Sunday, July 8, 2012

Kids' Bucket List

A little fluff for the post-Holiday week.....how about an Open Thread Question?

What's on your "bucket list" of must-have skills for kids to learn before they grow up and move out?

I'm not talking about bucket lists in the usual sense (things you want to do before you die), but instead, vital skills you think children should have before they move out of the house and start living on their own.

If you are a parent, what things have you made (or intend to make) a priority in your house?  If you aren't a parent, what did you wish your parents had taught you that you really needed to live on your own?  Or conversely, what were the things your parents did teach you that were very helpful or fulfilling skills to have?

My bucket list for my kids includes a lot of life skills and practical stuff, as well as things to keep them well-balanced human beings.  Some we are doing well on, and some are still on the "to-do" list.  Let's chat about a few.

Life Skills

In terms of life skills, I want my kids to have what I consider to be essential skills like first-aid/CPR, knowing how to swim, what to do in a disaster, that sort of thing.  You'd be surprised how many people don't know basic first-aid, for example.  It's just common sense for everyone to have good training in this.

I also think every child should know how to do some basic gardening.  My mom taught me a little bit of gardening, but I was known as the Black Thumb of Doom for many years because I killed plants left and right.  It took a number of tries before I figured it out as an adult and could raise a halfway decent garden.  I'm still a pretty casual gardener by serious gardening standards, but I raise enough that I could help our family in hard times. I'm trying to pass this along to my kids, but they certainly aren't overly enthusiastic about it.  Still, they'll have at least some knowledge in it.

Similarly, I think kids should know how to put up food.  This is a skill that has been lost in many families. Despite growing up on or near farms (in the Depression and WWII, no less!), neither my parents nor my in-laws ever learned canning or putting up food from their own parents, and so we in turn, never learned it either. But we as a society are far too dependent on a food supply system that is easily broken down during disasters or sudden fuel-supply crises.  It's important to not only have some of your own bought food reserves, but also to know how to grow your own and store it safely.  I'm still learning this skill; I'm making my oldest two learn it with me as well this summer.

I think all kids should have some experience with camping, nature, fire-making, and outdoor skills. Sadly, I got little of this in my upbringing.  As a result, I am just not Nature Girl; I get too cold too easily to be comfortable camping for long.  However, I'm working on building up some practical skills like fire-making and outdoor cooking skills anyway, just in case. Luckily, my husband is an Eagle Scout so he has made sure his boys are involved in Boy Scouts and are getting plenty of practical outdoor skills.  We haven't been as good with my daughters, mostly for coincidental (not sexist) reasons, but it's something I want to remedy.  My oldest has some significant medical issues so she's not going to be Nature Girl either, but we still have time to teach my littlest one some good skills, and the older one, like me, can at least learn some stuff. Definitely something we need to work on.

Another thing we've really fallen short on in our house is practical skills like how to take care of mechanical stuff, like cars and other machinery. I don't know anything about it; I've always depended on my husband.  Not a good idea. I want all my kids to have these skills, but frankly, we have just been too busy to pursue this, and so I feel like I've really fallen down on this important skill. It's on our "to-do" list.

What other life/essential skills can you think of that kids should learn before they become adults?

Practical Skills

On the practical side, I think all kids should know how to cook for themselves, do their own laundry, clean house properly, take care of the yard, etc.  It floors me how many kids leave home without knowing how to do these things, or with minimal cooking skills etc.

Start slowly when they are young, then gradually add chores for these things as they age.  This is important not only for life skills, but this is also how kids learn to be responsible, good workers.

We sometimes have playdates with friends, and it always shocks me when children eat a meal but don't take their dishes to the sink, or open a fruit leather and then just drop the wrapper on the floor and walk off.  What am I, your slave?  But apparently that's the way some houses are run.  Gah!

I'm not a fan of what I call Martyr Mothering ─ doing it all for your family so they don't have to. I don't like Martyr Mothering because it doesn't make your children (or husband) independent functioning humans, it makes a slave out of you by taking up most of your time (that could be spent on other activities), it doesn't teach children responsibility for themselves and their own actions, and it teaches a lack of acknowledgement/gratitude for the work of others and for the tasks that make a pleasant family home.

Now, of course, every family negotiates their own balance of chores ─ who does what, etc.  And that balance doesn't have to be the same for your family as for mine. Yet I see that many children don't have to do many chores and aren't learning how to care for themselves. You're really not doing your child any favors if you do everything for them or they have few chores.

Please, teach your children how to help out and how to be reasonably self-sufficient before they leave home.

Well-Balanced Human Being Skills

I think kids need experience in a variety of interest and pursuits in order to make them well-balanced human beings.  Enable your children to explore many activities.

I dislike the "specializing" approach that many parents take with their kids today ─ the kid has sports sports SPORTS all the time but never has a music class (or vice-versa).  Or the child never has the opportunity to take an art class, or to learn how to sew. Some become obsessed with one or two things and never explore anything else.

Children need to explore a variety of things before they can understand where their own interests and skills lie; it's good for kids to try new things and to experience gentle failure as well as success.  It's part of building their character.  Even highly specialized people like the Olympic-level athlete or the professional musician need to have other interests; being a well-rounded person will only help them in their chosen specialty.

Another important thing is to give children the opportunity to help in causes larger than themselves, to volunteer their time/energy for a good cause or to help others.  It's too easy to become centered only on yourself in our society; seeing the needs of others helps make children deeper, more empathetic people.

But while kids should have the opportunity to explore many different activities and to work in charitable causes, I'm also not a fan of over-scheduling children.  Children need "down" time to just play.  Imagination is a vital part of a child's life, and not just for little children. Teens need it too.

Turn off the computer and TV regularly, provide kids with a few basic games, toys, dress-up clothes, balls, swings, or whatever, and then just stand back and let them figure out how to play by themselves.  They struggle a bit at first, but in time they figure it out, and they are so much healthier for exercising those imagination muscles.  And "down time" really helps de-stress kids in a very stressed society.

Final Thoughts

Of course, all this is easy to say, harder to do.  We all fall down in some areas, and no parent ever "perfectly" prepares their children 100%.  You do the best you can to make them well-rounded and give them essential life skills, but you always have to remember that you are only the facilitator.

In the end, children are their own people and they make decisions about priorities for themselves as they grow.  We try to help them be well-rounded and diverse, but sometimes you can lead a horse to water but you can't make them drink, as the saying goes.  Some things children have to learn on their own.

For me, the goal is to offer the opportunity for building important skills and pursue lots of different interests, but it's always subject to the realities of life.  Sometimes the budget doesn't have room for all the classes you'd like to give your children.  Sometimes you just don't have the opportunity to help them pursue a certain activity. Sometimes you just don't have the skill set, budget, or extra time to help them with certain things.  You can seek out other mentors to help, but there are always limits that have to be acknowledged.  That's normal.

A kids' bucket list is not about making parents feel guilty for all the things they can't do, but rather just a road map to help parents be thoughtful about what they are doing to prepare their children for adulthood. Realizing that there will be gaps in these skills and forgiving yourself for that is part and parcel of the journey of parenting.  You just do the best you can, realize that you can't do it all, and let the rest go.  Remember that teaching children to be self-actualized learners goes a long long way towards filling any gaps.

So, in an ideal world, what are the things on your "bucket list" for your child?  If you don't have kids, what skills did your parents give you that were helpful, and what do you wish you had gotten? What do you wish people would give their kids more of?

This is an open thread; I welcome lots of comments and discussion.

Saturday, June 30, 2012

Gardening Rainbows

A recent double rainbow in my back yard at twilight.
Light at the end of the tunnel for this stressful year!

I finally got out to my garden this week after an intensely busy and high-pressured winter and spring. What a stressful year I had at work!  I'm always busy, but this year I was busy with a capital "B", and stress arrived in an economy-sized package.  Alas, that limited many of the other projects I had going (including my writing); so frustrating.  Apologies for some minimalist blogging content this spring.

I had so many things I wanted to try in the garden this year, but getting such a late late start meant that some of them just aren't going to get done this year. Feh.

However, once in a while I managed to steal a moment here and there to plant something this spring, so I do have carrots and peas going in various stages.  I had some garlic and onions overwinter, so that's helpful.  Surprisingly, I had some brussel sprouts overwinter too, so we'll see if that turns into anything. Of course I have my perennial fruits and veggies, like asaparagus, raspberries, strawberries, cherries, etc.  These form the core of my garden this year.

Asparagus Ferns to the left,
and the Rhubarb of Doom to the right

We were able to harvest asparagus this year. I planted it last year and you don't harvest the first year, so this was the first time we got to eat our own home-grown asparagus.  You harvest only minimally the second year, so we were sparing in our harvest, but I can see this is going to be a source of much delight to us. We love asparagus at our house!  Served al dente with a little garlic aeoli, or grilled with a little olive oil....Oh, sooo sooo good.  I'm just sad asparagus season is over now. But that's okay...they are busy building roots so they can give us lots of yummies next year. You can see the ferns that asparagus spears turn into in the picture above on the left.

I also planted rhubarb plants last fall, but that was a bit of a fail. I've never grown rhubarb before, so I didn't realize just how HUGE they get.  But you can see the Rhubarb of Doom in the picture above.  Uh, a little large for a raised bed planter, ya think? Obviously, it doesn't need the babying of being in a raised bed, based on its dinosaur-sized leaves.  So we're going to have to dig this puppy up and move it to a better spot.  I'm not looking forward to that job.


You can see the first strawberries of the season above. We're harvesting strawberries like crazy now. I will have enough to make a large batch of freezer jam that's just from our garden; in the past, I've had to supplement with berries from various Farmer's Markets.  I probably will again for later batches, but it's very satisfying to be able to do a few batches that are just from our garden.  I love strawberry freezer jam the best because you can use minimal sugar and the freezer jam keeps more of the fresh strawberry flavor. It's like a eating a little burst of summer in the middle of the winter. Flippin' awesome.


We also just started harvesting the first raspberries.  OMG, is there anything better than the first raspberries of the season???  Usually we just eat these fresh, but I put in a whole bunch more raspberries last year and so will need to put some up somehow...especially since we'll be harvesting raspberries into October.  Made some raspberry muffins yesterday, may try some raspberry sauce, some white chocolate raspberry bark, some raspberry chipotle sauce, and will also just freeze some straight up.  Any other great raspberry suggestions?  I'm going to have a lot.

We are knee-deep in cherries from our trees right now. I have to figure out what to do with them before they go bad. I don't much care for cooked cherries (so canning them is out) but love the fresh ones. I think we are going to freeze them raw.  Just wash them, pit them, put them on some parchment paper on a cookie tray and stick them in the freezer to freeze individually, and then bag them for later in the year.  I've heard that eating fresh-frozen cherries (no sugar, no additives) right out of the freezer is a real treat.  I'll let you know!

I have lots of plums starting to ripen, and many apples have set, so I'm looking forward to canning some plum chutney and applesauce later in the summer.  Looks like we'll have a few fresh pears too. However, my pluots (mix of an apricot and a plum) are total duds so far.  Maybe next year.


We did finally get some other stuff planted.  I was so late that I mostly used starts from the store, but that's okay; I'm not a gardening snob.  I have broccoli that's almost ready; the head has gotten a lot bigger than when I took the above picture.  We love fresh broccoli, which is good because we'll be having a lot in the next few weeks before we get slammed by hot weather.

I planted eggplant for the first time this year.  I'm not a big eggplant fan, but thought we'd give it a try. If all else fails, my MIL will eat them. Also put in a zillion tomatoes (for my special homemade spaghetti sauce, yummm), potatoes, pumpkins, green beans, swiss chard, zucchini, and cukes.

As some of you know, I have some knee issues from a bad car accident a few years ago.  This is why I mostly garden in raised beds.  But of course, raised beds are not cheap to build.  So this year, I'm contemplating trying straw bale gardening to expand my raised beds inexpensively.

Image from WSU Master Garden blog, wsumgtc.wordpress.com 

You condition a straw bale, then plant certain types of garden plants in the straw bales, like pumpkins or cukes or tomatoes (with staking).  It's raised bed gardening on the cheap. Then you use the decomposing straw left over for your potato beds next year, or put it in your compost pile. It's late to start this process, but what the heck.  I'm going to give it a shot anyhow.

I'm also looking at creating some sort of adapted portable cold frame/hoop house for my garden. I want to be able to cover the tomatoes to extend their season in the fall, and I want to be able to grow some cold-weather crops in the winter but be able to protect them from the very coldest weather.  So we'll be experimenting with that this summer.  Updates next fall.

So that's what's up with me right now.  I'm trying to get the kids' summer schedule organized (one's in Alaska with Scouts right now), I'm trying to get the garden established and weeded, I'm trying to start canning, and I've got to get my office cleaned before the cameras from the Hoarding shows arrive.  Oh yeah, and work on some writing projects.

What are you up to this summer? Got any big plans? If you garden, tell me what's going in in your garden!  Anybody got any great recipes for raspberries?

Sunday, June 17, 2012

Induction of Labor: An Incredibly Common Intervention Today


Here is a big, major recent study from the NIH that shows just how pervasive induction of labor is in U.S. society today and how it influences cesarean rates.

This study covered 19 hospitals across the U.S. over the space of a number of years.  It shows that nearly half of all first-time mothers are having their labors induced these days, and almost a third of those who have children before (multips).

Of those who are induced, a third of first-time mothers and nearly half of multips had an "elective" induction or "no recorded indication for induction" at term.  In other words, most of the time, these inductions are not being done for legitimate medical reasons like high blood pressure or serious concerns about the baby's well-being; instead, they're largely being done for convenience.

Yes, some moms ask for induction because they get tired of being pregnant, so some of this is being driven by consumers.  But it's also being strongly driven by many OBs who want to practice "daylight obstetrics" ─ induce in the early morning (or start the night before), break their water at noon, and be home in time for dinner.  Many start mentioning induction early in the pregnancy, planting the idea, so that when the end of pregnancy comes and women are uncomfortable, they are primed and ready to agree to an induction before it's really needed.

The question is whether nearly half of women should be induced, and what kind of risks are being imposed by this strong drive for induction of labor.

It also shows that inducing first-time moms presents a particularly high risk for cesarean, that cesareans are often done too early ("failure to wait"), and that inducing on an unripe cervix (low Bishop's Score) also often leads to cesareans.

[These are particularly relevant points for "obese" women, as I've pointed out before.]

All these have strong implications for lowering the national cesarean rate, as the authors note in their conclusion.  But are most care providers listening?  As I've said previously:
The $64,000 question is ─ will the publication of this study make any difference? Will hospitals change their policies and induce less women? Will doctors wait longer before resorting to cesareans? Will doctors and hospital administrators reverse their formal and informal VBAC bans? Will everyone involved make a concerted effort to reduce the cesarean rate ─ or will it just continue to be business as usual? 
It's positive that the questions are being asked and dialogue is being opened ─ but I am not holding my breath. Perhaps this is the beginning of a reversal of the pendulum, but the momentum is so strong towards inductions and cesareans right now that it's going to take a mighty counterforce indeed to really reverse things.

It's up to us to be part of that counterforce for change.


Am J Obstet Gynecol. 2012 Mar 23. Induction of labor in a contemporary obstetric cohort. Laughon SK, Zhang J, Grewal J, Sundaram R, Beaver J, Reddy UM.  PMID: 22520652

Source: Eunice Kennedy Shriver National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, National Institutes of Health, Bethesda, MD.
OBJECTIVE: We sought to describe details of labor induction, including precursors and methods, and associated vaginal delivery rates. 
STUDY DESIGN: This was a retrospective cohort study of 208,695 electronic medical records from 19 hospitals across the United States, 2002 through 2008. 
RESULTS: Induction occurred in 42.9% of nulliparas and 31.8% of multiparas and elective or no recorded indication for induction at term occurred in 35.5% and 44.1%, respectively. Elective induction at term in multiparas was highly successful (vaginal delivery 97%) compared to nulliparas (76.2%). For all precursors, cesarean delivery was more common in nulliparas in the latent compared to active phase of labor. Regardless of method, vaginal delivery rates were higher with a ripe vs unripe cervix, particularly for multiparas (86.6-100%). 
CONCLUSION: Induction of labor was a common obstetric intervention. Selecting appropriate candidates and waiting longer for labor to progress into the active phase would make an impact on decreasing the national cesarean delivery rate.

Tuesday, June 12, 2012

Pregnancy After WLS: The Risk for Internal Hernia

Image from Greenstein and O'Rourke,
Am J Surg, 2011
One of the risks that tends to be de-emphasized to women considering Gastric Bypass (GB) surgery is the risk of internal hernia, especially one that occurs during pregnancy.

What is an internal hernia?  Here is one definition:
An internal hernia is defined as a protrusion of intestine through a defect within the peritoneal cavity, as opposed to an external (or incisional) hernia that protrudes through all layers of the abdominal wall. Internal hernias almost always occur through iatrogenic defects created surgically.
The consequences of developing an internal hernia can include Small Bowel Obstruction (SBO), lack of adequate blood supply to the intestine and resulting necrotic tissue, gangrene, and a need for bowel resection.  In extreme cases, it can lead to death.

Granted, the risk for internal hernia is not a big risk, although it's difficult to pin down exactly what the risk really is.  One study found a 3.1% incidence of internal hernia after GB in a series of 2000 patients, while a different study found a 4.5% rate in a series of 1000 patients.  Another study found a higher rate of 6.9%.  A meta-analysis of 26 studies found an incidence of 2.5%, with a mortality rate of 1.1%.

However, these are internal hernia rates in the general GB population; the risk may be higher in pregnant women because pregnancy shifts the internal organs around and increases intra-abdominal pressure:
The incidence of internal hernia after [Laproscopic Gastric Bypass] is between 0.2 and 8.6 percent based on multiple studies...The particular case of pregnancy— with the mass effect of an enlarging uterus—may predispose to this condition...Due to the increasing scope of this problem and its potentially devastating consequences, surgeons should have a high clinical suspicion for internal hernia after LGBP.
Of course, it's important to remember that most women who have a Gastric Bypass and then a pregnancy afterwards will not experience an internal hernia.

However, there are some women who develop a hernia during pregnancy after Gastric Bypass, and it can be a very serious issue.  Women and babies have died from this complication (see case reports below). Therefore, it's important to raise awareness about this possible risk.

Any time a pregnant woman with a history of Gastric Bypass experiences significant abdominal pain, this must be taken very seriously.  

Physicians with experience both in WLS (Weight Loss Surgery), pregnancy, and intestinal issues should be consulted. Oftentimes, E.R. or family practice doctors miss internal hernias, CT scans are not always definitive, and as a result, there are a number of scary "near-miss" stories out there.  Most authorities agree that exploratory surgery is usually warranted, just in case, since a delayed or missed diagnosis is not unusual and can be deadly.

One of my concerns is whether or not this risk is adequately explained to women before they have WLS.  WLS is being actively marketed to fat women as a way to make childbearing "safer," yet are they really being told enough about this possible complication of pregnancy after GB?

And if they choose to go ahead, have the surgery, and then have a pregnancy, have they been sufficiently alerted to watch for abdominal pain and to seek help immediately if it occurs?

On a more cynical note, isn't it interesting that these cases are being recounted as case reports in the medical literature, but yet you rarely see them listed in the studies on pregnancy after WLS?  Granted, this complication is not so routine you'd see a lot of cases of it, but for every case report that is published, there are probably a number more that are not being written up.

Why isn't there more attention to this complication in the pregnancy-after-WLS literature? Given at least a 2-3% incidence of internal hernias after WLS in the general population and the number and seriousness of pregnancy-related case reports in the literature, you'd expect to see some of these documented in the large studies on pregnancy after WLS.  And yet, you almost never do.

Hmmmmmm.


References

*Note: Additional case reports can be found on Pubmed but were not listed here because they did not have an abstract available for review.

Case Reports on Internal Hernias During Pregnancy After GB

Acta Obstet Gynecol Scand. 2012 Apr 24. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0412.2012.01421.x. Pregnant woman with fatal complication after laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass. Renault K, et al.    PMID: 22524680
...We report a 22 year old woman, who had previously undergone uncomplicated laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass. She was admitted with severe abdominal pain at 35 weeks of gestation. A cesarean section with delivery of a healthy baby in combination with an exploratory laparotomy was performed. Internal herniation was suspected, but not identified during surgery. Three days later she died of a severely gangrenous small bowel secondary to internal herniation. This fatal case illustrates a potential complication and difficulties in the managment of pregnant women who have undergone Roux-en-Y gastric bypass. In these women observation and investigations based on multidisciplinary approach is vital if abdominal pain develops, with involvement of intestinal surgeons experienced in bariatric surgery as well as radiologists with specific knowledge of relevant imaging procedures.
Am Surg. 2005 Mar;71(3):231-4. Small bowel ischemia after Roux-en-Y gastric bypass complicated by pregnancy: a case report. Charles A, et al.   PMID: 15869139
...This case report involves a 23-year-old female at 25 weeks gestation with a 1-day history of diffuse abdominal pain and vomiting. She had a RYGB with a 15 cc micropouch 6 months prior to the commencement of this pregnancy. All radiologic investigations were normal. Esophagogastroscopy was performed revealing an ischemic Roux limb of the gastric bypass. At laparotomy, an internal hernia involving the afferent limb was identified at the site of the Roux anastomosis compromising portions of both the afferent and Roux limbs. Nonviable portions of both the afferent and Roux limbs were resected. Gastrointestinal continuity was achieved by fashioning a gastro-gastrostomy and a jejuno-jejunostomy, thus reversing the original gastric bypass procedure. The immediate postoperative period was complicated by fetal demise. With the increase in bariatric surgery, small bowel ischemia after Roux-en-Y gastric bypass will most likely become more prevalent, particularly in women of childbearing age.
N Engl J Med. 2004 Aug 12;351(7):721-2. Maternal and fetal deaths after gastric bypass surgery for morbid obesity. Moore KA, Ouyang DW, Whang EE. PMID: 15306679  Full text available here.
[Letter to the NEJM, discussing a case report of internal hernia and complications in a woman at 31 weeks' gestation, 18 months after a gastric bypass. Both mother and fetus died.]
Surg Obes Relat Dis. 2009 May-Jun;5(3):378-80. Epub 2008 Sep 9. Internal hernia after gastric bypass surgery during middle trimester pregnancy resulting in fetal loss: risk of internal hernia never ends. Efthimiou E, Stein L, Court O, Christou N. PMID: 19026598
[No abstract available for this case report, but the title tells us the fetus died.]
Obstet Gynecol. 2005 May;105(5 Pt 2):1195-8. Pregnancy after gastric bypass surgery and internal hernia formation. Kakarla N, et al.  PMID: 15863579
BACKGROUND: Gastric bypass is a surgical procedure that is increasingly performed in the United States to treat morbid obesity. Because of the changes associated with pregnancy, women with a history of gastric bypass surgery may be at an increased risk of gastrointestinal complications during the antepartum period, as demonstrated by these cases. CASES: The first patient presented at 12 weeks of gestation with abdominal pain. Computed tomography scan revealed rotation of the small bowel mesentery. In the operating room, a Petersen's internal hernia was observed. The second patient presented at 34 weeks of gestation with epigastric pain, nausea, and vomiting. An abdominal computed tomography scan suggested distention of the biliopancreatic limb, duodenum, and bypassed stomach. She underwent exploratory laparotomy with repair of an internal (mesenteric loop) hernia. CONCLUSION: As obstetricians, we should be aware of the potential for internal hernias in pregnant patients who have undergone bariatric surgery.
Obes Surg. 2010 Dec;20(12):1740-2. Epub 2009 Mar 25. Late intestinal obstruction due to an intestinal volvulus in a pregnant patient with a previous Roux-en-Y gastric bypass. Gazzalle A, et al.  PMID: 19319613 
This is a case of a 33 weeks pregnant woman, presented 2 years after laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass, with abdominal pain for 2 days. A laparoscopic cholecystectomy was performed 1 day earlier in another hospital, without improving the pain. She presented at our hospital with acute abdominal pain and clinical signs of intestinal obstruction, undergoing an exploratory laparotomy that revealed a volvulus and necrosis of the jejunum from the gastroenteroanastomosis through the lateral enteroenterostomy, which was resected with the reconstruction of the Roux-en-Y limb performed at the same operation. Patient and neonate presented with improvement after surgery and the patient was discharged on postoperative day 15. Internal hernias after bariatric surgery have been reported as the cause of acute abdomen problems during pregnancy, which may progress to necrosis and perforation. The delay of surgical intervention could have brought a tragic outcome for mother and neonate.
Obes Surg. 2010 Dec;20(12):1737-9. Epub 2009 Jan 28. Small-bowel volvulus in late pregnancy due to internal hernia after laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass. Naef M, Mouton WG, Wagner HE.   PMID: 19184255
Internal hernias are a specific cause of acute abdominal pain and are a well-known complication after laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass for morbid obesity. Although internal hernias are a rare cause of intestinal obstruction, they may evolve towards serious complications, such as extensive bowel ischemia and gangrene, with the need for bowel resection and sometimes for a challenging reconstruction of intestinal continuity. The antecolic position of the Roux limb is associated with a decrease in the incidence of small-bowel obstruction and internal hernias. The best prevention of the formation of these hernias is probably by closure of potential mesenteric defects at the initial operation with a non-absorbable running suture. We present a patient in late pregnancy with a small-bowel volvulus following laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass for morbid obesity and discuss the available literature. For a favorable obstetric and neonatal outcome, it is crucial not to delay surgical exploration and an emergency operation usually is mandatory.
Obes Surg. 2009 Jul;19(7):944-50. Epub 2008 Oct 2. Small bowel obstruction and internal hernias during pregnancy after gastric bypass surgery. Torres-Villalobos GM, et al.   PMID: 18830790
Small bowel obstruction (SBO) is a recognized complication of Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGB) surgery. Internal hernia (IH) a potential problem associated with RYGB, can have severe consequences if not diagnosed. We present two cases of SBO due to IH during pregnancy after laparoscopic RYGB (LRYGB). Both patients underwent an antecolic, antegastric LRYGB...IH should always be ruled out in pregnant patients with previous RYGB and abdominal pain. Prompt surgical intervention is mandatory for a good outcome.
Taiwan J Obstet Gynecol. 2007 Sep;46(3):267-71. Strangulation of upper jejunum in subsequent pregnancy following gastric bypass surgery. Wang CB, et al.  PMID: 17962108
...CASE REPORT: After a Roux-en-Y gastric bypass surgery, a 32-year-old woman had unrelenting epigastria for one week at 36 weeks' gestation. An emergency cesarean delivery, followed by laparotomy, was performed. A female neonate was delivered with Apgar scores of 8 and 9 at 1 and 5 minutes, respectively. Strangulation and gangrene of the upper jejunum caused by a fibrous band at the site of the Roux anastomosis were revealed. Segmental resection of the nonviable bowel was performed. The patient experienced a smooth postoperative course. CONCLUSION: The awareness of internal hernias and small bowel strangulation should be addressed when unrelenting epigastric pain is present in women after Roux-en-Y gastric bypass surgery, during their first subsequent pregnancy.
Case Reports in Obstetrics and Gynecology. Volume 2011 (2011), Article ID 415795. doi:10.1155/2011/415795.  Abdominal Pain after Gastric Bypass: Labor, Uterine Rupture, or Obstruction and Internal Hernia. Cross, SN et al. PMID: 22567508 Full text available here.
...CASE: A 26-year-old G4P1112 status post-Roux-en-Y gastric bypass required multiple urgent antenatal evaluations due to frequent episodes of abdominal pain. At 35 + 4 weeks, she presented with severe abdominal pain; initial evaluation was negative for gastrointestinal pathology. The patient was found to be in preterm labor and underwent a repeat cesarean section. The postoperative course was complicated by bowel obstruction due to internal hernia resulting in an emergent laparotomy and a prolonged hospital course....
Obes Surg. 2006 Sep;16(9):1246-8. Internal hernia with Roux loop obstruction during pregnancy after gastric bypass surgery. Ahmed AR and O'Malley W.   PMID: 16989713
We report the rare case of a pregnant woman who had undergone Roux-en-Y gastric bypass 8 months previously, and now presented with subacute small bowel obstruction secondary to internal herniation of some of the proximal Roux limb into the lesser sac through the transverse mesocolon rent, which was widely spread apart. At laparoscopy, the hernia contents were reduced and the defect was repaired. The patient made a good recovery. Because of the changes associated with pregnancy, gastric bypass patients may be at an increased risk of internal herniation. It is particularly important not to delay surgical exploration, even in the absence of a positive finding on imaging, because delay may lead to potentially devastating bowel strangulation and sepsis culminating in loss of fetus and mother.
Hum Reprod Update. 2009 Mar-Apr;15(2):189-201. Epub 2009 Jan 8. Reproductive outcome after bariatric surgery: a critical review. Guelinckx I, Devlieger R, Vansant G.  PMID: 19136457
...METHODS: English-language articles were identified in a PUBMED search from 1982 to January 2008 using the keywords for pregnancy and bariatric surgery or gastric bypass or gastric banding. RESULTS: The few reported case-control and cohort studies clearly show improved fertility and a reduced risk in obstetrical complications, including gestational diabetes, macrosomia and hypertensive disorders of pregnancy, in women after operatively induced weight loss when compared with morbidly obesity women. The incidence of intrauterine growth restriction (IUGR) appears to be increased, however. No conclusions can be drawn concerning the risk for preterm labour and miscarriage, although these risks are probably increased compared with controls matched for body mass index. Operative complications are not uncommon with bariatric surgery and several cases have pointed to the increased risk for intestinal hernias and nutritional deficiencies in subsequent pregnancy. Deficiencies in iron, vitamin A, vitamin B(12), vitamin K, folate and calcium can result in both maternal complications, such as severe anaemia, and fetal complications, such as congenital abnormalities, IUGR and failure to thrive. CONCLUSIONS: Close supervision before, during and after pregnancy following bariatric surgery and nutrient supplementation adapted to the patient's individual requirements can help to prevent nutrition-related complications and improve maternal and fetal health, in this high-risk obstetric population.
Incidence of Internal Hernias After GB

Obes Surg. 2003 Jun;13(3):350-4. Internal hernias after laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass: incidence, treatment and prevention. Higa KD, Ho T, Boone KB.   PMID: 12841892
BACKGROUND: Laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (RYGBP) has been shown to be a safe and effective alternative to traditional "open" RYGBP. Although lack of postoperative adhesions is one advantage of minimally invasive surgery, this is also responsible for a higher incidence of internal hernias. These patients often present with intermittent abdominal pain or small bowel obstruction with completely normal contrast radiographs. METHODS: Data was obtained concurrently on 2,000 consecutive patients from February 1998 to October 2001 and analyzed retrospectively...RESULTS: 66 internal hernias occurred in 63 patients, an incidence of 3.1%...20% of patients had normal preoperative small bowel series and/or CT scans..There was 1 death associated with complications of the internal hernia. The negative exploration rate was 2%. CONCLUSION: Internal hernias are more common following laparoscopic RYGBP than "open" RYGBP. Contrast radiographs alone are unreliable in ruling out this diagnosis. Early intervention is crucial; most repairs can be performed laparoscopically. This diagnosis should be entertained in all patients with unexplained abdominal pain following laparoscopic RYGBP. Meticulous closure of all potential internal hernia sites is essential to limit this potentially lethal complication.
Obes Surg. 2006 Oct;16(10):1265-71. Internal hernia after laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass for morbid obesity. Iannelli A, Facchiano E, Gugenheim J.   PMID: 17059733
BACKGROUND: Laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (LRYGBP) is associated with a relatively high incidence of internal hernias (IH) when compared to the open operation. METHODS: A search in PubMed MEDLINE from January 1994 through January 2006 was performed (keywords: obesity, laparoscopy, gastric bypass and internal hernia). RESULTS: 26 studies with a total of 11,918 patients were considered. 300 cases of IH occurred (rate 2.51%)...Mortality was 1.17%. CONCLUSIONS: IH after LRYGBP has an incidence of 2.51%. Closure of mesenteric defects with non-absorbable running suture and antecolic Roux limb are recommended. Surgical exploration for suspicion of IH after LRYGBP should be first done by laparoscopy.
Obes Surg. 2011 Dec;21(12):1822-7. Small bowel obstruction after antecolic antegastric laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass without division of small bowel mesentery: a single-centre, 7-year review. Abasbassi M, et al.   PMID: 21656166
Reported incidence of small bowel obstruction (SBO) after laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass varies between 1.5% and 3.5%. It has been suggested that the antecolic antegastric laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass (AA-LRYGB) is associated with a low incidence of internal herniation (IH). Therefore we routinely did not close mesenteric defects. The records of 652 consecutive patients undergoing primary AA-LRYGB from January 2003 to December 2009 in a single institution were retrospectively reviewed...Of the 652 patients, 63 (9.6%) developed SBO. The majority (6.9%, 45 patients) had a SBO due to IH...Twenty-nine out of 63 cases had negative computed tomography (CT) findings and IH was diagnosed on CT in only 33% (14/45) of patients with IH. All patients underwent diagnostic laparoscopy. No bowel resections had to be performed. In contrast to previous reports, a high incidence of SBO with a high rate of IH at the JJ site was found in our series. Accuracy of CT is low and diagnostic laparoscopy is mandatory when SBO is suspected. Since 2010 we have started closing the JJ site, and data on SBO are collected prospectively. We believe that closing of the mesenteric defects is a mandatory step, even in an AA-LRYGB.
Am J Surg. 2004 Dec;188(6):796-800. Internal hernias after laparoscopic Roux-en-Y gastric bypass. Garza E Jr, et al.   PMID: 15619502
...METHODS: A retrospective review of 1,000 retrocolic Lap-RYGB was performed to identify those who developed postoperative internal hernias. Clinical symptoms, radiologic characteristics, and operative outcomes were analyzed to determine clinical and radiologic diagnostic accuracy (including computed tomography [CT] scan and upper gastrointestinal imaging). Subsequent independent review was performed to match operative intervention with radiologic imaging and interpretation. Operative outcomes, including the hernia closure technique, hospital length of stay, and mortality were obtained. RESULTS: Of 1,000 Lap-RYGB procedures, 45 internal hernias were identified (4.5%) in 43 patients...The most common clinical symptoms included intermittent, postprandial abdominal pain, and/or nausea vomiting (86%), although 20% had no abdominal tenderness. Initial radiologic imaging studies were diagnostic in 64%, although subsequent review of all imaging studies showed diagnostic abnormalities in 97%...The mean time to intervention for an internal hernia repair was 225 days (range 2 to 490), whereas hospital length of stay was 1.2 days (range 1 to 4). No deaths were noted. CONCLUSIONS: Internal hernias after retrocolic lap-RYGB are associated with vague abdominal complaints and limited radiologic imaging results. A high index of clinical suspicion should be used in this patient population, and surgeon review of radiology imaging studies should be performed. Prompt surgical intervention is successful and can commonly be performed laparoscopically.

Monday, June 4, 2012

Do You Know You're Overweight?

Another gem from My OB Said What?!?

I keep trying to swear off repeating these here on my blog, but they just make too many of my points for me to resist, plus it's just important to fully document incidents like this.  So here's another one:
“Oh my goodness! Do you know you’re overweight? Have you tried to diet and exercise??"
– OB immediately upon entering the room and meeting a mother for the first time. The mother was in the process of miscarrying a 16 week pregnancy
I'm not even going to start commenting on this one, it's so wrong on so many levels. Urgh.

Commenters, go for it.  What do you want to say to this doctor?

Tuesday, May 29, 2012

Plea for Help in the U.K.


This comment was left on a recent post on this blog.  It is a plea for help from a pregnant women in the U.K.

I am only going to address one aspect of her concerns, the one I find most disturbing; I hope others will step up and address some of the rest of her concerns.
Please please please, can someone help me. I am 10 weeks pregnant and currently have a BMI of 35.  
Firstly, I have suffered with severe sickness since 5 weeks and doctor said it was ok as I 'could do with losing some weight' and refused to give me medications, and now I have had my first midwife appointment today and was told that more than 50 percent of maternal deaths in pregnancy and childbirth are obese mothers and that I will have to have special monitoring and won't be allowed to have a natural birth at the birth centre and will have to be under consultant care and be constantly monitored throughout labour (meaning no water birth, no moving around, no getting into positive positions to birth).  
I am so scared and disappointed, I feel like I am an unfit mother already and feel that the drs think I do not care about the health of my unborn baby. Now I know that this will not go down well with some people but I am considering a termination so that I can lose more weight before carrying a child (I have currently lost 70 pounds). 
I came across this blog and I am aware that you are based in the US and I am in the UK so some things are different...for instance I can't actually choose a provider and am stuck with who I have :(...but please, any advice would be so appreciated. Both myself and my partner are concerned and do not know what to do. 
There are so many things to cover here, it's hard to know where to start.  Please comfort and reassure this woman that she CAN do this.  She needs to hear from many people, not just me.  Please leave some encouraging comments at the end of this post.*

In the meantime, here is my response.  First, dear Reader, please don't terminate this pregnancy over these scare tactics or your fears.  Chances are that everything will be okay.  Many MANY women with a BMI well over 35 have had healthy pregnancies and babies.  My BMI is 48, far over yours, and I had 4 healthy pregnancies and babies, and am none the worse for wear for it. I know so many women your size and far larger who have had healthy happy babies.  You can read some of their birth stories here and here.

No, no one can promise you with 100% certainty that you and this baby will be fine, but the odds are certainly in your favor, "obese" or not. Most obese women have healthy babies; some do have complications like GD or high blood pressure, but even then, most of the time, these conditions are able to be treated and everyone is still fine.  So don't panic over the scare tactics they are giving you.

To be fair, the doctors and midwives are trying to do what they think is their job, to apprise you of possible risks associated with "obesity" and pregnancy, but the problem is that they have gone so far overboard in stating these that they are frightening women unduly, making them think that almost no women of size have healthy pregnancies or babies, when in fact, most do.

In some cases, care providers lay on the scare tactics so strongly that they bully women into weight loss surgery, risky diets, over-intervention, and even terminating the pregnancy.  That is NOT good health care, that's medical bullying. And for God's sake, this poor woman has already lost 70 lbs., but despite the fact that she followed typical medical advice to lower her BMI before pregnancy, she is still being punished and scared half to death.  Where is the justice in that?

Yes, there are some risks associated with pregnancy in obese women, but NO, the answer is not in scaring women into terminating an established pregnancy until they reach a "normal" BMI.

Shame on these providers for laying the scare tactics on so strongly that someone would even consider terminating a pregnancy simply because of their weight.

Yes, among those rare women who have died during pregnancy or birth, obese women are overrepresented somewhat.  That does NOT mean that 50% of obese women who are pregnant die during pregnancy─that's a misunderstanding of what the care providers were trying to say. Death is an extremely rare occurrence for childbearing women in the developed world, and although very high BMI women are somewhat overrepresented in that group, the actual numerical risk of it happening to any one obese woman is quite low.

And the reason why fat women do die during pregnancy or birth boils down to three main causes, some of which is preventable:
  • Complications from general anesthesia during a cesarean
  • Complications from hypertensive disorders (high blood pressure and resulting disorders) in pregnancy
  • Blood clots (usually in conjunction with cesareans)
So to lower the risk for these problems, consider the following:
  • Don't let them push you into a cesarean you don't need. If a cesarean is required at some point, make sure they are prepared to use an epidural or spinal block instead of general anesthesia. Have an anesthesia consult ahead of time to be sure they have the equipment needed on hand if it were needed
  • Make sure you are monitoring your blood pressure carefully (you can get a home BP monitor if your readings are questionable at all), make sure they use the correct-sized BP cuff so that that readings are accurate, and get regular exercise and have great nutrition to lower your risk for developing gestational diabetes or blood pressure issues 
  • Regular exercise also lowers the risk for a blood clot during pregnancy; for certain people, low-dose aspirin therapy (only under the supervision of a care provider) is sometimes advised. If you have a cesarean, discuss with your provider the use (and proper dosage) of blood thinners, and be sure to move your legs around and walk as early as you can tolerate after the surgery. There are also special wraps and cuffs that can help reduce your chances of a blood clot after a cesarean; make sure to request these if you have a cesarean, and note any increase in shortness-of-breath to your providers
If this woman were in the U.S., I'd tell her to change care providers ASAP because it's difficult to overcome a really deep-set provider bias about obesity in just a few months, and it often influences the care a high-BMI mother receives.  However, I'm not sure what your options are for alternatives in the U.K.

There are, of course, private midwives that you could hire from outside the NHS system, and it seems to me like this would be well worth the money to do if you can manage it.  I bet we could find a private midwife who would take you on as a client and who would work with you to find a way to make it financially feasible.  I know there have been women of size who have had great out-of-hospital births in the U.K. with private midwives.

But if that's absolutely not an option, then you will have to work within the system, and the way to do that is to push back against the care providers who are giving you a hard time.  I'm hoping some of my U.K. readers will pop in and leave some suggestions about how to do that.

At the very least, one of the best things you can do is to find a Pregnancy Buddy, an advocate familiar with size-friendly care practices, who will come with you to appointments and help you speak up for quality care and question fat-phobic practices.  A doula who really "gets" weight stigma and has a Health At Every Size approach could be a great help for you in advocating for more size-friendly care.

Best wishes to you, and I sincerely hope you will not let your fears (and the scare tactics of the providers) keep you from enjoying this pregnancy and this baby.  Be as healthy as you can in your habits without obsessing over them, find a Pregnancy Buddy or Size-Friendly Doula to help you speak up for yourself, and don't be afraid to push back against the bias of your providers and even report them to their superiors if necessary.

Pregnancy is one of the best times to learn how to advocate for yourself, your baby, and your needs (whatever size you are), and you deserve to have loving, respectful care, regardless of your BMI or whether you lose enough weight to fit into their narrow definition of "normal".  Start demanding that care now, and don't settle for second-best.  You and your baby deserve no less.


*Please keep your comments civil and kind and aimed towards helping this woman's specific situation or about commenting on weight-biased scare tactics, rather than about pushing a particular point of view on abortion. This is not a forum for abortion debates, and I will be vetting comments before I publish them.  Please stay kind and helpful in your words.  Thank you.

Wednesday, May 23, 2012

A 50-75% Chance of "Needing" a Cesarean?

Another gem from My OB Said What?!?
“You Have A 50-75% Chance Of Needing A Cesarean Section Next Time…” 
“You have a 50-75% chance of needing a cesarean section next time, because you are short and overweight.” 
– Perinatologist to mother during preconception meeting...after the mother had already had a successful vaginal birth
This is how many doctors perceive us because of our size (both height and weight).  They simply conclude that there is virtually no way for us to birth a baby vaginally, never considering that their own biases around size and their common interventions with short/fat women (inducing early, having a low threshold for surgery) influences these outcomes.

The kicker here is that this woman has already had a vaginal birth, and despite difficult conditions too.  Once you've had a vaginal birth, your chances of having another is greatly increased....yet in his eyes, this doesn't really count at all if you are fat and short.

Older women get the same kind of grief.  And so do VBAC moms.  And it's all nonsense, frankly.

Yes, there is some research showing higher c-section rates in fat women, older women, short women, blah blah blah.  But RARELY do they consider whether it's really that "risk factor" or instead the way they manage the labors of these women and the fear they have around these risk factors that increases the cesarean rate more than the risk factor itself.

In obstetric research,the problem is always assumed to be with the woman.  Not the care provider's management or perceptions of risk, but somehow the fault of the woman herself (or her obesity, or her age, or her shortness, yadda yadda). I almost never see studies raise the question of provider perception or management at all.

It's time for care providers to recognize that their management of women is an integral part of high c-section rates in certain groups...not the only factor, but a much stronger factor than is generally acknowledged.

I have a dear online friend who is currently having a difficult time finding a provider who will support her for a VBAC.  This despite the fact that she has already had TWO VBACs.  It doesn't matter; they just see that she's fat and had a prior cesarean.

This is really pissing me off. Especially since I'm all of the above.  I'm short, "morbidly obese", old, and a VBAC mom.  Most doctors would look at me and tell me I had NO chance of having a vaginal birth because of these four risk factors....and yet I did.  Twice.

Risk factors are not absolute sentences. MOST women, even with risk factors, can birth just fine, if they can just get care providers to "let" them have an adequate chance at it.

It's long past time for care providers (and researchers) to recognize that the way providers manage and perceive women with risk factors has a lot to do with the outcomes associated with them.




Saturday, May 19, 2012

Birth Story Video: Jennifer's Waterbirth

Here is the birth story and wedding/birth video of a plus-sized mama I thought readers might enjoy.  It's not a short video (about 6 minutes) but it's well worth watching!

Below is the mother's story (which includes 4 previous miscarriages) and what she wants other women of size to know about pregnancy and birth.
My name is Jennifer. I live in southern Oregon and am a midwife apprentice. I have attended many births and have caught 4 babies under supervision. Of the many births I have attended, a good handful have been to plus-size mommas. 
Two off the top of my head were between 300-400 lbs. Both mommas had very healthy uneventful pregnancies and wonderful easy labors, and both mommas delivered in water at home. Water is great for plus-size mommas because it allows you to move more easily into different positions.  
I myself am a plus size momma. I am 5'6" and started my pregnancy at 232 lbs., about size 18. I finished my pregnancy at 276. I know doctors like to tell you to only gain 15 lbs. if you're "obese" but that's one of many reasons I didn't choose a doctor! I am a firm believer that as long as you gain your weight on healthy food then you gain what you need, and restricting food can cause issues in pregnancy. Nutrition is key in pregnancy, especially protein!   
I had a wonderful very healthy pregnancy with a midwife, and gave birth to a beautiful baby at home on Christmas eve.  A baby girl,  9 lbs. 12 ounces, 20.5 inches. 
Being plus size and pregnant is a challenge but I think it's because we set up obstacles in our minds. Will I look pregnant, how much weight will I gain, will I be able to handle the physical demands of labor, will I be bullied into tests and procedures because I'm overweight? 
Remember that you are a strong, intelligent, beautiful woman who can birth a healthy baby, regardless of your weight. If you aren't comfortable being your own advocate, then hire a doula! Get educated, know your options, and don't forget to celebrate this beautiful rite of passage!

Tuesday, May 8, 2012

Fetal Over-testing in the Last Trimester Because of Fat?

This is a comment that was left on my blog recently, in the "Will I Feel My Baby Move If I'm Fat?" post. It's a new twist on the old wives' tale (more like old OB's tale) that fat women supposedly have too much abdominal fat to feel their babies move in pregnancy.
"I am 29 weeks today and a nurse practitioner I saw last week told me I have to have nonstress tests 2X week because of my weight. She claims I won't feel the baby's movements so they need to monitor them. Has anyone else been told this? I'm a very busy woman and incredibly stressed about having to go to the hospital 2X week, plus she says I have to do an ultrasound monthly, plus do my weekly doctors appts. Advice would be great because I don't want to do this but I feel I have to so the baby will be monitored appropriately."
Seriously?  A non-stress test 2x per week from 29 weeks on because a fat woman supposedly won't feel her baby's movements? 

This is pure and unadulterated bullsh*t.  Women of size feel their babies move perfectly well, thank you. There's no fat between the baby and the inside of the uterus; we feel every roll and punch and kick.

Nearly every woman of size I've ever spoken to has said that yes, they feel their babies move just fine; I certainly did. Yet this myth about fat "preventing" women from feeling their babies still persists. That it persists among the public is disappointing but attributable to ignorance; that it persists among some healthcare providers is nothing short of appalling.

But the second question here is whether fat women are so incredibly high-risk from "obesity" alone that we have to be monitored 2x/week from the middle of the second trimester on?  Yet other women only start monitoring around week 41? Oh puleeeze.

Even most diabetics aren't monitored this aggressively. Insulin-dependent diabetics usually start fetal surveillance around 32 weeks. For gestational diabetics not on insulin, the need for fetal surveillance is widely debated; if used at all, it is usually introduced around the end of pregnancy.  Only diabetics with severe comorbid complications like vascular issues or kidney disease usually benefit from this kind of aggressive monitoring starting in the late second trimester. Are the providers in the above scenario seriously comparing the risk of an uncomplicated pregnancy in an obese woman to that of a brittle type 1 insulin-dependent diabetic with pre-existing kidney damage?

The only time I can see this kind of over-the-top monitoring being truly needed in a woman of size would be in someone who has experienced serious major poor outcomes in a previous pregnancy, or who is experiencing major complications in a current pregnancy (HELLP syndrome, hypertensive disorders, prior stillbirth, brittle or uncontrolled diabetes, diabetes with comorbidities, IUGR, or various other serious complications). The commenter didn't mention any such comorbidities.

Now, the argument some docs make for increased fetal surveillance in "obese" women is that some studies have shown an increase in the risk for stillbirth in these women.  However, not all studies have shown an increase in the risk of stillbirth in obese women. Moreover, there is no data to prove that aggressive monitoring in obese women lowers the risk for stillbirth.  

It is questionable whether obesity itself, without concurrent complications like HELLP or uncontrolled diabetes, necessitates this kind of frequent monitoring.  It is telling that most care providers do not require it. The American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists (ACOG) does not currently recommend increased antepartum surveillance in the last trimester for obese women.  Nor does the Society of Obstetricians and Gynaecologists of Canada (SOGC).  And research suggests that obese women don't have more poor results on non-stress tests.

Although there may be a somewhat higher risk for stillbirth in women of size, and although non-stress tests and biophysical profiles can sometimes help identify babies at high risk for stillbirth, these tests don't always help and come with downsides too. The rate of  false-positives is quite high, and often results in unnecessary interventions like early induction of labor or cesareans, and these also carry risks.

So while I can understand some providers wanting to offer this as an option to women of size (especially those who experience comorbid complications like hypertension disorders or restricted growth), I strongly question the value of its routine use in women of size with uncomplicated pregnancies. Furthermore, the testing schedule this woman has been put on is quite excessive (barring some complication we are not aware of).

Awareness of the possibility of complications in women of size is one thing, but clinicians must remember that over-testing brings its own risks and often becomes a self-fulfilling prophecy.

I've been through four pregnancies as a "morbidly obese" woman and I was never required to do this kind of monitoring. Nor do I know many other fat women who have been required to do this extreme amount of monitoring. And I can assure you that I most definitely felt my baby well enough to do kick counts by the end of pregnancy.  The idea that non-stress tests or biophysical profiles are required because fat women are too fat to adequately keep track of their baby's movements is ludicrous.

Commenter, unless you have some major complication we don't know about, you might want to think about running far and fast from this practice so you can find one that doesn't see you as such a ticking time bomb.  Pick a practice that knows that fetal surveillance testing has both pros and cons, that knows there is a high risk of false positives and over-intervention with these tests, and that is willing to discuss these pros and cons with you and let you make the final decision on their use instead of compelling you to follow an arbitrary schedule of testing virtually designed to find problems and intervene.

*How about you?  If you are a woman of size, have you been required to have such aggressive fetal surveillance from so early on?  What kind of fetal testing was recommended for you as a woman of size by your providers?

Tuesday, May 1, 2012

Supersized Women and Cesareans: A Tale of Two Cities

Although most care providers mean well when caring for high-BMI women, one consistent blind spot has been providers recognizing how the  high level of interventions used with many high-BMI women influence outcome.

In other words, are poor outcomes only due to "obesity" or do some poor outcomes reflect the interventive way that obese women are often managed in pregnancy and birth?

This is a particularly relevant question for the high cesarean rates found in "morbidly obese" women (BMI of 40 or more).  If a high-BMI woman is perceived as ultra high-risk, and is therefore subjected to increased rates of interventions (like inductions, early epidurals, and a lower threshold for surgery), does the resulting high cesarean rate really reflect problems with obesity itself, or with the way obese women are managed?

Here are two studies of cesarean rates in women of size that demonstrate that iatrogenic (provider-caused) influences can have a very strong effect on cesarean rates, and that a high cesarean rate in morbidly obese women is NOT just about the obesity itself.

These two studies examined cesarean rates in "super obese" women (BMI of 50 or more), one from Kentucky and one from the U.K.  The Kentucky study found a super-high c-section rate, and the U.K. study did not.

Yet the two studies basically were looking at very similar study groups, women with a BMI of 50 or more. If cesarean rates really are tightly tied to obesity and obesity alone, shouldn't the cesarean rates in these two studies be similar?

In the Kentucky study, women with a BMI over 50 had a whopping 56% cesarean rate. Compare that with the British study that found a 30% cesarean rate in women with a BMI over 50.

The Kentucky cesarean rate was nearly DOUBLE the rate of the British group, even though the size of the women was similar. 

This strongly suggests that management of labor around the pregnancies of supersized women differed and highly influenced the resulting cesarean rate, and that it's NOT just about a woman's size, but also her care provider's management.

We can't tell for sure from these particular studies why the cesarean rates in women of size in these two places are so different, but it's a good bet that it's NOT because the uteri of British women are that much more efficient than those of Kentucky women. No, the contrast in rates is much more likely to be due to differences in care, attitudes, and interventions.

A couple of strong possibilities spring to mind.

First, midwives are the most prevalent form of care provider for most women in the U.K., whereas most women in the USA get their care from OBs.  Research shows that on the whole, midwives tend to have lower cesarean rates, even when the risk profiles of patients are similar.  So perhaps the cesarean rate is lower because more of the "super obese" women in the U.K. had access to midwifery care.  If so, this is yet another reason to be alarmed about the move towards restricting fat women's access to lower-tech birthing alternatives and midwifery care.

Second, we don't know that much about the types of intervention, induction rates, and threshold for surgical intervention in each study.  My guess is that the Kentucky study had very high induction rates (which tends to lead to higher cesarean rates), a higher rate of interventions, and a lower threshold for doing a cesarean in labor.

I would love to see more research that focuses on why there can be such different outcomes in "morbidly obese" women.  We need to really shine a spotlight on differing management protocols and how they impact cesarean rates ─ and particularly so in women of size.

Interestingly, the Kentucky study notes that pitocin augmentation in labor led to lower cesarean rates in these women, although this difference did not rise to statistical significance.  They speculated, therefore, that "a qualitative or quantitative deficiency in the hormonal regulation of labor exists in the morbidly obese parturient."

This is a theory that is often bandied about in obstetric research (without any supporting proof, but often accepted as gospel anyhow). Yet if this were true, why were 70% of British women able to birth vaginally? It's far too easy and convenient to blame fat women's hormones instead of looking more closely at your own management practices instead.

It's time for doctors to stop scapegoating obesity alone for high cesarean rates in women of size, and long past time for them to start examining more closely how their own biases and high-intervention protocols negatively influence outcomes in this group.

This is not an emotionally comfortable thing to study, because care providers are human and no one wants to acknowledge that their own biases and management can affect outcome so strongly.  I understand that.

But if care providers are truly interested in improving outcomes in "obese" women, then this is the kind of work that MUST be done.  

The contrast between these studies shows that most very fat women CAN give birth vaginally....if caregivers would just stand aside and let them. It's time to take off the blinders and see how management protocols can  influence that.



References

Am J Perinatol.  2011 Jun 9. [Epub ahead of print] Extreme Morbid Obesity and Labor Outcome in Nulliparous Women at Term.  Garabedian MJ, Williams CM, Pearce CF, Lain KY, Hansen WF.  PMID: 21660900

Source: Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, University of Kentucky, Lexington, Kentucky.
We examined the prevalence of cesarean delivery (CD) among women with morbid obesity and extreme morbid obesity. Using Kentucky birth certificate data, a cross-sectional analysis of nulliparous singleton gestations at term was performed. We examined the prevalence of CD by body mass index (BMI; in kg/m (2)) using the National Institutes of Health/World Health Organization schema and a modified schema that separates extreme morbid obesity (BMI ≥50) from morbid obesity (BMI ≥40 to less than 50). Bivariate and multivariate analyses were performed. Multivariate modeling controlled for maternal age, estimated gestational age, birth weight, diabetes, and hypertensive disorders. Overall, 83,278 deliveries were analyzed.

CD was most common among women with a prepregnancy BMI ≥50 (56.1%, 95% confidence interval 50.9 to 61.4%). Extreme morbid obesity was most strongly associated with CD (adjusted odds ratio 4.99, 95% confidence interval 4.00 to 6.22).

Labor augmentation decreased the likelihood of CD among women with extreme morbid obesity, but this failed to reach statistical significance. We speculate a qualitative or quantitative deficiency in the hormonal regulation of labor exists in the morbidly obese parturient. More research is needed to better understand the influence of morbid obesity on labor.
BJOG. 2011 Mar;118(4):480-7. Planned vaginal delivery or planned caesarean delivery in women with extreme obesity. Homer CS, Kurinczuk JJ, Spark P, Brocklehurst P, Knight M.  PMID: 21244616

Source: National Perinatal Epidemiology Unit, University of Oxford, UK.
OBJECTIVE: To compare the outcomes of planned vaginal versus planned caesarean delivery in a cohort of extremely obese women (body mass index ≥ 50 kg/m(2)). 
DESIGN: A national cohort study using the UK Obstetric Surveillance System (UKOSS). 
SETTING: All hospitals with consultant-led maternity units in the UK. 
POPULATION: Five hundred and ninety-one extremely obese women delivering in the UK between September 2007 and August 2008. 
METHODS: Prospective cohort identification through UKOSS routine monthly mailings. 
MAIN OUTCOME MEASURES: Anaesthetic, postnatal and neonatal complication rates. 
RESULTS: After adjustment, there were no significant differences in anaesthetic, postnatal or neonatal complications between women with planned vaginal delivery and planned caesarean delivery, with the exception of shoulder dystocia (3% versus 0%, P = 0.019). There were no significant differences in any outcomes in the subgroup of women who had no identified medical or antenatal complications. 
CONCLUSIONS: This study does not provide evidence to support a routine policy of caesarean delivery for extremely obese women on the basis of concern about higher rates of delivery complications, but does support a policy of individualised decision-making on the mode of delivery based on a thorough assessment of potential risk factors for poor delivery outcomes.



Monday, April 23, 2012

First Cesareans and Risk for Fetal Death in Subsequent Pregnancies

International Cesarean Awareness
Network, www.ican-online.org
 
This recent study shows yet another reason to avoid cesareans whenever possible.

Remember that the absolute risk of this complication for any one mother is quite low, but the fact that the risk is increased at all is a good reason to be cautious about the overuse of cesareans on a population-wide basis.

If you would like to read a more complete summary of this study (and others like it which examined the same question), please read Henci Goer's analysis of the study over at Science & Sensibility.


J Midwifery Womens Health. 2012 Jan;57(1):12-7. doi: 10.1111/j.1542-2011.2011.00142.x. First birth cesarean and risk of antepartum fetal death in a subsequent pregnancy. Osborne C, Ecker JL, Gauvreau K, Lieberman E.  PMID: 22251907
Introduction: To examine the relationship between first birth by cesarean and antepartum fetal death in a subsequent pregnancy in a large, hospital-based population.  
Methods : Data for this retrospective cohort study were taken from a database of all women who gave birth at Brigham and Women's Hospital during 4 waves of data collection beginning in 1994 and ending in 2002. We calculated the risk of antepartum fetal death in the subsequent pregnancy for women whose first birth was by cesarean compared to women with a vaginal first birth. Survival analysis was used to examine the influence of gestational age at birth.  
Results: Of 10,996 women who met inclusion criteria, 22% (n = 2450) had first births by cesarean, and 78% (n = 8546) had vaginal first births. The risk of antepartum fetal death in the subsequent pregnancy for women whose first birth was by cesarean was significantly greater than the risk for women whose first birth was vaginal (odds ratio 2.6; 95% confidence interval, 1.1-6.2). The relationship between first birth cesarean and antepartum fetal death in a subsequent pregnancy differed by gestational age at birth, with no excess risk among women with a previous cesarean birth who gave birth before 34 weeks' gestation but with a substantially increased risk for women who gave birth at 34 or more weeks' gestation (unadjusted hazard ratio = 5.6; 95% confidence interval, 1.6-19.8). Hazard ratio estimates for the association remained significant in bivariate models when adjusted for maternal height, weight, age, hypertension, and diabetes.  
Discussion: In these data, first birth by cesarean was associated with an increased risk of antepartum fetal death in a subsequent pregnancy. Our findings suggest that antepartum fetal deaths in subsequent pregnancies might be prevented by avoiding primary cesarean birth.