or Cholesterol, and if you do, get effective treatment.
    • If you Smoke, get help to quit.
  • Make your calories count by eating a heart-healthy diet high in fresh fruits and vegetables and low in sodium and trans fat.
  • Take control of your heart health by following your doctor's prescription instructions.
To this list, we can now add breastfeeding, especially long-term.  Breastfeeding is not a guarantee against heart problems, obviously, but it does seem to help, and any help to lower the risk for the number one cause of death is very welcome. 

*Please note, posting this research is not meant to make mothers who can't breastfeed feel bad.  Because PCOS can impact milk supply in some women, a number of my readers may well have experienced breastfeeding struggles, and I always want to be sensitive to that fact, even as I highlight the research supporting the benefits of breastfeeding.  I strongly encourage anyone who has struggled with breastfeeding issues to visit MOBI, Mothers Overcoming Breastfeeding Issues, and www.lowmilksupply.org, both of which are incredible resources for both information and support.


References

*Please note that a number of the following abstracts have links to free full texts of the studies.

Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2009 Feb;200(2):138.e1-8. Epub 2008 Dec 25. Duration of lactation and incidence of myocardial infarction in middle to late adulthood. Stuebe AM, et al.   PMID: 19110223
OBJECTIVE: We assessed the relation between duration of lactation and maternal incident myocardial infarction. STUDY DESIGN: This was a prospective cohort study of 89,326 parous women in the Nurses' Health Study. RESULTS: During 1,350,965 person-years of follow-up, 2540 cases of coronary heart disease were diagnosed. Compared with parous women who had never breastfed, women who had breastfed for a lifetime total of 2 years or longer had 37% lower risk of coronary heart disease (95% confidence interval, 23-49%; P for trend < .001), adjusting for age, parity, and stillbirth history. With additional adjustment for early-adult adiposity, parental history, and lifestyle factors, women who had breastfed for a lifetime total of 2 years or longer had a 23% lower risk of coronary heart disease (95% confidence interval, 6-38%; P for trend = .02) than women who had never breastfed.
CONCLUSION: In a large, prospective cohort, long duration of lactation was associated with a reduced risk of coronary heart disease.
Obstet Gynecol. 2009 May;113(5):974-82. Duration of lactation and risk factors for maternal cardiovascular disease. Schwarz EB, et al.   PMID: 19384111
OBJECTIVE: To examine dose-response relationships between the cumulative number of months women lactated and postmenopausal risk factors for cardiovascular disease.
METHODS: We examined data from 139,681 postmenopausal women (median age 63 years) who reported at least one live birth on enrolling in the Women's Health Initiative observational study or controlled trials. Multivariable models were used to control for sociodemographic (age, parity, race, education, income, age at menopause), lifestyle, and family history variables when examining the effect of duration of lactation on risk factors for cardiovascular disease, including obesity (body mass index [BMI] at or above 30), hypertension, self-reported diabetes, hyperlipidemia, and prevalent and incident cardiovascular disease.
RESULTS: Dose-response relationships were seen; in fully adjusted models, women who reported a lifetime history of more than 12 months of lactation were less likely to have hypertension (odds ratio [OR] 0.88, P<.001), diabetes (OR 0.80, P<.001), hyperlipidemia (OR 0.81, P<.001), or cardiovascular disease (OR 0.91, P=.008) than women who never breast-fed, but they were not less likely to be obese. In models adjusted for all above variables and BMI, similar relationships were seen. Using multivariate adjusted prevalence ratios from generalized linear models, we estimate that among parous women who did notbreast-feed compared with those who breast-fed for more than 12 months, 42.1% versus 38.6% would have hypertension, 5.3% versus 4.3% would have diabetes, 14.8% versus 12.3% would have hyperlipidemia, and 9.9% versus 9.1% would have developed cardiovascular disease when postmenopausal. Over an average of 7.9 years of postmenopausal participation in the Women's Health Initiative, women with a single live birth who breast-fed for 7-12 months were significantly less likely to developcardiovascular disease (hazard ratio 0.72, 95% confidence interval 0.53-0.97) than women who never breast-fed.
CONCLUSION: Among postmenopausal women, increased duration of lactation was associated with a lower prevalence of hypertension, diabetes, hyperlipidemia, and cardiovascular disease.
Am J Epidemiol. 2011 Nov 15;174(10):1147-58. Epub 2011 Oct 12. Duration of lactation and incidence of maternal hypertension: a longitudinal cohort study. Stuebe AM, et al.  PMID: 21997568
Never or curtailed lactation has been associated with an increased risk for incident hypertension, but the effect of exclusive breastfeeding is unknown. The authors conducted an observational cohort study of 55,636 parous women in the US Nurses' Health Study II. From 1991 to 2005, participants reported 8,861 cases of incident hypertension during 660,880 person-years of follow-up. Never or curtailed lactation was associated with an increased risk of incident hypertension. Compared with women who breastfed their first child for ≥12 months, women who did not breastfeed were more likely to develop hypertension (hazard ratio (HR) = 1.27, 95% confidence interval (CI): 1.18, 1.36), adjusting for family history and lifestyle covariates. Women who never breastfed were more likely to develop hypertension than women who exclusively breastfed their first child for ≥6 months (HR = 1.29, 95% CI: 1.20, 1.40). The authors found similar results for women who had never breastfed compared with those who had breastfed each child for an average of ≥12 months (HR = 1.22, 95% CI: 1.13, 1.32). In conclusion, never or curtailed lactation was associated with an increased risk of incident maternal hypertension, compared with the recommended ≥6 months of exclusive or ≥12 months of total lactation per child, in a large cohort of parous women.
Am J Med. 2010 Sep;123(9):863.e1-6. Lactation and maternal risk of type 2 diabetes: a population-based study. Schwarz EB, et al.  PMID: 20800156
We explored the relationships between lactation and risk of type 2 diabetes in a well-characterized, population-representative cohort of women, aged 40-78 years, who were members of a large integrated health care delivery organization in California and enrolled in the Reproductive Risk factors for Incontinence Study at Kaiser (RRISK), between 2003 and 2008. Multivariable logistic regression was used to control for age, parity, race, education, hysterectomy, physical activity, tobacco and alcohol use, family history of diabetes, and body mass index while examining the impact of duration, exclusivity, and consistency of lactation on risk of having developed type 2 diabetes. RESULTS: Of 2233 women studied, 1828 were mothers; 56% had breastfed an infant for greater than or =1 month. In fully adjusted models, the risk of type 2 diabetes among women who consistently breastfed all of their children for greater than or =1 month remained similar to that of women who had never given birth (odds ratio [OR] 1.01; 95% confidence interval [CI], 0.56-1.81). In contrast, mothers who had never breastfed an infant were more likely to have developed type 2 diabetes than nulliparous women (OR 1.93; 95% CI, 1.14-3.27) [corrected]. Mothers who never exclusively breastfed were more likely to have developed type 2 diabetes than mothers who exclusively breastfed for 1-3 months (OR 1.52; 95% CI, 1.11-2.10).
CONCLUSIONS: Risk of type 2 diabetes increases when term pregnancy is followed by less than 1 month of lactation, independent of physical activity and body mass index in later life. Mothers should be encouraged to exclusively breastfeed all of their infants for at least 1 month.
Diabetes. 2010 Feb;59(2):495-504. Epub 2009 Dec 3. Duration of lactation and incidence of the metabolic syndrome in women of reproductive age according to gestational diabetes mellitus status: a 20-Year prospective study in CARDIA (Coronary Artery Risk Development in Young Adults). Gunderson EP, et al.  PMID: 19959762 
OBJECTIVE: The objective of the study was to prospectively assess the association between lactation duration and incidence of the metabolic syndrome among women of reproductive age.
RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS: Participants were 1,399 women (39% black, aged 18-30 years) in the Coronary Artery Risk Development in Young Adults (CARDIA) Study, an ongoing multicenter, population-based, prospective observational cohort study conducted in the U.S. Women were nulliparous and free of the metabolic syndrome at baseline (1985-1986) and before subsequent pregnancies, and reexamined 7, 10, 15, and/or 20 years after baseline. Incident metabolic syndrome case participants were identified according to National Cholesterol Education Program Adult Treatment Panel III (NCEP ATP III) criteria. Complementary log-log models estimated relative hazards of incident metabolic syndrome among time-dependentlactation duration categories by gestational diabetes mellitus (GDM) adjusted for age, race, study center, baseline covariates (BMI, metabolic syndrome components, education, smoking, physical activity), and time-dependent parity.
RESULTS: Among 704 parous women (620 non-GDM, 84 GDM), there were 120 incident metabolic syndrome case participants in 9,993 person-years (overall incidence rate 12.0 per 1,000 person-years; 10.8 for non-GDM, 22.1 for GDM). Increased lactation duration was associated with lower crude metabolic syndrome incidence rates from 0-1 month through greater than 9 months (P < 0.001). Fully adjusted relative hazards showed that risk reductions associated with longer lactation were stronger among GDM (relative hazard range 0.14-0.56; P = 0.03) than non-GDM groups (relative hazard range 0.44-0.61; P = 0.03).
CONCLUSIONS: Longer duration of lactation was associated with lower incidence of the metabolic syndrome years after weaning among women with a history of GDM and without GDM, controlling for preconception measurements, BMI, and sociodemographic and lifestyle traits. Lactation may have persistent favorable effects on women's cardiometabolic health.
Obstet Gynecol. 2007 Mar;109(3):729-38. Lactation and changes in maternal metabolic risk factors. Gunderson EP, et al.   PMID: 17329527
METHODS: This 3-year prospective study examined changes in metabolic risk factors among lactating women from preconception to postweaning and among nonlactating women from preconception to postdelivery, in comparison with nongravid women. Of 1,051 (490 black, 561 white) women who attended two consecutive study visits in years 7 (1992-1993) and 10 (1995-1996), 942 were nongravid and 109 had one interim birth. Of parous women, 48 (45%) did not lactate, and 61 (55%) lactated and weaned before year 10. The lactated and weaned women were subdivided by duration of lactation into less than 3 months and 3 months or more. Multiple linear regression models estimated mean 3-year changes in metabolic risk factors adjusted for age, race, parity, education, and behavioral covariates.
RESULTS: Both parous women who did not lactate and parous women who lactated and weaned gained more weight (+5.6, +4.4 kg) and waist girth (+5.3, +4.9 cm) than nongravid women over the 3-year interval; P<.001. Low-density lipoprotein cholesterol (+6.7 mg/dL, P less than .05) and fasting insulin (+2.6 microunits, P=.06) increased more for parous women who did not lactate than for nongravid and parous women who lactated and weaned. High-density lipoprotein cholesterol decrements for both parous women who did not lactate and parous women who lactated and weaned were 4.0 mg/dL greater than for nongravid women (P less than .001). Among parous, lactated and weaned women, lactation for 3 months or longer was associated with a smaller decrement in high-density lipoprotein cholesterol (-1.3 mg/dL versus -7.3 mg/dL for less than 3 months; P less than .01).
CONCLUSION: Lactation may attenuate unfavorable metabolic risk factor changes that occur with pregnancy, with effects apparent after weaning. As a modifiable behavior, lactation may affect women's future risk of cardiovascular and metabolic diseases.

Monday, February 20, 2012

Your Body Is Not A Lemon


Image from BodyLoveWellness.com


Sadly, in our society, pregnancy is often used as a time to make women feel neurotic or guilty about their bodies.

However, pregnancy is an incredible opportunity for body love and body image healing.  It offers a tremendous chance to do many years' worth of healing, compressed into a short amount of time.

Instead of hating on your body, try embracing your body instead. Marvel that the miracle of growing a new baby can occur in a lush body as well as a sparse one.  Give yourself credit for all the things your body is doing right.  Embrace the changes that pregnancy and birth bring to your body, for they are the Tiger Stripe Emblems of Honor that mark your experiences as a mother.

Remember this, for it is as true as true gets: Your body is not a lemon.  
You are not a machine. The Creator is not a careless mechanic. Human female bodies have the same potential to give birth well as aardvarks, lions, rhinoceri, elephants, moose and water buffalo.  
Even if it has not been your habit throughout your life so far, I recommend that you learn to think positively about your body.
~Ina May Gaskin, midwife and author of Ina May's Guide to Childbirth

Tuesday, February 14, 2012

"You and the Baby are About 85% Likely To Die on the Table"


The hype around the risks of pregnancy and obesity is so extreme at times that some doctors have developed an exaggerated fear of the possibilities of deadly complications in "morbidly obese" women.

In particular, some have begun to routinely tell very fat women  that they are quite likely to die during pregnancy or birth.  This is their way of bullying them out of further pregnancies or at least scaring them into massive weight loss.

Sigh. Here we go again.  We've seen the Dead Mama Card before.

Some women of size have been told that they are so fat, they'll surely have a heart attack and die during labor, that they or their baby will probably not survive a pregnancy, that choosing to be pregnant while fat is committing suicide by pregnancy, or they have been pointedly asked about their funeral arrangement preferences before surgery.

There was yet another blood pressure-raising example of this from My OB Said What?!? recently, where one OB said to a "morbidly obese" mother:
I can't believe I have been put in this position!  I absolutely resent that I am now responsible for your life and delivering this baby, you have no right thinking you can safely deliver a child when you are so overweight.    
In the comments section on the My OB Said What?!? website, the original poster gave some more details behind the case. The mother weighed in the upper 200s in her pregnancy and had had a healthy pregnancy.  At one week overdue, she had a slow leak of her amniotic fluid (normally not a big deal, but in this case it had leaked out enough that contractions were pressing on the baby's umbilical cord and interfering with his heart rate).  They took her back for a cesarean, where the on-call OB began to berate the patient and her husband with the above statement ─ and more:
This was the LEAST of the horrible things he said to my husband and I.  He lectured my husband so severely that my big tough husband started to cry.  He told us that I and the baby were about 85% likely to die on the table during the surgery and it was all hubby's fault because I am SO fat. 
What the hell.....??!!!  Where does this doctor get off treating a patient, ANY patient, no matter her risk factors, like this?

Now, up to a point, I can understand the on-call OB feeling put on the spot at having to do what he perceived as risky surgery on a larger-sized person.  This wasn't his patient, but because he was on-call, he ended up having to the surgery on a patient whose risks he was uncomfortable with.  Fair enough, even though really, that's the nature of being on-call for another doctor's patients.

But this doctor had such an exaggerated sense of fear around the pregnancy and cesarean of this woman of size.  An 85% chance of dying during the surgery?  Really?  What orifice did he pull that statistic from?

Did he really believe that statistic, or was he just trying to scare and bully this woman?  Or maybe a little of both?

Now, to be fair, some research does suggest that obesity is over-represented as a risk factor in the very few women in developed countries who die during pregnancy or birth.  It does look like it is a risk factor for some cases of maternal mortality and near-misses. And that's a legitimate cause for concern.

However, the part that gets ignored by the media is that obesity usually is a co-factor along with other factors like low socioeconomic status, non-white ethnicity, cesarean surgery, pre-eclampsia, or receiving substandard medical care (like inadequate prophylaxis against blood clots, or faulty intubation during general anesthesia).

But of course, it is often obesity only that gets the focus instead of seeing it as just one of several co-factors, and rarely do authorities seriously examine how substandard care for obese women contributes to maternal mortality.

And of course, the only cure is always seen as pushing weight loss before pregnancy instead of the more uncomfortable task of looking at how poor care for obese women has impacted outcomes. Far more effective would be studying how to improve care in obese women (by improving blood clot prophylaxis, by improved recognition of pulmonary embolisms, by more careful follow-up postpartum, by doing fewer damn cesareans in women of size in the first place).

Also conveniently ignored in the media hype is that the risk of dying during pregnancy is actually extremely small, even in women with risk factors. 

So this doctor telling this woman that she (and her baby) had an 85% chance of dying during the c-section is total and unadulterated bullsh*t.  

As I said, either this doctor has a distorted-in-the-extreme sense of risk around c-sections in obese women, or he is trying to bully this woman ─ or more likely, a bit of both.

Typically, what docs like this are trying to do is shock fat women into either losing massive amounts of weight (usually through weight loss surgery....funny how that surgery is not seen as "too risky" eh?), or to frighten them out of ever daring to have a baby again.

This kind of over-the-top scare tactic is a major exaggeration of the risks around obesity and pregnancy and is a new form of Medical Bullying.  It's trying to scare women of size out of having babies, rather than giving nuanced and evidence-based counseling about possible risks and reasonable ways to mitigate those risks.

There are so many ways that this type of tactic is wrong, but one of the things that bugs me most is that they are trying to become the gate-keepers for who is "allowed" to procreate, and they have deemed fat people unworthy of procreating.  This far exceeds their mandate as physicians, and worse, it smacks of eugenics.

It's deeming some types of risk factors (like type 1 diabetes) as worthy of having babies despite the risks, and other types of risk factors (obesity) as unworthy of having babies.

But it's not up to doctors to decide which patients with which risk factors should procreate.  

Rather, it is up to the couple to look at their particular risks and make an informed decision about having children or not. Reasonable risk counseling is appropriate, medical bullying through risk hyperbole is not.

Thankfully, most care providers do not use extreme tactics like this with women of size, but the fact that some do (and get away with it) is a terrible stain on the medical profession.  I've said it before but I'll say it again.....this is a unique and insidious form of eugenics and IT MUST STOP.


**I have a more in-depth piece about obesity and maternal mortality in the works, but seeing this entry on My OB Said What?!? necessitated a quicker response.  Stay tuned for more on this topic in the future.

Monday, February 6, 2012

Induction Math: The Importance of the Bishop Score

Image from Relay Health, as displayed on http://www.med.umich.edu/

Yet another study shows that inducing labor increases the risk for a cesarean, especially in first-time mothers with an unripe cervix (one that has not done much dilating and effacing yet).

In the study, they specifically looked at cesarean rates among induced mothers with an unripe cervix.  They found that cesarean rates were particularly high among first-time mothers who were induced with an unripe cervix, but the risk was also elevated for mothers with prior vaginal births who were induced on an unripe cervix.  

This is why it is absolutely vital to ask your provider about your Bishop Score before agreeing to induce labor.

The Bishop Score

The Bishop Score is a measure of how soft and ripe your cervix is before labor. It can help predict whether or not your body is ready for labor, and whether or not an induction is likely to succeed or fail.

A vaginal exam is done and the care provider evaluates the degree of:
  • cervical dilation (how far the cervix has opened so far)
  • cervical effacement (how thinned out the cervical walls are)
  • cervical consistency (how soft or firm the cervix is)
  • cervical position (whether the cervix is pointing forwards or backwards relative to the vaginal walls)
  • fetal station (how far down the baby is in the pelvis)
[If you need further explanation about the terminology above, you can find an excellent explanation and great illustrations here.]


Each factor is "graded" on a scale of 0-2 or 0-3.  The maximum possible score is 13. This all adds up to what some doulas call "induction math".

The exact cut-offs used differs by source, but generally a score of 5 or less indicates the woman is unlikely to go into labor spontaneously at that time, and that an induction is likely to fail (result in a cesarean).

A score of 8 or more indicates that an induction is more likely to succeed.  A score of 9 or more indicates the woman will likely go into labor on her own very soon.

Sometimes care providers use modifications of a Bishop Score to help predict likelihood of successful induction.  One point may be added to the score for the existence of pre-eclampsia or for every previous vaginal birth.  One point is often subtracted for a "postdates" pregnancy, being a first-time mother (or for no previous vaginal births), or preterm prelabor rupture of membranes.

The Bishop Score is just one tool for predicting a woman's response to induction.  Obviously, other factors matter as well.

The Influence of Fetal Position

One often-overlooked factor is fetal position ─ which way a head-down baby is facing in utero.  Most babies face either occiput anterior (back of the head towards mother's belly; baby looking at mother's back) or occiput posterior (back of the head towards mother's back; baby looking at mother's belly).

Often a low Bishop Score is associated with a posterior baby, which is a less ideal position for birth.  In this position, the the baby's head is not putting pressure as efficiently on the cervix, so there is less cervical effacement or dilation, and the cervix is often posterior (pointed towards the lower vaginal wall and hard to reach during a vaginal exam).  When the baby rotates to anterior, the Bishop Score often changes dramatically because the physics of the baby's pressure changes.

Many "overdue" babies are actually posterior babies whose positions are simply not putting the most efficient kind of pressure on the cervix to thin and dilate, and so the body wisely does not go into labor yet.  Forcing the issue by inducing labor when the baby is posterior (or has other malpositions) tends to result in long, hard labors that often end in a c-section.

[This is a pet peeve for me, because it is the story of my first c-section....induced at 40 weeks despite a very low Bishop Score (the OB told me I had a "horrible" cervix) and a malpositioned baby.  Small wonder I ended up with a cesarean!]

So if your Bishop Score is low, it may not just be that your body is not "ripe" for labor, it may also be that the reason you are not ripe is because the baby is not in a great position for labor.  For that reason, it may be wise to delay inducing until the baby is in a more favorable position for labor.

Seeing a pregnancy chiropractor and getting adjusted may help encourage the baby to get into a better position for labor, which in turn might lessen your chances for a cesarean.  (This is what was key for me in my VBACs.)

Induction Triples the Risk for Cesarean in First-Time Mothers

In the 2011 study listed below, the charts of women who were induced with a Bishop score of less than 7 were studied.

Those first-time moms who were induced with a Bishop score less than 7 had a whopping 42% cesarean rate.  

This shows just how important it is to have a nice ripe cervix before inducing labor, and especially so in first-time moms, whose cervices have never dilated before.

Sometimes a doctor will try to reassure you that it doesn't matter if your cervix isn't ripe; they use drugs that help ripen the cervix before starting the induction drugs.  And it's true that these drugs can help at times.

However, even with cervical ripening methods, many inductions still fail.  Cervical ripening drugs are simply not a panacea for preparing the body for birth when it's not ready.  They work best when the baby is in good position and the body is close to being ready but not quite there yet.  Cervical ripening methods are very unlikely to help in women with very low Bishop Scores.

Now, if the cervix has dilated before, induction is more likely to work. Women who had had vaginal births before had a much lower cesarean rate after induction in this study, 14%.  Still, this was nearly double the cesarean rate of those multips who went into labor spontaneously.  

Obviously, cervical ripeness matters, even in women who have had vaginal births before.

Take-Home Points About Induction

Additional research confirms that cervical ripeness is one of the key factors in whether or not an induction will work.  Here are some take-home lessons from the 2011 study:
  • Whenever possible, wait to go into labor spontaneously
  • If induction is being considered, try to avoid inducing if your Bishop Score is less than 7
Other general bits of wisdom about inductions:
  • Try to see a provider who is not induction-happy and won't induce automatically at a certain gestation.  This is especially important for women of size, because many providers induce "obese" women at extremely high rates (a 50-60% induction rate is common in many recent studies).  This is a direct but under-acknowledged factor in the very high cesarean rate in women of size.
  • Question whether an induction is truly necessary in your case.  Many inductions are done routinely, simply because it is convenient for the provider or protocol to induce by a certain gestational age.  However, you don't have to agree to this intervention.  Discuss the pros and cons of the induction vs. waiting with the provider, and see if you can negotiate for more time.  
  • If you are contemplating an induction, ask about your Bishop Score before agreeing to the induction.  If at all possible, try not to induce before you have a favorable Bishop Score. 
  • If you are contemplating induction, ask about your baby's position before agreeing to the induction.   If the baby is not anterior, consider delaying the induction.  Seeing a well-trained pregnancy chiropractor may help encourage the baby to get into an easier position for birth.
  • If a medical condition makes induction necessary even with an unripe cervix, look into ways to increase cervical ripeness before the induction.  This can include acupuncture, herbs, and cervical ripening agents.  Consider the pros and cons of each choice carefully for your situation, and remember that gentler methods generally need a longer time to be effective.  Don't wait to the last minute to try the more gentle methods of cervical ripening if you are very likely to face induction.
  • Be sure your provider allows adequate induction time before resorting to a cesarean.  Recent research has shown that many providers move to a cesarean too soon in an induction; allowing just a few more hours (provided mother and baby are doing well ) may result in a vaginal birth after all.
  • Remember, induction doesn't automatically mean you're going to have a cesarean; many women who are induced do end up having a vaginal birth.  Go in with a positive attitude, try to remain as mobile as possible, and be sure to have professional labor support (a doula), who can often help maximize your chances even during an induction.  However, because an induction does increase the chances for cesarean, be prepared for any possibility and have a cesarean birth plan ready if one becomes necessary.
Induction is more and more common these days.  This is why it is important for all women to be informed birth consumers and learn more about their choices around induction.  The Bishop Score is an important ─ and often overlooked ─ part of this discussion.

*Thanks to Holistic NYC Doula for the term "induction math" and for her excellent posts on the topic of the Bishop Score.



References

Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2011 Oct;90(10):1094-9. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0412.2011.01213.x. Epub 2011 Jul 21. Induction of labor and the risk for emergency cesarean section in nulliparous and multiparous women. Thorsell M, et al.   PMID: 21679162
OBJECTIVE: To assess the risk for emergency cesarean section among women in whom labor was induced in gestational week ≥41 and to evaluate if parity and mode of induction affected this association.
DESIGN: Hospital-based retrospective cohort study.
POPULATION: Singleton pregnancies delivered after ≥41 gestational weeks at Danderyd Hospital, Stockholm, Sweden, during 2002-2006.
MATERIAL AND METHODS: Of 23 030 singleton pregnancies meeting the entry criteria, 881 were induced with a Bishop score of less than 7. Obstetric outcome was assessed through linkage with the Swedish Medical Birth Registry and a local obstetrical database containing information from patients' medical files. Results were adjusted for body mass index, age and the use of epidural analgesia.
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURE: Risk for emergency cesarean section.
RESULTS: Among women who were induced, the proportions delivered by emergency cesarean section were 42% for nulliparous and 14% for multiparous. Compared to spontaneous onset, this corresponded to a more than threefold increase in risk for nulliparous women (OR 3.34, 95% CI 2.77-4.04) and an almost twofold increase in risk for multiparous women (OR 1.94, 95% CI 1.24-3.02). There was no significant difference in risk for emergency cesarean section between the two methods of induction (PGE(2) and transcervical catheter).
CONCLUSIONS: Compared to spontaneous onset of delivery, induction of labor is associated with an increased risk for emergency cesarean section both among nulliparous and multiparous women. When labor is induced, the high risk for emergency cesarean must be kept in mind.
Clin Obstet Gynecol. 2006 Sep;49(3):564-72. Preinduction cervical assessment. Baacke KA, Edwards RK.   PMID: 16885663 
The rate of labor induction is increasing in the United States. Methods for quantifying cervical factors have been developed to identify patients who may benefit from cervical ripening before induction. The first cervical scoring systems used digital examination. More recently, cervical ultrasound and testing for the presence of fetal fibronectin have been suggested to evaluatecervical readiness for labor induction, but neither of these methods provides a significant improvement over digital examination. The Bishop score, the most widely used digital examination scoring system, still is the most cost effective and accurate method of evaluating the cervix before labor induction.
Obstet Gynecol. 2005 Apr;105(4):690-7. Bishop score and risk of cesarean delivery after induction of labor in nulliparous women. Vrouenraets FP, et al.  PMID: 15802392 
OBJECTIVE: To quantify the risk and risk factors for cesarean delivery associated with medical and elective induction of labor in nulliparous women.
METHODS: A prospective cohort study was performed in nulliparous women at term with vertex singleton gestations who hadlabor induced at 2 obstetrical centers. Medical and elective indications and Bishop scores were recorded before labor induction. Obstetric and neonatal data were analyzed and compared with the results in women with a spontaneous onset of labor. Data were analyzed using univariate and multivariable regression modeling.
RESULTS: A total of 1,389 women were included in the study. The cesarean delivery rate was 12.0% in women with a spontaneous onset of labor (n = 765), 23.4% in women undergoing labor induction for medical reasons (n = 435) (unadjusted odds ratio [OR] 2.24; 95% confidence interval [CI] 1.64-3.06), and 23.8% in women whose labor was electively induced (n = 189) (unadjusted OR 2.29; 95% CI 1.53-3.41). However, after adjusting for the Bishop score at admission, no significant differences in cesarean delivery rates were found among the 3 groups. A Bishop score of 5 or less was a predominant risk factor for a cesarean delivery in all 3 groups (adjusted OR 2.32; 95% CI 1.66-3.25). Other variables with significantly increased risk for cesarean delivery included maternal age of 30 years or older, body mass index of 31 or higher, use of epidural analgesia during the first stage oflabor, and birth weight of 3,500 g or higher. In both induction groups, more newborns required neonatal care, more mothers needed a blood transfusion, and the maternal hospital stay was longer.
CONCLUSION: Compared with spontaneous onset of labor, medical and elective induction of labor in nulliparous women at term with a single fetus in cephalic presentation is associated with an increased risk of cesarean delivery, predominantly related to an unfavorable Bishop score at admission.

Sunday, January 29, 2012

More Evidence That Vertical Incisions Have Increased Complications

We have blogged about this before, but here's yet another study that vertical (up-down) cesarean incisions in "obese" women have more complications than low transverse (side-to-side) incisions.

As we've  noted before, sometimes there can be legitimate justification for using a vertical incision. However, most of the time, its use in fat women springs from outdated and non evidence-based teachings that an incision under the belly (pannus) predisposes the wound to infection, and that a vertical incision will supposedly lower the risk for infection and improve outcomes. 

Yet when researchers finally got around to actually studying the question, they found that vertical incisions either did not improve outcome OR significantly worsened it, as in this study, where incision type was associated both with infectious complications and with wound separation.

Notice that in this study, ~46%% of "morbidly obese" women with vertical incisions experienced a wound complication of some sort.  Nearly half!   

In comparison, only ~12% of morbidly obese women with low transverse incisions experienced a wound complication.

Yet still, despite more complications with vertical incisions, about 7% of obese women in this study (11% in others) are being subjected to vertical incisions instead of low transverse incisions during cesareans.  That's around 1 out of every 10 to 14 obese women having a cesarean. That's far too high a rate, considering the poorer medical and cosmetic outcomes with vertical incisions.

More and more data is accumulating to show that the most optimal incision is usually the low transverse incision, even in very fat women.  When will doctors heed their own research?




J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2012 Jan 10. Risk factors for wound complications in morbidly obese women undergoing primary cesarean delivery. Thornburg LL, et al.   PMID: 22233403

Source: Department of Obstetrics & Gynecology, Maternal Fetal Medicine, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, NY, USA.
Objective: To determine factors influencing separation and infectious-type wound complications (WC) in morbidly obese women undergoing primary cesarean delivery (CD).  
Methods: Retrospective cohort study evaluating infectious and separation WC in morbidly obese (Body mass index (BMI) greater than 35) women undergoing primary CD between 1/1994 and 12/2008. Chi-square, Fisher's exact, and Student's t-test used to assess associated factors; backwards logistic regression to determine unadjusted and adjusted odds ratios.  
Results: Of 623 women, low transverse skin incisions were performed in 588 (94.4%), vertical in 35 (7%). Overall WC rate was 13.5%, which varied by incision type (vertical 45.7% vs. 11.6% transverse; p less than 0.01), but not BMI class. Incision type and unscheduled CD were associated with infection risk, while incision type, BMI, race, and drain use were associated with wound separation.  
Conclusion: In morbidly obese women both infectious and separation-type WC are more common in vertical than low transverse incisions; therefore transverse should be preferred.

Monday, January 23, 2012

News Flash: Labor Managed Differently in High-BMI Women!

For a long time, doctors have observed a higher cesarean rate in high-BMI women, but always blamed this solely on obesity.

But how would obesity impede labor and result in more cesareans, you ask?

The usual reasons given (based on assumptions or poor research) were soft tissue dystocia (i.e., the fat vagina theory), or inefficient uterine contractility due to high leptin or cholesterol levels (seriously, that's a current theory still floating around, despite evidence that contradicts it).

Yet no one was asking whether the way labor was managed in "obese" women contributed to this high cesarean rate.

Now, for the first time, FINALLY someone is starting to ask these questions!  A Canadian study out earlier this year examined labor management of obese women compared with other women.

And guess what?!  As I've been saying for years, they found that the labors of women of size are indeed managed differently, with more interventions and a much lower threshold for surgery. 

Furthermore, when the study controlled for the use of interventions, the relationship between obesity and cesareans was "markedly attenuated." 

Details from the Study

There are a couple of interesting items in the study worth a closer look.

Induction Rates

First, induction rates went up strongly as BMI increased.  Here's a summary of induction rates by BMI category (delivery BMI):
  • "Normal" BMI (20-24.9)               23.7% induced
  • "Overweight" BMI (25-29.9)         29.3% induced
  • "Obese" BMI (30-39.9)                37.2% induced
  • "Morbidly Obese" BMI (40+)       50.0% induced
Now, some of that increased rate is to be expected, given that fatter women have higher rates of pre-eclampsia and other complications, and induction is more common in women with these complications.  But even so, a 50% induction rate?  Do 50% of all "morbidly obese" women really need to be induced? Come on!

A great deal of research has shown that induction of labor is linked to higher cesarean rates.  This is particularly true for first-time mothers or women who have never had a vaginal birth before, or whose cervix was not ripe before the induction.

So why don't any researchers (including this one) connect the dots between such an extremely high induction rate in women of size and a resulting high cesarean rate?

The authors don't really comment on the induction rates or question them at all; most research never does.  Most authors assume that all these inductions are truly indicated, especially in women of size.  But frankly, they need to question such a high rate of induction more closely.

How many of these inductions were for real medical indications, and how many were for dubious indications like suspected macrosomia or provider fear? 

We know from research that inducing early for a suspected big baby does not improve outcomes, and actually strongly increases the cesarean rate in many studies.  Yet it is common practice still among clinicians to induce labor early if a big baby is suspected, especially in women of size. 

So when you see the 50% induction rate in "morbidly obese" women, how many were for "soft" indications like suspected macrosomia?  And what was the cesarean rate among those induced for "soft" indications? I would love for researchers to look more carefully at induction indications and how that influences cesarean rates in women of size.

We know from another recently published study that high induction rates definitely do have a strong influence on cesarean rates in obese women.  According to the authors of that study:
We conclude that morbid obesity is associated with a significantly higher risk of pre-existing medical conditions, developing antenatal complications, induction of labour, caesarean section and greater birth weight. However, there was no significant difference in caesarean section rates when adjusted for induction of labour. 
More research is needed to further clarify the impact of high induction rates on cesarean rates in obese women, and researchers need to finally start questioning the validity of many of these inductions.

Cervical Status Upon Admission

Another interesting finding that deserves further investigation is a major difference in cervical status upon admission and what might be influencing this.

Women whose cervix is more dilated upon admission tend to have shorter labors and a lower cesarean rate; those whose cervix is less dilated at admission usually have longer labors and more cesareans because their bodies aren't ready to labor yet. 

In this study, 37.9% of women of average BMI had minimal cervical dilation (2 cm or less) upon admission to the hospital.  In comparison, 55.7% of "morbidly obese" women had minimal cervical dilation upon admission.

Yes, this is surely partly due to a higher rate of inductions and therefore less spontaneous labors in the high-BMI group, but it also suggests that perhaps this group is far less ready for labor when being induced.  Again, many authors have noted this and have blamed it on "inefficient uterine contractility" or hormonal deficits, but what if there are other factors they are not considering?

Studies have shown that high-BMI women have longer menstrual cycles and longer gestations; perhaps what is happening is that their due dates are not being sufficiently adjusted for their longer cycle length and as a result, their bodies are less ready for labor when the doctors think they "should" be going into labor. And, as a result, they have more inductions, less cervical ripeness when induced, and more cesareans when the induction doesn't work.

More Interventions

The study found that there was more use of oxytocin augmentation and epidurals as BMI increased.  The pit augmentation increase may reflect the lower level of cervical ripeness before labor, but it may also reflect the common perception among some clinicians that obese women won't labor sufficiently on their own. So they automatically just start pitocin augmentation, without ever looking at whether it's needed or not.

The increased epidural rate may simply reflect the higher rate of inductions and pitocin augmentations; it's hard to go through such induced and augmented labors with little mobility and not need some pain relief.  However, it may also reflect the common practice of strongly encouraging early epidural placement in obese women to avoid a difficult placement later if a cesarean is needed.

(And of course, once that epidural is placed, oxytocin augmentation is often needed to compensate for the way that epidurals tend to slow labor.  It can be an vicious circle.)

Lower Surgical Threshold

The study also shows that doctors were quicker to terminate labor early and move to a cesarean in "obese" women.  In the study, the labors of "morbidly obese" women were terminated about an hour earlier than women of average BMI.

Some of this is understandable; surgery in a very heavy woman is more difficult and takes quite a bit longer than in a woman of average size.  Doctors want to avoid an emergency situation where every second counts to save a baby, and especially so in a woman whose extensive adipose layers may require more time to get to the baby in the first place.  Therefore, doctors may be more prone to intervene early in women of size, before things get to an emergency situation.

Yet most cesareans are not done under truly emergent conditions, and research shows that many women whose progress is slow are able to give birth vaginally if just given a little more time, and their babies generally do just as well.

So doctors have to walk a fine line between not waiting too late and not intervening too early.  From this study, it looks like too many doctors are erring on the side of intervening far too early.  And because cesareans are extra risky for women of size, this is a cause for concern ─ and a potentially modifiable variable for reducing the tremendously high cesarean rate in women of size.

Final Thoughts

As I've been saying for years, the high cesarean rate in obese women is not only about obesity itself, but also about the way that obese women are managed during pregnancy.

Sky-high induction rates, increased utilization of interventions during labor, and a very low threshold for surgical intervention all combine to ratchet up the cesarean rate in women of size.

The important thing to note is that these are all potentially modifiable factors for reducing the cesarean rate in this group.  

Up till now, the only options most doctors saw for lowering the cesarean rate in women of size involved  encouraging weight loss before pregnancy or restricting weight gain during pregnancy.  Yet this research suggests that if doctors simply change their management practices and fear levels around women of size, it's likely that the cesarean rate can be lowered in this group without draconian weight restrictions.

In the Canadian study, the authors concluded: 
Because of the potential morbidities associated with Caesarean section, we must modify our management approaches to allow equal opportunity for a vaginal birth for all women.
Those are strong words for an obstetrical community that's usually pretty mealy-mouthed about these things, and frankly, it's nice to finally hear them from someone other than me.  Bravo to these authors for being willing to advocate for vaginal birth for women of size at a time when some doctors are advocating pre-emptive cesareans across the board for this group.

But if doctors really want to get serious about allowing equal opportunity for a vaginal birth for fat women, first and foremost they need to crack down on the insanely high induction rates, as well as re-examining the use of interventions and threshold for surgery in this group.


References

J Obstet Gynaecol Can. 2011 May;33(5):443-8. Higher caesarean section rates in women with higher body mass index: are we managing labour differently? Abenhaim HA, Benjamin A.  PMID: 21639963
Background: Higher body mass index has been associated with an increased risk of Caesarean section. The effect of differences in labour management on this association has not yet been evaluated.

Methods: We conducted a cohort study using data from the McGill Obstetrics and Neonatal Database for deliveries taking place during a 10-year period. Women's BMI at delivery was categorized as normal (20 to 24.9), overweight (25 to 29.9), obese (30 to 39.9), or morbidly obese (≥ 40). We evaluated the effect of the management of labour on the need for Caesarean section using unconditional logistic regression models.

Results: Data were available for 11 922 women, of whom 2289 women had normal weight, 5663 were overweight, 3730 were obese, and 240 were morbidly obese. After adjustment for known confounding variables, increased BMI category was associated with an overall increase in the use of oxytocin and in the use of epidural analgesia, and with a decrease in use of forceps and vacuum extraction among second stage deliveries. 
Higher BMI was also found to be associated with earlier decisions to perform a Caesarean section in the second stage of labour. 
When adjusted for these differences in the management of labour, the increasing rate of Caesarean section observed with increasing BMI category was markedly attenuated (P less than 0.001). 
Conclusion: Women with an increased BMI are managed differently in labour than women of normal weight. This difference in management in part explains the increased rate of Caesarean section observed with higher BMI.
Aust N Z J Obstet Gynaecol. 2011 Apr;51(2):172-4. Impact of morbid obesity on the mode of delivery and obstetric outcome in nulliparous singleton pregnancy and the implications for rural maternity services. Green C, Shaker D.  PMID: 21466521
Obesity represents a rapidly emerging epidemic amongst pregnant women. Our study looks at the impact of morbid obesity on pregnant singleton nulliparous women in comparison with normal body mass index women. We conclude that morbid obesity is associated with a significantly higher risk of pre-existing medical conditions, developing antenatal complications, induction of labour, caesarean section and greater birth weight. However, there was no significant difference in caesarean section rates when adjusted for induction of labour. We also found no significant difference in length of hospital stay, postnatal complications and neonatal morbidity.



Monday, January 16, 2012

Increased Morbidity After Just One Cesarean

This study is about adverse outcomes in the next pregnancy after just one cesarean.  Women with only one prior cesarean were already at increased risk for anemia, placental abruption (where the placenta pulls away from the uterus before birth, cutting off nutrients and oxygen), uterine rupture, and hysterectomy.

Of course, the actual numerical risk of these complications is generally small, but it does represent an increased risk over women who first birth was vaginal, and that's an important point.

If 1 out of 3 women in the USA is having a baby via cesarean (and in some hospitals, the rate is more like 1 in 2 or more), that's an awful lot of potential risk being put onto women.  And that's after only one cesarean. Most women who have one cesarean will go on to have more with future children because VBAC is not an option in far too many hospitals.

When cesareans save lives, these risks are absolutely worth the trade-off.  When cesareans are used casually or for dubious indications, these trade-offs are much more ominous.

The authors' conclusion is that women who have cesareans need to be counseled about the possible increased risks in future pregnancies. This is true, but the importance of reducing these risks by avoiding that first cesarean whenever possible should also have been mentioned.

Recognizing that cesareans carry risks is an important part of the discussion of the public health implications of a high c-section rate.  



Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2011 Sep 24. [Epub ahead of print] Morbidity following primary cesarean delivery in the Danish National Birth Cohort. Jackson S, et al.   PMID: 22051815
Source: Division of Maternal Fetal Medicine, Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Cedars-Sinai Medical Center, Los Angeles, CA. 
OBJECTIVE: Cesarean delivery rates are on the rise in many countries, including the United States. There is mounting evidence that cesarean delivery is associated with adverse reproductive outcomes in subsequent pregnancies. The purpose of this article is to review those outcomes in a well-defined cohort of pregnant women.
STUDY DESIGN: In a cohort of primigravid women from the Danish National Birth Cohort with known baseline exposure characteristics, we stratified women by method of first delivery, vaginal or cesarean, and evaluated for appearance of adverse reproductive events in subsequent pregnancies.
RESULTS: After adjusting for age, body mass index, alcohol, smoking, and socioeconomic status, women who underwent cesarean delivery at first birth were at increased risk in their subsequent pregnancy for anemia (odds ratio [OR], 2.8; 95% confidence interval [CI], 2.3-3.4), placental abruption (OR, 2.3; 95% CI, 1.5-3.6), uterine rupture (OR, 268; 95% CI, 65.6-999), and hysterectomy (OR, 28.8; 95% CI, 3.1-263.8).
CONCLUSION: Women who deliver their first baby with a cesarean are at increased risk of adverse reproductive outcomes in subsequent pregnancies and should be counseled accordingly.

Monday, January 9, 2012

Need an Extra Layer for Warmth?

If you are a person of size and a "cold" person ─ that is, strongly affected by cold weather and in need of lots of extra layers during the wintertime ─ then you know how hard it can be to find those extra layers in our sizes.  So let's talk about that for a minute.

As frequent readers know, I have hypothyroidism.  It's well-treated with meds, my TSH is in my ideal range, and I'm much less symptomatic than I used to be, but that doesn't mean I am totally symptom-free.

One of the most striking symptoms that remains is how poorly I regulate my temperature.  Within a certain range of temps, I'm fine, but even slightly outside that narrow range and I'm really uncomfortable.  In particular, I am strongly affected by cold.  It really makes me absolutely miserable, I kid you not.

So I'm always looking for extra layers to help keep me warmer in the winter...but I am a bit claustrophobic and hate feeling suffocated by really thick or poufy layers.  And I don't tolerate itchy fabrics like wool very well either.  In addition, even when there's good-quality stuff available, it's usually not available in my size.  Most plus-sized stuff in the athletic brands goes up to 2x or maybe 3x, but I typically prefer a 4x because I like things quite roomy and comfortable.  So it's not easy to find something that suits my needs very well.

Junonia makes exercise and outdoorwear in extended sizes (4x, 5x, sometimes 6x). I've bought from them for years but their quality is spotty.  Sometimes I get something really great from them (so they are definitely worth checking out), but sometimes I've gotten some very mediocre stuff too.  Generally speaking, they don't seem to have the kind of quality and choice of really good outdoor stuff that I could get at REI if I were of average size, like the really high-tech insulation-against-cold fabrics or the ultra-light packable gear, etc.  And I really want the good stuff.

I am not overly outdoorsy because of my cold-weather intolerance but I do have times when I do outdoorsy stuff.  I like to take walks in my area, and we have been known to camp or hike. I also volunteer at my kids' school, which regularly has "farm days" (for environmental education), no matter what the weather is...raining, windy, snowing, sleeting, you name it. That can be pretty brutal.  So I definitely need some layers and good outerwear for these activities.

Even around the house at night, it gets a lot colder than I am comfortable with, but I'm not willing to crank up the heat for the whole house that far when I'm the only one really affected. So, given how cold I tend to be, I need some good-quality layers for lounging around or working at home. I'm looking for lightweight but very warm layers ─ in my size ─ that I can add and subtract as needed.

Last year, I discovered that Columbia Sportswear carries good-quality sports and cold-weather clothing/gear in plus sizes.  They have women's sizes up to 3x, but their men's sizes go up to 4x and sometimes 5x.  This gives more choices to those of us who need/prefer extended sizes. (The men's sizes also have an option for "tall" sizes if you need that. I, alas, am very far from needing that.)

It frustrates me to have to shop in the men's department in order to get really good-quality sports and outdoor clothing in my size, but hey, at least we have some choices, even if it's in menswear.  So last year I invested in a whole bunch of winter gear from Junonia and Columbia, and have been testing it this year to see what's best.

I've fallen in love with the following item and wanted to let you know about it before it's all gone:

http://www.columbia.com/Men%E2%80%99s-Mountain-Tech%E2%84%A2-1/2-Zip-%E2%80%94-Big/AX6565,default,pd.html#

It's a lightweight polyester half-zip sports shirt for wicking away moisture while running or biking.  However, I've found that it does an amazing job of keeping me warmer, much better than a wool sweater or a cardigan.  I just wear normal clothes underneath, and put this on top whenever I start feeling chilly.

That's usually enough for hanging around the house, doing chores, driving in the car or for short jaunts outside if the weather's not too bad.  For longer outside jaunts in nasty weather, I wear them for layering under my winter coat (the soft shell coat or the Bugaboo parka from Columbia) as needed.

Sometimes if I'm really cold I will put on two of these zip-up sports shirts.  They are so lightweight that I don't feel like the Stay-Puft Marshmallow Man, and they really do add a nice layer of extra warmth.  I haven't found this combination of warmth and thinness of fabric with any other product, so I wanted to be sure to let you know about these before they are all gone.

These little zip-up sport shirts have made a MAJOR difference for me in staying warmer in and out of the house.  I still have cold moments, but these have really helped. They come in several different colors and pack really well, so they'd be ideal for trips too.

I'm buying some more to have on-hand.  I was hoping they'd be on sale after the holidays, but no such luck. So they're not cheap....about $40.....but well worth it in my book!

If you need some more stay-warm options, you might want to check them out.

Thursday, December 29, 2011

Fourth Annual Turkey Awards: Leaps of Logic, the Dead Baby Card, and Scorched Earth Tactics

Well, it's that time of year again...time for my Fourth Annual Turkey Awards.

The Turkey Awards are my opportunity to highlight a biased or ignorant remark or media coverage of "obesity and pregnancy," a particularly insensitive treatment by a care provider towards a woman of size, or a trend in the care of women of size that is troubling and frustrating.

As always, I have plenty of candidates to choose from.  The hard part is limiting myself to just one.

Here's this year's nominee, another gem from My OB Said What.  I picked this one because it fails on several different levels:
“I am sure you have gestational diabetes because you are overweight, you need to be on Glucophage. If you are not comfortable taking that medication you will end up with a stillborn.”   – OB to mother, as found here
Sigh. This doctor may have meant well, but his statement has several things that demonstrate some of the troubling trends and perceptions around obesity and pregnancy, including:
  • Jumping To Conclusions About Risks
  • Scorched-Earth Tactics To Deal With Inflated Perception of Risk
  • Pulling the Dead Baby Card To Ensure Compliance with Intervention.
Jumping To Conclusions About Risk

Okay, let's start with the obvious ─ the exaggeration of risk around obesity and pregnancy. We've discussed this before, but it always bears repeating because it's such a common issue.

The problem with the coverage of risk around obesity and pregnancy is that providers often start doing "mental inflation" of the actual numerical risk, and then they start making unfounded leaps of logic from there.

A statement with some truth to it, such as "Obese women are at increased risk for gestational diabetes," gets hyped in the press and in the research until it becomes transformed in some caregivers' minds into "Most obese women get gestational diabetes."  Then it's just a short jump to "Nearly all obese women get gestational diabetes" to "This obese woman no doubt ALREADY HAS gestational diabetes right now."

But the fact of the matter is that while the risk for gestational diabetes is definitely increased in women of size, most women of size still don't get GD.  You can cherrypick whatever study you want, but no study shows a 100% GD rate in obese women, even the most obese women.

Many studies show around a 15% risk for GD in "morbidly obese" women.  This is definitely higher than the 2-4% range found in a "normal BMI" population, but hardly universal.  What most providers fail to do is the opposite math.....that is, if 15% of morbidly obese women get GD, then that means that 85% do NOT.

Yes, that's right.....the majority of even very fat women will not get GD.

Are fat women at increased risk for getting GD?  Yes, absolutely.  Do all of them get it?  No, not even remotely close.  In fact, most do not get it.

And remember, just because a particular group is at increased risk for a complication does not mean that everyone in that group will get that complication, nor does it mean that you can predict the outcome for any individual within that group.

Of course, you can make a case for this being a rogue doctor, jumping to conclusions. Hopefully, most providers who care for women of size understand that GD is by no means a foregone conclusion in this group.  But I'm hearing stories like these more and more often.

There are a lot of care providers out there who have a distorted sense of risk around obese women and GD, from the ones who force their obese clients to undergo really frequent GD testing to those that push weight loss during pregnancy as a way to avoid GD (despite evidence that weight loss in pregnancy is risky).

So this comment is a candidate for this year's Turkey Award because of this individual doctor's mental inflation of risk ─ turning a mere potential of risk into an inevitable outcome in his mind.

But this comment also gets nominated because it's not just about this doctor's individual bias; it demonstrates an overall troubling trend of a distorted sense of risk about pregnancy in women of size.

Scorched Earth Tactics for Inflated Perception of Risk

Another issue I see in the comment is the kind of Scorched Earth, over-the-top tactics that some providers take in order to try to reduce the risks associated with obesity and pregnancy.  There is little research on these tactics, mind, but because care providers have such an exaggerated sense of risk around obese pregnancies, they feel justified in taking the Napalm Option...just in case.

For example, in the past, some care providers have advocated extremely restrictive diets for obese women in pregnancy.  Obese pregnant women have been put on 1200 calorie or even 1000 calorie diets during pregnancy, or told to drink Slim-Fast in order to limit their weight gain. Some are told that they have to lose weight during pregnancy....10, 20, even 50 pounds, during pregnancy.  It doesn't matter how this is achieved, the main goal is for them to lose weight in pregnancy, even if it sacrifices nutritional adequacy, since many care providers erroneously believe that fat women have extra nutritional stores to draw from instead.

This is the Napalm Option; resorting to extreme measures because you don't know what else to do or you are convinced that the risk is SOO high that only extreme measures will improve outcomes.

A new Scorched-Earth Tactic being considered is a move among some care providers to prophylactically prescribe metformin to all obese women during pregnancy in order to prevent big babies and other complications.

The use of Glucophage (metformin) in pregnancy is already somewhat controversial, even in women with strong indications for it (PCOS, severe insulin resistance, gestational diabetes). Its use prophylactically in all obese women, even those without other risk factors, should be even more controversial...yet many care providers are not questioning it at all.

Metformin is probably relatively safe during pregnancy for those with strong indications for it but some docs are very conservative about its use because the trials on it so far are small and some have found an increase in pre-eclampsia in women on metformin (while others have not). More data is needed.

Therefore, many docs err on the side of taking women off metformin during pregnancy, but there are a number of practices where the protocol is to continue metformin (with informed consent) because it lowers the risk for GD and possibly miscarriage and big babies as well.

I'm not opposed to the use of metformin in pregnancy in those for whom it is indicated and in those who have been given full informed consent.  They get to evaluate the research and decide for themselves whether they think it's a worthwhile intervention. However, I think across-the-board use of metformin on all obese women is highly questionable.

One early trial of metformin in pregnancy found an increase in both pre-eclampsia and stillbirth in the metformin group, so caution is clearly indicated.  [However, it has to be noted that there are two major confounding factors here. The women on metformin were mostly type 2 diabetics with pre-existing diabetes and poorer control; they also put these same women on 1200 calories a day, which might also be a factor.] Later trials have found no increase in stillbirth with metformin.

Another study of metformin vs. insulin for treatment of GD found a slightly higher rate of spontaneous-labor prematurity in the metformin group, although the confidence intervals were wide and crossed 1.0, so the trend could be attributable simply to chance.

Bottom line, we need more long-term data from larger groups on the safety of metformin during pregnancy in women with PCOS or GD, as well as the benefits and risks of metformin used in a wider population of women. Right now, the best data shows it lowers the risk for GD and miscarriage in women with PCOS, and probably does not increase the risk for birth defects. Other results vary from study to study. It’s probably a reasonably safe med for women with PCOS or GD, but we need more data to be sure.

Despite this, there is a trend to put ALL women of size on metformin prophylactically (there is a trial of this in the UK right now) and THAT I have problems with. It’s one thing to put a woman with severe PCOS or GD on this med, it’s entirely another to put all healthy high-BMI woman with no known glucose issues on it prophylactically. Ugh.

So this comment gets an individual nod for the Turkey Award because not only does the doctor assume the woman is automatically going to get gestational diabetes, he also wants to put her on metformin prophylactically, just on the basis of her being "overweight" (without proof of GD).

But it also gets a Disturbing Trend nod because it represents a new willingness among some care providers to prescribe extreme measures ─ like prescribing weight loss during pregnancy or putting all fat women on metformin ─ because of their inflated sense of risk around pregnancy in women of size.

Remember, the Napalm Option often harms more than it helps.  We must be cautious about being overly-interventive without proof that such interventions actually improve outcomes.

Pulling the Dead Baby Card to Ensure Compliance

Yet another problem highlighted by this quote is the issue of what we cynical activists call "The Dead Baby Card."

The Dead Baby Card is telling women in an emotionally manipulative way, your baby will die if you don't do exactly what I tell you.

(Its corollary is, And If You Question Me, You're A Bad Mother and Must Not Love Your Child.)

It's not merely informing a woman of the possibility of a poor outcome, it's medical bullying trying to force a woman (via scaring or shame or guilt etc.) to go along with a particular kind of highly interventive care the physician wants.

It's not a reasonable or sensible precaution in the face of an extremely high-risk situation, it's using the mother's fears to manipulate her into some dubious intervention the doctor wants, usually for his own convenience or fear of litigation.  And it's implying that the woman is a Bad Mother if she even thinks about questioning these interventions.

It's statements like, "We think your baby is going to be 9 lbs., so you have to have a planned cesarean or your baby will get stuck and die," even though research shows that elective cesareans for macrosomia do not improve outcome and may actually worsen it.

Or telling a woman that if she chooses Vaginal Birth After Cesarean, her baby will almost certainly die. And if the woman dares to question the provider, it's using scare tactics or implying that she's selfish to even consider such another choice. It's using emotionally manipulative language to bully a mother into following a questionable course of treatment the doctor wants.

In the Metformin example above, telling the mother that if she does not go along with the doctor's preferred treatment plan (i.e. use of metformin), her baby will probably die is medical bullying, a.k.a. Pulling The Dead Baby Card.  The doctor is trying to scare her into complying with his questionable intervention by using the biggest scare tactic he knows.

Instead, the mother should be counseled about the possibility of gestational diabetes, the pros and cons of GD testing, the small but real possibility for stillbirth if there was uncontrolled pre-existing diabetes, and offered GD testing.  She should be informed that some care providers are using Glucophage to prevent/treat GD, she should be informed of the pros and cons of metformin, and offered the choice to consider it.

She should not be ordered to take metformin, or told that if she doesn't take it her baby will undoubtedly die.  That's classic Dead Baby Card territory, and that's unethical and unconscionable medical bullying.

So this comment is a "winner" a third time because of this doctor trying to scare this mother into an extreme intervention by using emotional manipulation, and because it sadly represents a tactic that's being used against women of size far too often these days.

Medical bullying is being used far too often these days, and particularly against women of size.  This kind of over-the-top manipulation has to stop.

Final Thoughts

This comment is nominated for my Fourth Annual Turkey Award because it demonstrates an Epic Fail on several different levels.

It presumes an "overweight" woman will automatically get gestational diabetes (when most will not), it orders her to take metformin prophylactically just on the basis of her weight alone (without proof of GD), and tries to scare her into compliance by suggesting that her baby will die if she doesn't agree to this intervention.  It's a classic case of medical bullying.

Of course, we need to make it clear that most providers don't treat women of size like this.  And hopefully most would never result to medical bullying like this.

But this comment does represent several troubling trends in the care of women of size, including the tendency to Jump to Conclusions about Risks, the increasing use of Scorched-Earth Tactics, and the use of the Dead Baby Card to scare women of size into whatever extremist intervention the doctor wants to use on them.

And that's why this little comment gets this year's nomination for a Turkey of the Year Award.


*By the way, My OB Said What is looking for submissions on the idiotic things caregivers sometimes say to women.  If you have more doozies on things they say to fat pregnant women, I hope you will submit them so we can document this kind of treatment.


Do note, they also accept submissions for positive, helpful things caregivers say to women─it doesn't always have to be bad. If you have had a really supportive caregiver as a woman of size, be sure to nominate those stories too.  It's so important to highlight the positive stuff too!


Either way, email your story to submissions@myobsaidwhat.com