Friday, December 24, 2010
Happy Holidays
May you have a wonderful holiday season. May you enjoy family time, whether that's with family of origin or family of choice. And may you have a wonderful new year.
Peace and blessings to us all!
*Painting by Renoir; image from Wikimedia.
Wednesday, December 22, 2010
Waterbirth Video of Plus-Sized Mom
A (plus-sized) reader of my blog sent me the link to the video of her recent waterbirth. This seems like the perfect complement to last week's post about a new waterbirth study, plus it's a lovely, cheery story for Christmas week.
Not only is this awesome because it's waterbirth─ the coolest thing ever! ─ but it's waterbirth in a woman of size, something some care providers and some facilities do not "permit." (Actually, women of size are the perfect candidates for waterbirth, since it can help us be more mobile in labor and pushing.)
But this mom didn't let rules against waterbirth in women of size stop her ─ she found a place and a provider that was amenable to waterbirth for her, regardless of size.
This was her fifth child. She had had vaginal births with all her prior children in the hospital, but with some significant interventions (forceps, big episiotomy, a near c-section with the fourth one because she wasn't progressing fast enough for them...even after 3 prior vaginal births!). She was determined to change things for the next baby.
She had a boy, 9 lbs. 12 ozs., 22.5 inches long, a size many doctors would freak out over (and some would mandate a c-section for) ─ but she had him naturally and easily with the mobility that the water offered.
Here are her words about her story (slightly edited):
*Reposted with permission from http://rubyslippersx3.blogspot.com/
Not only is this awesome because it's waterbirth─ the coolest thing ever! ─ but it's waterbirth in a woman of size, something some care providers and some facilities do not "permit." (Actually, women of size are the perfect candidates for waterbirth, since it can help us be more mobile in labor and pushing.)
But this mom didn't let rules against waterbirth in women of size stop her ─ she found a place and a provider that was amenable to waterbirth for her, regardless of size.
This was her fifth child. She had had vaginal births with all her prior children in the hospital, but with some significant interventions (forceps, big episiotomy, a near c-section with the fourth one because she wasn't progressing fast enough for them...even after 3 prior vaginal births!). She was determined to change things for the next baby.
She had a boy, 9 lbs. 12 ozs., 22.5 inches long, a size many doctors would freak out over (and some would mandate a c-section for) ─ but she had him naturally and easily with the mobility that the water offered.
Here are her words about her story (slightly edited):
I avoided seeking out a midwife for my previous births because of size issues, but I went for it and called tons of midwives, wearing my heart on my sleeve as I brought up the issue of weight. I found a wonderful midwife, had a healthy pregnancy and had my baby at home in the water.
I am still on cloud nine. It was one of the most amazing accomplishments of my life.
I want to help as many moms as possible develop the courage for the birth they want. Waterbirth, long sigh, was so wonderful. Compared to straps around my tummy that didn't fit, cutting into my skin (literally) at the hospital on a bed I could barely move in....
I want to help any mom of any size to achieve the birth she wants - I didn't have that courage for my other births and its a big regret. This was my fifth birth and first home/waterbirth.
My first son was a hospital birth with a very 'old school' obstetrician. I was induced. He only saw me in labor to break my water and he barely darkened the doorway when I started pushing. He mostly waited in the hallway. The nurse finally called him over because she felt my pushes were inadequate - he almost immediately said we needed forceps. My son was born via forceps with a very intense episiotomy.
The next three births followed, with some changes - new doctors, new hospitals, more interventions that I felt weren't needed. My fourth birth they 'threatened' a c-section because I was not progressing to their liking. I didn't get said c-section but I was left very frightened by the threats. I told my husband before I was even home that if we were blessed with another baby I was not going to any hospital.
I had to face my fears of finding a midwife who would accept me even though I am a plus size mom. I called many midwives before I even knew if I wanted to get pregnant again. I felt so strongly about a homebirth that if it was not an option, it would have affected my choice to even get pregnant again. I found a wonderful Midwife...and I achieved the birth I knew I wanted. My homebirth healed many disappointments from the past. And I was so much more comfortable than I was with any pain-relieving techniques offered at the hospital.
Even though my body may not be [what] want many women would want, I LOVE my body. It brings me so much joy. With my body I shared love with my husband, grew a healthy baby and birthed him naturally in the safety of my home. That is indescribable joy.Here is the video of her birth:
*Reposted with permission from http://rubyslippersx3.blogspot.com/
Tuesday, December 14, 2010
Italian Waterbirth Study
Giving birth in the water is one of the most wonderful things EVER.
I can't tell you how much I loved it, how much it helped with labor pain, and how it made it easier to be really mobile during labor.
It's a terrible shame that it is not offered as an option more widely in the United States. Certainly, more hospitals in Europe seem to be incorporating it before we do.
One of the objections you hear voiced on occasion by the doctors who resist waterbirth is the idea that it's not sterile enough and babies would be put at risk for infection.
This study contradicts that idea. Yes, there were microorganisms in the water, but the babies seemed largely unaffected by them, and in fact had a lower rate of infection/antibiotic use than babies born after "land delivery."
Alas, the study is in Italian so the only information I have is in the abstract, but note that the episiotomy rate in the water was less than 1%, a rate rarely seen in most hospitals. There's a tremendous benefit right there.
Also note that only 13% of women needed drugs for the pain. This is the "aquadural" effect; many women find that pain is greatly lessened (or at least more manageable) when in the water.
It's not that it totally relieves pain ─ I can attest that it doesn't. I still felt labor pains intensely during my waterbirth. However, they were manageable. The warm water felt WONDERFUL, it helped lessen the pain enough to get by, and I was able to be quite mobile in the birth tub in a way that helped me respond proactively to the pain.
So we shouldn't over-exaggerate the pain-relieving effects of water in labor. For some people it really does take the pain away. But for many of us it merely takes a significant edge off and helps you cope more proactively with it. (And if it helps shorten labor, I'm okay with that!)
But the point is, waterbirth is helpful and not harmful. Infection is not really an issue.
Time for more U.S. hospitals to get a clue and start incorporating more waterbirths.
Thöni A, Mussner K, Ploner F. [Water birthing: retrospective review of 2625 water births. Contamination of birth pool water and risk of microbial cross-infection]. Minerva Ginecol. 2010 Jun;62(3):203-11. [Article in Italian]
Reparto di Ginecologia e Ostetricia, Ospedale di Vipiteno, Bolzano, Italy.
Abstract
The aim of this study was to document the practice of 2625 water births at Vipiteno over the period 1997-2009 and compare outcome and safety with normal vaginal delivery. The microbial load of the birth pool water was analyzed, and neonatal infection rates after water birth and after land delivery were compared.
METHODS: The variables analyzed in the 1152 primiparae were: length of labor; incidence of episiotomies and tears; arterial cord blood pH and base excess values; percentage of pH<7.10 and base excess values >/=12 mmol/L. In all 2625 water births, the variables were: analgesic requirements; shoulder dystocia/ neonatal complications; and deliveries after a previous caesarean section. Bacterial cultures of water samples obtained from the bath after filling (sample A) and after delivery (sample B) were analyzed in 300 cases. The pediatricians recorded signs of suspected neonatal infection after water birth and after conventional vaginal delivery.
RESULTS: There was a marked reduction in labor duration in the primiparae who birthed in water; the episiotomy rate was 0.46%. Owing to the pain relieving effect of the warm birth pool water, pain relievers (opiates) were required in only 12.9% of water births.
Arterial cord blood pH and base excess values were comparable in both groups. Shoulder dystocia/neonatal complications were managed in 4 water births; 105 women with a previous caesarean section had a water birth.
In sample A, the isolated micro-organisms were Legionella spp. and Pseudomonas aeruginosa; in sample B, there was elevated colonization of birth pool water by total coliform bacilli and Escherichia coli. Despite microbial contamination of birth pool water during delivery, antibiotic prophylaxis, as indicated by clinical and laboratory suspicion of infection, was administered to only 0.98% of babies after water birth versus 1.64% of those after land delivery.
CONCLUSIONS: Results suggest clear medical advantages of water birthing: significantly shorter labor duration among the primiparae; a net reduction in episiotomy rates; and a marked drop in requests for pain relievers.
During expulsion of the fetus at delivery, fecal matter is released into the birth pool water, contaminating it with micro-organisms. Despite this, water birthing was found to be safe for the neonate and did not carry a higher risk of neonatal infection when compared with conventional vaginal delivery.
PMID: 20595945
I can't tell you how much I loved it, how much it helped with labor pain, and how it made it easier to be really mobile during labor.
It's a terrible shame that it is not offered as an option more widely in the United States. Certainly, more hospitals in Europe seem to be incorporating it before we do.
One of the objections you hear voiced on occasion by the doctors who resist waterbirth is the idea that it's not sterile enough and babies would be put at risk for infection.
This study contradicts that idea. Yes, there were microorganisms in the water, but the babies seemed largely unaffected by them, and in fact had a lower rate of infection/antibiotic use than babies born after "land delivery."
Alas, the study is in Italian so the only information I have is in the abstract, but note that the episiotomy rate in the water was less than 1%, a rate rarely seen in most hospitals. There's a tremendous benefit right there.
Also note that only 13% of women needed drugs for the pain. This is the "aquadural" effect; many women find that pain is greatly lessened (or at least more manageable) when in the water.
It's not that it totally relieves pain ─ I can attest that it doesn't. I still felt labor pains intensely during my waterbirth. However, they were manageable. The warm water felt WONDERFUL, it helped lessen the pain enough to get by, and I was able to be quite mobile in the birth tub in a way that helped me respond proactively to the pain.
So we shouldn't over-exaggerate the pain-relieving effects of water in labor. For some people it really does take the pain away. But for many of us it merely takes a significant edge off and helps you cope more proactively with it. (And if it helps shorten labor, I'm okay with that!)
But the point is, waterbirth is helpful and not harmful. Infection is not really an issue.
Time for more U.S. hospitals to get a clue and start incorporating more waterbirths.
Thöni A, Mussner K, Ploner F. [Water birthing: retrospective review of 2625 water births. Contamination of birth pool water and risk of microbial cross-infection]. Minerva Ginecol. 2010 Jun;62(3):203-11. [Article in Italian]
Reparto di Ginecologia e Ostetricia, Ospedale di Vipiteno, Bolzano, Italy.
Abstract
The aim of this study was to document the practice of 2625 water births at Vipiteno over the period 1997-2009 and compare outcome and safety with normal vaginal delivery. The microbial load of the birth pool water was analyzed, and neonatal infection rates after water birth and after land delivery were compared.
METHODS: The variables analyzed in the 1152 primiparae were: length of labor; incidence of episiotomies and tears; arterial cord blood pH and base excess values; percentage of pH<7.10 and base excess values >/=12 mmol/L. In all 2625 water births, the variables were: analgesic requirements; shoulder dystocia/ neonatal complications; and deliveries after a previous caesarean section. Bacterial cultures of water samples obtained from the bath after filling (sample A) and after delivery (sample B) were analyzed in 300 cases. The pediatricians recorded signs of suspected neonatal infection after water birth and after conventional vaginal delivery.
RESULTS: There was a marked reduction in labor duration in the primiparae who birthed in water; the episiotomy rate was 0.46%. Owing to the pain relieving effect of the warm birth pool water, pain relievers (opiates) were required in only 12.9% of water births.
Arterial cord blood pH and base excess values were comparable in both groups. Shoulder dystocia/neonatal complications were managed in 4 water births; 105 women with a previous caesarean section had a water birth.
In sample A, the isolated micro-organisms were Legionella spp. and Pseudomonas aeruginosa; in sample B, there was elevated colonization of birth pool water by total coliform bacilli and Escherichia coli. Despite microbial contamination of birth pool water during delivery, antibiotic prophylaxis, as indicated by clinical and laboratory suspicion of infection, was administered to only 0.98% of babies after water birth versus 1.64% of those after land delivery.
CONCLUSIONS: Results suggest clear medical advantages of water birthing: significantly shorter labor duration among the primiparae; a net reduction in episiotomy rates; and a marked drop in requests for pain relievers.
During expulsion of the fetus at delivery, fecal matter is released into the birth pool water, contaminating it with micro-organisms. Despite this, water birthing was found to be safe for the neonate and did not carry a higher risk of neonatal infection when compared with conventional vaginal delivery.
PMID: 20595945
Friday, December 10, 2010
VBAC After 2 Cesareans - Distorted Risk Perception
I recently wrote about ACOG's change in guidelines (August 2010), now "allowing" a trial of labor (TOL) again in women with 2 prior cesareans, whether or not they have had a prior vaginal birth. This was a welcome change of policy and a breath of fresh air after many years of campaigning to get VBA2C back.
However, in the same post, I discussed the chilling effect that the earlier 2004 guidelines (which disallowed TOLs after 2 prior cesareans unless the woman had already had a prior vaginal birth) had had on the choices of women, and decried the reality that many women were forced into unnecessary repeat cesareans by these old guidelines.
The fact of the matter is that when ACOG makes these sweeping policy decisions (like all breeches should be born by cesarean, or VBAMC is not appopriate), it has MAJOR effects on the birthing climate in the world, effects that are not easily changed even if ACOG later recognizes its decisions were based on questionable research and changes its mind.
The net effect of disallowing VBAMC has been that only a few doctors in the world now "allow" women to choose a trial of labor after 2 prior cesareans, even though the risks associated with this have been shown to be reasonable.
And although ACOG now "allows" a trial of labor after 2 cesareans, few OBs are rushing to change their policies. The barn door is open, that horse is gone, and it's not coming back anytime soon. I have hopes for change still, but I'm not holding my breath while waiting. The simple truth is that women are still being harmed by those old rules, even now. ACOG has much to answer for.
This is similar to what has happened with breech births in the United States. A flawed study came out that suggested that all breech babies were safer being born by cesarean, and BOOM, vaginal breech birth all but disappeared from the country, almost overnight. Medical schools even quit teaching how to attend vaginal breech births, so many doctors now have no idea how to safely attend a surprise breech that shows up at the hospital.
Research since the flawed breech study has questioned its conclusions and other recent studies have shown that vaginal breech birth is a reasonable option for most breech babies (and safer for the mother) ─ but it's close to too late to bring back the option because the art has been lost among so many providers. Canada has been leading the way to try and get vaginal breeches re-established, but there's a long way to go.
As with breech, many doctors have developed an extremely distorted picture about risk with VBAC after two cesareans.
And as with breech, all it took was one flawed study (Caughey 1999) that showed an abnormally high rate of rupture in VBA2C mothers, and ACOG rushed to virtually ban access to VBA2C.
The problem is, that study had only 134 women in it, a sample size far too small to reliably determine risk (much less base sweeping policy decisions on); coincidence could easily have distorted the results. No study before or since has shown such rates ─ but that didn't matter to ACOG. It changed the rules, VBAMC was basically disallowed, and despite later research that showed the risk was not nearly as high as the Caughey study, VBAMC is still viewed by many as "far too risky" to even consider. All on the basis of one very small, very flawed study.
Of course, some doctors have been overestimating the risk for uterine rupture in any VBAC for years, but the degree of risk overestimation is especially egregious with VBA2C.
Look at the following study, which surveyed doctors in France about their perceptions of the risks for uterine rupture with VBA1C and VBA2C. The doctors overestimated the risk for rupture with both, but the overestimation was HUGE in the VBA2C group.
In addition, they underestimated the risks associated with multiple repeat cesareans and counseled the women insufficiently about these.
As a result, less than a quarter of doctors surveyed would even consider "letting" a woman try a VBA2C trial of labor.
The amazing thing is that this survey was published five years after major research showing far lower rupture rates in VBA2C mothers than these doctors estimated.
So what is the risk for rupture in VBA2C? Studies vary, but the largest and most statistically powerful studies have shown rupture rates generally between 0.9% - 2.0% (Leung 1993, Miller 1994, Asakura 1995, Lin and Raynor 2004, Macones 2005, Landon 2006).
Tahseen and Griffiths (2010) did a meta-analysis of studies on VBA2C. They found the average rupture rate was 1.36% and that the maternal morbidity between VBA2C and repeat cesarean was similar.
Note that all these studies include VBA2Cs with lots of induction and augmentation. (Indeed, in Macones 2005, 16 of 19 ruptures in the VBA2C group were associated with induction or augmentation.) With spontaneous labors only, the rupture risk for VBA2C would likely be even less. (Never zero, alas, but less.)
What did the French doctors estimate the rupture risk to be with VBA2C? 14%!!! Seven to fifteen times than the real risk.
Distorted risk perception among doctors is one of the biggest things we battle on so many topics, from VBAC after multiple cesareans, to breech births, to pregnancy among women of size.
AUGH.
Abstract
Vaginal birth after two previous c-sections: obstetricians-gynaecologists opinions and practice patterns. Doret M, Touzet S, Bourdy S, Gaucherand P. J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2010 Mar 17.
Hospices Civils de Lyon, Hôpital Femme-Mère-Enfant, Service d'obstétrique, F-69677 Bron, Lyon, France.
Objectives. To evaluate obstetricians' practice patterns, opinions and factors influencing decision-making about mode of delivery in women with two previous c-sections.
Methods. A questionnaire was mailed to the 160 obstetricians from the Rhone-Alpes perinatal network. Questionnaires included demographic, organisational information and questions about physicians' opinion, practice patterns and patient counseling concerning vaginal birth after c-section (VBAC) after one and two caesarean sections.
Results. Response rate was 65.6%; 100% and 23.8% would offer VBAC to women with respectively one and two previous c-sections.
Uterine rupture rate was largely overestimated in both women with one (2.8%) and two prior c-sections (14.2%).
Factors positively influencing obstetricians were cerebral palsy estimated rate less than 20%, a minimal decision to birth delay less than 20 min when emergency c-section would be required. Neonatal severe outcomes consecutive to trial of labour as well as placenta praevia or accreta risk and morbidity associated with multiple c-sections would be insufficiently discussed.
Conclusion. Obstetricians largely prefer a third planned c-section in women with two previous c-sections.
This decision is partly based on a large overestimation of immediate maternal and neonatal serious outcomes consecutive to trial of labour as well documented serious long term outcomes of multiple c-sections are insufficiently considered. [sic]
PMID: 20233132
However, in the same post, I discussed the chilling effect that the earlier 2004 guidelines (which disallowed TOLs after 2 prior cesareans unless the woman had already had a prior vaginal birth) had had on the choices of women, and decried the reality that many women were forced into unnecessary repeat cesareans by these old guidelines.
The fact of the matter is that when ACOG makes these sweeping policy decisions (like all breeches should be born by cesarean, or VBAMC is not appopriate), it has MAJOR effects on the birthing climate in the world, effects that are not easily changed even if ACOG later recognizes its decisions were based on questionable research and changes its mind.
The net effect of disallowing VBAMC has been that only a few doctors in the world now "allow" women to choose a trial of labor after 2 prior cesareans, even though the risks associated with this have been shown to be reasonable.
And although ACOG now "allows" a trial of labor after 2 cesareans, few OBs are rushing to change their policies. The barn door is open, that horse is gone, and it's not coming back anytime soon. I have hopes for change still, but I'm not holding my breath while waiting. The simple truth is that women are still being harmed by those old rules, even now. ACOG has much to answer for.
This is similar to what has happened with breech births in the United States. A flawed study came out that suggested that all breech babies were safer being born by cesarean, and BOOM, vaginal breech birth all but disappeared from the country, almost overnight. Medical schools even quit teaching how to attend vaginal breech births, so many doctors now have no idea how to safely attend a surprise breech that shows up at the hospital.
Research since the flawed breech study has questioned its conclusions and other recent studies have shown that vaginal breech birth is a reasonable option for most breech babies (and safer for the mother) ─ but it's close to too late to bring back the option because the art has been lost among so many providers. Canada has been leading the way to try and get vaginal breeches re-established, but there's a long way to go.
As with breech, many doctors have developed an extremely distorted picture about risk with VBAC after two cesareans.
And as with breech, all it took was one flawed study (Caughey 1999) that showed an abnormally high rate of rupture in VBA2C mothers, and ACOG rushed to virtually ban access to VBA2C.
The problem is, that study had only 134 women in it, a sample size far too small to reliably determine risk (much less base sweeping policy decisions on); coincidence could easily have distorted the results. No study before or since has shown such rates ─ but that didn't matter to ACOG. It changed the rules, VBAMC was basically disallowed, and despite later research that showed the risk was not nearly as high as the Caughey study, VBAMC is still viewed by many as "far too risky" to even consider. All on the basis of one very small, very flawed study.
Of course, some doctors have been overestimating the risk for uterine rupture in any VBAC for years, but the degree of risk overestimation is especially egregious with VBA2C.
Look at the following study, which surveyed doctors in France about their perceptions of the risks for uterine rupture with VBA1C and VBA2C. The doctors overestimated the risk for rupture with both, but the overestimation was HUGE in the VBA2C group.
In addition, they underestimated the risks associated with multiple repeat cesareans and counseled the women insufficiently about these.
As a result, less than a quarter of doctors surveyed would even consider "letting" a woman try a VBA2C trial of labor.
The amazing thing is that this survey was published five years after major research showing far lower rupture rates in VBA2C mothers than these doctors estimated.
So what is the risk for rupture in VBA2C? Studies vary, but the largest and most statistically powerful studies have shown rupture rates generally between 0.9% - 2.0% (Leung 1993, Miller 1994, Asakura 1995, Lin and Raynor 2004, Macones 2005, Landon 2006).
Tahseen and Griffiths (2010) did a meta-analysis of studies on VBA2C. They found the average rupture rate was 1.36% and that the maternal morbidity between VBA2C and repeat cesarean was similar.
Note that all these studies include VBA2Cs with lots of induction and augmentation. (Indeed, in Macones 2005, 16 of 19 ruptures in the VBA2C group were associated with induction or augmentation.) With spontaneous labors only, the rupture risk for VBA2C would likely be even less. (Never zero, alas, but less.)
What did the French doctors estimate the rupture risk to be with VBA2C? 14%!!! Seven to fifteen times than the real risk.
Distorted risk perception among doctors is one of the biggest things we battle on so many topics, from VBAC after multiple cesareans, to breech births, to pregnancy among women of size.
AUGH.
Abstract
Vaginal birth after two previous c-sections: obstetricians-gynaecologists opinions and practice patterns. Doret M, Touzet S, Bourdy S, Gaucherand P. J Matern Fetal Neonatal Med. 2010 Mar 17.
Hospices Civils de Lyon, Hôpital Femme-Mère-Enfant, Service d'obstétrique, F-69677 Bron, Lyon, France.
Objectives. To evaluate obstetricians' practice patterns, opinions and factors influencing decision-making about mode of delivery in women with two previous c-sections.
Methods. A questionnaire was mailed to the 160 obstetricians from the Rhone-Alpes perinatal network. Questionnaires included demographic, organisational information and questions about physicians' opinion, practice patterns and patient counseling concerning vaginal birth after c-section (VBAC) after one and two caesarean sections.
Results. Response rate was 65.6%; 100% and 23.8% would offer VBAC to women with respectively one and two previous c-sections.
Uterine rupture rate was largely overestimated in both women with one (2.8%) and two prior c-sections (14.2%).
Factors positively influencing obstetricians were cerebral palsy estimated rate less than 20%, a minimal decision to birth delay less than 20 min when emergency c-section would be required. Neonatal severe outcomes consecutive to trial of labour as well as placenta praevia or accreta risk and morbidity associated with multiple c-sections would be insufficiently discussed.
Conclusion. Obstetricians largely prefer a third planned c-section in women with two previous c-sections.
This decision is partly based on a large overestimation of immediate maternal and neonatal serious outcomes consecutive to trial of labour as well documented serious long term outcomes of multiple c-sections are insufficiently considered. [sic]
PMID: 20233132
Monday, December 6, 2010
The Fat Vagina Theory: "Soft Tissue Dystocia"
One common misconception that many birth attendants have about labor in women of size is the "fat vagina" theory.
In this theory, birth attendants believe that women of size have a lot of extra fat tissue internally, crowding the maternal pelvis and birth canal. Extra fat tissue then supposedly gets in the way and obstructs the passage of the baby through the bony pelvis and/or vagina.
In medical research they call this "soft tissue dystocia," but sometimes doctors will patronizingly explain it to patients as the "fat vagina" theory.
[Note: "Fat Vagina" is an actual term used by an OB to tell a friend of mine from ICAN why she had a cesarean ─ she was told her morbid obesity made her vagina "too fat" to let the baby out during labor ─ and she's not the only one who has been told that. So although my sarcasm meter is certainly on when I use it, that's really a term that has been used with some women of size.]
Alas, it's not just doctors who buy into the "fat vagina" theory. One TV birth show featuring a midwifery practice even promoted this same theory, encouraging a fat woman who wanted a Vaginal Birth After Cesarean (VBAC) at their birthing center to lose weight during pregnancy in order to "decrease the fat deposits in the vagina" and "make it possible" for the woman to have a VBAC. (As if no fat woman has ever had a VBAC without losing weight! Sorry, they have. And so have I.)
Or there's the story one of my blog's readers emailed to me:
But what does the evidence say?
The Research, Such As It Is
One of the most frustrating aspects of the whole "fat vagina" theory is how little actual evidence there is on it, yet it is taught as if it is clearly established science.
One study (Crane 1997) describes it as a possible reason for a higher primary cesarean rate in "obese" women:
Most studies discuss increased maternal fat deposits as if it is a proven concept, but no one has actually done much study showing a real difference in maternal fat compartments, let alone proven that it affects labor.
Barau et al., 2006, also favors the concept of soft tissue dystocia but acknowledges that:
Most of the time, practitioners believe in the concept of soft tissue dystocia because they know that visceral fat can build up around internal abdominal organs, so they speculate that a similar thing must be happening in the maternal pelvis.
Furthermore, they often observe more tissue during pap smears in "morbidly obese" women, sometimes needing to use a larger speculum in order to hold open the vaginal vault and do the exam. Therefore, they jump to the conclusion that there is more fat "crowding" the pelvis of women of size, and that therefore, this must be obstructing the passage of the baby through the mother's pelvis.
But just because a fat woman's vagina tends to have more tissue to hold back with a speculum does not necessarily mean that there is enough fat way up inside the pelvis (pelvic inlet) or at the pelvic outlet to be clinically significant.
Remember, because the considerable weight of a fat woman's abdomen presses down with the weight of gravity, it may tend to make the vaginal walls more prone to collapse and look overly crowded, but it may not actually be so, or not enough to make much difference. And even if there was somewhat more tissue in a fat woman's vaginal area, remember......fat squishes. It's unlikely that there would be enough tissue there to actually impede a baby's exit, even in very fat women.
The one study we do have that actually did medical imagery to discover whether there are extra maternal fat deposits in the pelvis does not support the idea that there is enough extra soft tissue to be relevant to birth.
Wischnik (1992) did a study on the "fatty pelvis" to see whether fat compartments within the pelvis actually resulted in "functional reduction of the birth channel diameters." They found slightly more fat compartments, but did not find it to be clinically relevant. They concluded:
All we have is the observation that there is slightly more tissue pushing in and thus more need for a stronger speculum during the pap smears of women of size.
I think most medical providers then take a leap of logic and conclude that if fat women's babies don't come out as easily as skinny women's babies, it must be due to fat blocking the way....and the need for a bigger speculum during a GYN exam in some women of size just seems to confirm that bias.
But I think they need to look more closely at this assumption.
Alternative Explanations
Unfortunately, despite a glaring lack of evidence, soft tissue dystocia is a concept that continues to be taught and widely believed.
Barau 2006 argued that although there is no hard proof of soft tissue dystocia, it must exist because there is an increase in cesareans due to prolonged labor in obese women compared to average-sized women with similarly-sized babies.
However, I will point out again that a higher rate of malpositioned babies among women of size could also explain their longer labors and increased rate of cesareans due to labor dystocia.
Babies who face their mothers' tummies (occiput posterior) don't fit as easily through the pelvis, present with a larger head diameter, and often experience long, slow, hard labors. Research clearly shows that posterior babies have longer and slower labors and have a much higher cesarean rate than anterior babies.
Although the subject needs further study, some research has found a higher rate of malpositioned babies in "obese" women, and very old obstetric research also often notes in passing a higher rate of occiput posterior and other malpositions in women of size as well.
And anecdotally, women of size often do seem to have more malpositions, especially occiput posterior, many of which result in cesareans.
Many of these fat women have been told they had cesareans because of their "fat vagina" or "too small" pelvis. Yet if you read their stories carefully, they had all the signs and symptoms of a malpositioned baby instead.
Furthermore, many women who had cesareans for "fat vaginas" went on to have subsequent vaginal births with babies that were even larger than their cesarean babies....without losing weight first. This would be impossible if the problem really were a "fat vagina."
The key was having a well-positioned baby, not losing weight or reducing maternal pelvic fat deposits.
Another problem with the concept of the "fat vagina" is the inconsistency with which this diagnosis is applied. If a ~275 lb. woman (like my friend from ICAN) is told that her vagina is "too fat" and prevented her baby from getting out, then it follows that a 350 lb. woman should not be able to birth a similarly-sized baby vaginally. Yet we know that women of that size can and do have vaginal births. I have birth stories on my website of vaginal births to women at 300, 350, and 400 lbs. Yes, women of this size have a high cesarean rate because they are almost never given a real chance to actually have a vaginal birth.....but it can happen when they are given a realistic chance.
If fat vaginas truly prevented vaginal birth as much as some providers think they do, there would be NO vaginal birthers above a certain size. Sure, vaginal birth is always a combo of factors, including pelvic size/shape, the baby's size and position, (passenger, powers, position, etc.), so some variability in who gives birth vaginally is logical, but if soft tissue dystocia were a really significant factor, really supersized women would never birth vaginally. Yet many can and do, if they have a well-positioned baby and are given a realistic chance.
In my opinion, the real issue behind a higher rate of "dystocia" cesareans in women of size is probably fetal position, not fat vaginas.
However, because doctors are trained to blame obesity as the go-to diagnosis when they don't have another explanation, soft tissue dystocia gets blamed for "blocking" the baby's way out.
But that's just lazy thinking, not actual proof of soft tissue dystocia.
What About Shoulder Dystocia?
Another fear that many doctors and midwives have is that extra soft tissue in a fat woman's vagina might cause such a tight fit for the baby that the baby's shoulders will get stuck ("shoulder dystocia"), which can be a true obstetric emergency.
This fear seems borne out by studies which have shown higher rates of shoulder dystocia in "obese" women. Yet many of these studies did not control for other factors, like macrosomia, diabetes, forceps/vacuum extractor, or induction, all of which increase the risk for shoulder dystocia, and most of which occur at higher rates in women of size.
It's important to note that other studies have found that obesity is not a risk factor for shoulder dystocia when these other factors are controlled for.
Furthermore, it is not extra fat crowding the vaginal walls that causes shoulder dystocia. Rather, shoulder dystocia is caused by obstruction by the bony pelvis, not soft tissues. A complex interplay of factors results in shoulder dystocia, including fetal position, maternal position and mobility, pelvic shape, induction, operative delivery, diabetes, and macrosomia.
But justified or not, fear that "extra" soft tissue will cause shoulder dystocia is a big contributor to the high planned cesarean rate and early induction rate in women of size.
But What If Soft Tissue Dystocia is Real?
Frankly, soft tissue dystocia as a concept has not been proven at all, but some care providers believe in it with all their heart and refuse to be dissuaded from the possibility, pointing out that it hasn't been disproven conclusively either. That's a fair point.
To these providers I would argue that IF soft tissue dystocia were indeed real, then it is vital to change how most providers manage the labors of women of size in order to minimize its theoretical impact.
The typical way the labors of many "obese" women is managed often includes inducing early, breaking the bag of waters early, strongly encouraging early placement of an epidural "just in case," strictly limiting mobility, and using semi-sitting or lying back positions for pushing. Yet these measures often limit the amount of pelvic space the baby has to fit through.
If a bunch of extra fat is supposedly crowding things already, these restrictive protocols just make things worse.
IF soft tissue dystocia were real, mobility in labor would be even more important to women of size because it opens up the pelvic dimensions and gives "obese" women the best possible chance to help that baby fit through. Yet "obese" women have the most restrictions on their mobility in labor and are the least encouraged to try alternative positions for birth.
If a provider truly believes that soft tissue dystocia might be real, then the answer is not to pre-emptively induce or section women of size, but to give them every chance at creating more space in the pelvis.
This means not having her in the usual lying back/semi-sitting position, which puts pressure on the tailbone and presses it into the pelvic cavity, reducing the space available.
This means not requiring/pressuring her for an early epidural (as many practices encourage with women of size), so that she can move freely during labor and encourage her baby to be in a good position for birth.
It means not breaking her waters early in labor, so the baby has the watery cushion to help it move into an optimal position.
It means letting her stay upright as much as possible, so she can use gravity to help bring that baby down and press it through those supposedly fat-crowded walls.
It means letting her push in whatever position feels comfortable to her, encouraging her to stay mobile, and letting her utilize things that will help her stay mobile more easily (a labor tub, a dangling support or trapeze bar, a squat bar, etc.).
Personally, I don't believe that soft tissue dystocia is clinically relevant, but if you are a provider and you firmly believe in its existence, follow that to its logical conclusion and utilize labor protocols that help that woman maximize her pelvic space, not inhibit it via restrictive protocols.
Conclusion
Soft tissue dystocia is a belief that is near and dear to many doctors' hearts (and sadly, even to some midwives' hearts). Yet despite no research to support it, it as taught as if it is fact.
At this point, soft tissue dystocia is NOT fact. It has not been proven at all, and remains highly speculative as a possible cause of labor issues.
Furthermore, many women of size who have had their cesareans blamed on "fat vaginas" have gone on to have vaginal births in later births----without having lost weight first. If soft tissue dystocia were really the cause of their cesareans, this would not have been possible. The issue for them was fetal position, not maternal soft tissue.
The "morbidly obese" friend of mine who was told that her "fat vagina" was the cause of her cesarean? She has since gone on to have TWO vaginal births.....at the same maternal weight, with similarly-sized babies. So much for her "fat vagina" preventing the baby from coming out!
And then there's the commenter on my blog who had a similar experience:
And unfortunately, it prevents caregivers from examining their own care practices and how iatrogenic influences like weight bias, induction, fear of macrosomia, restrictive protocols, "failure to wait" and fetal position issues are the real factors driving the cesarean rate for women of size.
In this theory, birth attendants believe that women of size have a lot of extra fat tissue internally, crowding the maternal pelvis and birth canal. Extra fat tissue then supposedly gets in the way and obstructs the passage of the baby through the bony pelvis and/or vagina.
In medical research they call this "soft tissue dystocia," but sometimes doctors will patronizingly explain it to patients as the "fat vagina" theory.
[Note: "Fat Vagina" is an actual term used by an OB to tell a friend of mine from ICAN why she had a cesarean ─ she was told her morbid obesity made her vagina "too fat" to let the baby out during labor ─ and she's not the only one who has been told that. So although my sarcasm meter is certainly on when I use it, that's really a term that has been used with some women of size.]
Alas, it's not just doctors who buy into the "fat vagina" theory. One TV birth show featuring a midwifery practice even promoted this same theory, encouraging a fat woman who wanted a Vaginal Birth After Cesarean (VBAC) at their birthing center to lose weight during pregnancy in order to "decrease the fat deposits in the vagina" and "make it possible" for the woman to have a VBAC. (As if no fat woman has ever had a VBAC without losing weight! Sorry, they have. And so have I.)
Or there's the story one of my blog's readers emailed to me:
[The midwife] said I will have a large fat buildup around my birth canal and uterus so baby will get stuck in a natural birth.Alas, this "fat vagina" belief is a theory near and dear to many birth attendants' hearts. They have been taught in medical or midwifery school that "soft tissue dystocia" is the cause of many cesareans in fat women, and they believe it with all of their hearts. It's very difficult to get them to question its existence.
But what does the evidence say?
The Research, Such As It Is
One of the most frustrating aspects of the whole "fat vagina" theory is how little actual evidence there is on it, yet it is taught as if it is clearly established science.
One study (Crane 1997) describes it as a possible reason for a higher primary cesarean rate in "obese" women:
Perhaps dystocia due to an increased deposition of soft tissues in the maternal pelvis may lead to the observed increase in the cesarean delivery rate.One review (Vahratian 2005) noted that many studies attribute the increased rate of cesareans in "obese" women to soft tissue dystocia but that few prove it.
Several authors have speculated that this association [between obesity and cesarean rates] may be due to the added soft-tissue deposits in the pelvis of obese women, which coupled with a larger fetus might necessitate more time and stronger contractions to progress through labor. However, direct evidence of fat deposition in the pelvis is needed to support this assertion.The study noted that as yet, the authors promoting this theory have failed to provide this evidence.
Most studies discuss increased maternal fat deposits as if it is a proven concept, but no one has actually done much study showing a real difference in maternal fat compartments, let alone proven that it affects labor.
Barau et al., 2006, also favors the concept of soft tissue dystocia but acknowledges that:
There is no direct support of this concept by medical imagery studies.So why are healthcare providers so devoted to this theory when there is very little actual proof of it?
Most of the time, practitioners believe in the concept of soft tissue dystocia because they know that visceral fat can build up around internal abdominal organs, so they speculate that a similar thing must be happening in the maternal pelvis.
Furthermore, they often observe more tissue during pap smears in "morbidly obese" women, sometimes needing to use a larger speculum in order to hold open the vaginal vault and do the exam. Therefore, they jump to the conclusion that there is more fat "crowding" the pelvis of women of size, and that therefore, this must be obstructing the passage of the baby through the mother's pelvis.
But just because a fat woman's vagina tends to have more tissue to hold back with a speculum does not necessarily mean that there is enough fat way up inside the pelvis (pelvic inlet) or at the pelvic outlet to be clinically significant.
Remember, because the considerable weight of a fat woman's abdomen presses down with the weight of gravity, it may tend to make the vaginal walls more prone to collapse and look overly crowded, but it may not actually be so, or not enough to make much difference. And even if there was somewhat more tissue in a fat woman's vaginal area, remember......fat squishes. It's unlikely that there would be enough tissue there to actually impede a baby's exit, even in very fat women.
The one study we do have that actually did medical imagery to discover whether there are extra maternal fat deposits in the pelvis does not support the idea that there is enough extra soft tissue to be relevant to birth.
Wischnik (1992) did a study on the "fatty pelvis" to see whether fat compartments within the pelvis actually resulted in "functional reduction of the birth channel diameters." They found slightly more fat compartments, but did not find it to be clinically relevant. They concluded:
The common assumption can no longer be maintained, that adiposity necessarily causes soft tissue dystokia [sic] due to larger fat compartments within the small pelvis.So from a strictly evidence-based point of view, there is no substantiated medical evidence of enough increased deposits to be medically significant.
All we have is the observation that there is slightly more tissue pushing in and thus more need for a stronger speculum during the pap smears of women of size.
I think most medical providers then take a leap of logic and conclude that if fat women's babies don't come out as easily as skinny women's babies, it must be due to fat blocking the way....and the need for a bigger speculum during a GYN exam in some women of size just seems to confirm that bias.
But I think they need to look more closely at this assumption.
Alternative Explanations
Unfortunately, despite a glaring lack of evidence, soft tissue dystocia is a concept that continues to be taught and widely believed.
Barau 2006 argued that although there is no hard proof of soft tissue dystocia, it must exist because there is an increase in cesareans due to prolonged labor in obese women compared to average-sized women with similarly-sized babies.
However, I will point out again that a higher rate of malpositioned babies among women of size could also explain their longer labors and increased rate of cesareans due to labor dystocia.
Babies who face their mothers' tummies (occiput posterior) don't fit as easily through the pelvis, present with a larger head diameter, and often experience long, slow, hard labors. Research clearly shows that posterior babies have longer and slower labors and have a much higher cesarean rate than anterior babies.
Although the subject needs further study, some research has found a higher rate of malpositioned babies in "obese" women, and very old obstetric research also often notes in passing a higher rate of occiput posterior and other malpositions in women of size as well.
And anecdotally, women of size often do seem to have more malpositions, especially occiput posterior, many of which result in cesareans.
Many of these fat women have been told they had cesareans because of their "fat vagina" or "too small" pelvis. Yet if you read their stories carefully, they had all the signs and symptoms of a malpositioned baby instead.
Furthermore, many women who had cesareans for "fat vaginas" went on to have subsequent vaginal births with babies that were even larger than their cesarean babies....without losing weight first. This would be impossible if the problem really were a "fat vagina."
The key was having a well-positioned baby, not losing weight or reducing maternal pelvic fat deposits.
Another problem with the concept of the "fat vagina" is the inconsistency with which this diagnosis is applied. If a ~275 lb. woman (like my friend from ICAN) is told that her vagina is "too fat" and prevented her baby from getting out, then it follows that a 350 lb. woman should not be able to birth a similarly-sized baby vaginally. Yet we know that women of that size can and do have vaginal births. I have birth stories on my website of vaginal births to women at 300, 350, and 400 lbs. Yes, women of this size have a high cesarean rate because they are almost never given a real chance to actually have a vaginal birth.....but it can happen when they are given a realistic chance.
If fat vaginas truly prevented vaginal birth as much as some providers think they do, there would be NO vaginal birthers above a certain size. Sure, vaginal birth is always a combo of factors, including pelvic size/shape, the baby's size and position, (passenger, powers, position, etc.), so some variability in who gives birth vaginally is logical, but if soft tissue dystocia were a really significant factor, really supersized women would never birth vaginally. Yet many can and do, if they have a well-positioned baby and are given a realistic chance.
In my opinion, the real issue behind a higher rate of "dystocia" cesareans in women of size is probably fetal position, not fat vaginas.
However, because doctors are trained to blame obesity as the go-to diagnosis when they don't have another explanation, soft tissue dystocia gets blamed for "blocking" the baby's way out.
But that's just lazy thinking, not actual proof of soft tissue dystocia.
What About Shoulder Dystocia?
Another fear that many doctors and midwives have is that extra soft tissue in a fat woman's vagina might cause such a tight fit for the baby that the baby's shoulders will get stuck ("shoulder dystocia"), which can be a true obstetric emergency.
This fear seems borne out by studies which have shown higher rates of shoulder dystocia in "obese" women. Yet many of these studies did not control for other factors, like macrosomia, diabetes, forceps/vacuum extractor, or induction, all of which increase the risk for shoulder dystocia, and most of which occur at higher rates in women of size.
It's important to note that other studies have found that obesity is not a risk factor for shoulder dystocia when these other factors are controlled for.
Furthermore, it is not extra fat crowding the vaginal walls that causes shoulder dystocia. Rather, shoulder dystocia is caused by obstruction by the bony pelvis, not soft tissues. A complex interplay of factors results in shoulder dystocia, including fetal position, maternal position and mobility, pelvic shape, induction, operative delivery, diabetes, and macrosomia.
But justified or not, fear that "extra" soft tissue will cause shoulder dystocia is a big contributor to the high planned cesarean rate and early induction rate in women of size.
But What If Soft Tissue Dystocia is Real?
Frankly, soft tissue dystocia as a concept has not been proven at all, but some care providers believe in it with all their heart and refuse to be dissuaded from the possibility, pointing out that it hasn't been disproven conclusively either. That's a fair point.
To these providers I would argue that IF soft tissue dystocia were indeed real, then it is vital to change how most providers manage the labors of women of size in order to minimize its theoretical impact.
The typical way the labors of many "obese" women is managed often includes inducing early, breaking the bag of waters early, strongly encouraging early placement of an epidural "just in case," strictly limiting mobility, and using semi-sitting or lying back positions for pushing. Yet these measures often limit the amount of pelvic space the baby has to fit through.
If a bunch of extra fat is supposedly crowding things already, these restrictive protocols just make things worse.
IF soft tissue dystocia were real, mobility in labor would be even more important to women of size because it opens up the pelvic dimensions and gives "obese" women the best possible chance to help that baby fit through. Yet "obese" women have the most restrictions on their mobility in labor and are the least encouraged to try alternative positions for birth.
If a provider truly believes that soft tissue dystocia might be real, then the answer is not to pre-emptively induce or section women of size, but to give them every chance at creating more space in the pelvis.
This means not having her in the usual lying back/semi-sitting position, which puts pressure on the tailbone and presses it into the pelvic cavity, reducing the space available.
This means not requiring/pressuring her for an early epidural (as many practices encourage with women of size), so that she can move freely during labor and encourage her baby to be in a good position for birth.
It means not breaking her waters early in labor, so the baby has the watery cushion to help it move into an optimal position.
It means letting her stay upright as much as possible, so she can use gravity to help bring that baby down and press it through those supposedly fat-crowded walls.
It means letting her push in whatever position feels comfortable to her, encouraging her to stay mobile, and letting her utilize things that will help her stay mobile more easily (a labor tub, a dangling support or trapeze bar, a squat bar, etc.).
Personally, I don't believe that soft tissue dystocia is clinically relevant, but if you are a provider and you firmly believe in its existence, follow that to its logical conclusion and utilize labor protocols that help that woman maximize her pelvic space, not inhibit it via restrictive protocols.
Conclusion
Soft tissue dystocia is a belief that is near and dear to many doctors' hearts (and sadly, even to some midwives' hearts). Yet despite no research to support it, it as taught as if it is fact.
At this point, soft tissue dystocia is NOT fact. It has not been proven at all, and remains highly speculative as a possible cause of labor issues.
Furthermore, many women of size who have had their cesareans blamed on "fat vaginas" have gone on to have vaginal births in later births----without having lost weight first. If soft tissue dystocia were really the cause of their cesareans, this would not have been possible. The issue for them was fetal position, not maternal soft tissue.
The "morbidly obese" friend of mine who was told that her "fat vagina" was the cause of her cesarean? She has since gone on to have TWO vaginal births.....at the same maternal weight, with similarly-sized babies. So much for her "fat vagina" preventing the baby from coming out!
And then there's the commenter on my blog who had a similar experience:
I was told by my OB, while on the operating table and again at my 6 week check, that 'my vagina was too fat to birth a baby naturally'. Had a VBAC 3 years later though!Far too often, "fat vagina" is just a convenient excuse for lazy thinking, a handy scapegoat for the high cesarean rate in women of size, and a convenient excuse for blocking access to VBAC in yet another group.
[Comment on 10-12-10, on Prenatal Weight Gain: The Importance of Study Design.]
And unfortunately, it prevents caregivers from examining their own care practices and how iatrogenic influences like weight bias, induction, fear of macrosomia, restrictive protocols, "failure to wait" and fetal position issues are the real factors driving the cesarean rate for women of size.
Thursday, December 2, 2010
Fat Reserves Equal Extra Nutrition On Board?
Reply turned post from My OB Said What?!:
This is one reason why some doctors champion the idea that fat women don't need to gain weight in pregnancy....they believe that because a fat woman is "over-nutritioned," she has plenty of nutrient and energy stores to draw from and therefore doesn't need the same amount of calories and/or nutrients that other women do.
For example, here's a quote from an article about doctors wanting to lower pregnancy weight gain guidelines:
The Context of the Original Post
The doc in the original post at My OB Said What?!? is probably just trying to reassure the mother that a lower weight gain is very common in women of size and not necessarily something to get very alarmed about. That's true. As long as the mother is not deliberately trying to restrict gain, her nutrition is good, and baby is growing well, things will probably be fine even with a low gain.
(As we've noted before, most women of size gain less in pregnancy than other women, and many gain very little in pregnancy even without restriction. However, a policy of deliberate restriction to cause weight loss or little or no gain in women who would otherwise naturally gain may very well increase the risk of prematurity and too-small babies.)
The problem I have with his comment is the bit about "extra nutrition on board." He probably just meant it as a polite way to tell the mom she had extra fat reserves before pregnancy, so she didn't need to gain the same amount as women who don't already have those fat reserves. So I'll give this doc the benefit of the doubt and assume this was probably just his awkward way of saying it's not necessarily a problem if she gains less weight naturally.
But when many other doctors make this kind of comment (and I've seen it a number of times), what they really mean is that fat women can (and should) restrict intake significantly and baby will not be affected because of the fat mother's supposed extra reserves.
I strongly question the accuracy and wisdom of this.
Concerns With This Assumption
The doctors who favor strictly-limited caloric intake to restrict weight gains among women of size assume our fat reserves are basically "extra nutrition." They reason that because we have supposedly have "extra nutrition," the baby will just take what it needs from mom and she therefore has little or no need for extra nutrition or calories.
There are several problems with restricting calories and assuming the baby will "get what it needs" from the reserves of the obese woman:
Do Nutritional Reserves Really Substitute Adequately For Fresh Nutrient Intake?
Yes, the baby can get energy for growth from the mother's fat reserves, but that's NOT the same (or as valuable) as REAL NUTRITION from fresh food intake.
Doctors should be promoting a sensible diet and nutrients for mom and baby from fresh whole foods, not from the baby cannibalizing the mother's reserves.
Furthermore, if the mother's caloric intake is not sufficient for her energy needs, other things are sacrificed. Anne Frye, midwife and author of Holistic Midwifery states:
Furthermore, it is questionable whether the fetus is truly getting everything it needs from its mother. Jeremy Appleton, ND, writes:
Do Women of Size Really Have Extra Nutritional Reserves?
Furthermore, research shows that many people of size actually have nutritional deficits in things like iron, B-12, folate, and other areas.
For example, Schweiger 2010 recently found the following nutritional deficiencies in "morbidly obese" people just before they underwent weight loss surgery:
Other Concerns
In addition, there are other concerns with placing mothers on restricted calorie diets during pregnancy:
Conclusion
While I think THIS doctor in THIS comment was probably just trying to find a polite way to reassure the mom about her lack of gain, many doctors have said something similar but meant it to justify restricting "obese" women's intakes in pregnancy.
Those doctors believe that the baby will draw any needed energy and nutrients from the mother's fat reserves and therefore it's fine to place the mother on highly restricted calorie diets in pregnancy.
THAT I have a problem with.
Although doctors think they are doing fat women a favor when they put them on restricted diets/weight gains, it is more likely that they are doing far more harm than good.
“Well, you had a little extra nutrition on board when you got pregnant so you really don’t need to be gaining much weight.” – OB to mother who inquired about her low weight gain during her pregnancy;Comments like this represents another misperception that a lot of people have about nutrition and weight gain in women of size in pregnancy....that fat women are "over-nutritioned" and so have plenty of excess "nutrition" available for themselves or for a baby.
This is one reason why some doctors champion the idea that fat women don't need to gain weight in pregnancy....they believe that because a fat woman is "over-nutritioned," she has plenty of nutrient and energy stores to draw from and therefore doesn't need the same amount of calories and/or nutrients that other women do.
For example, here's a quote from an article about doctors wanting to lower pregnancy weight gain guidelines:
Dr. Patrick Catalano of Case Western Reserve University in Cleveland said an obese woman has nutrients stored away and doesn’t need to gain weight to provide for the baby.But does an obese woman really have "extra" nutrition stored away? And is that really an adequate substitution for nutrients from fresh whole foods eaten during pregnancy?
The Context of the Original Post
The doc in the original post at My OB Said What?!? is probably just trying to reassure the mother that a lower weight gain is very common in women of size and not necessarily something to get very alarmed about. That's true. As long as the mother is not deliberately trying to restrict gain, her nutrition is good, and baby is growing well, things will probably be fine even with a low gain.
(As we've noted before, most women of size gain less in pregnancy than other women, and many gain very little in pregnancy even without restriction. However, a policy of deliberate restriction to cause weight loss or little or no gain in women who would otherwise naturally gain may very well increase the risk of prematurity and too-small babies.)
The problem I have with his comment is the bit about "extra nutrition on board." He probably just meant it as a polite way to tell the mom she had extra fat reserves before pregnancy, so she didn't need to gain the same amount as women who don't already have those fat reserves. So I'll give this doc the benefit of the doubt and assume this was probably just his awkward way of saying it's not necessarily a problem if she gains less weight naturally.
But when many other doctors make this kind of comment (and I've seen it a number of times), what they really mean is that fat women can (and should) restrict intake significantly and baby will not be affected because of the fat mother's supposed extra reserves.
I strongly question the accuracy and wisdom of this.
Concerns With This Assumption
The doctors who favor strictly-limited caloric intake to restrict weight gains among women of size assume our fat reserves are basically "extra nutrition." They reason that because we have supposedly have "extra nutrition," the baby will just take what it needs from mom and she therefore has little or no need for extra nutrition or calories.
There are several problems with restricting calories and assuming the baby will "get what it needs" from the reserves of the obese woman:
- It assumes that the mother has extra nutritional reserves just because she's got extra fat stores
- It assumes that getting nutrients from the mother's reserves is the same or at least as good as getting those nutrients directly from fresh food
Do Nutritional Reserves Really Substitute Adequately For Fresh Nutrient Intake?
Yes, the baby can get energy for growth from the mother's fat reserves, but that's NOT the same (or as valuable) as REAL NUTRITION from fresh food intake.
Doctors should be promoting a sensible diet and nutrients for mom and baby from fresh whole foods, not from the baby cannibalizing the mother's reserves.
Furthermore, if the mother's caloric intake is not sufficient for her energy needs, other things are sacrificed. Anne Frye, midwife and author of Holistic Midwifery states:
If calories are insufficient, the body will burn available protein for energy instead. When protein is burned due to a lack of sufficient calories, less amino acids will be available for fetal growth and development, for albumin production to expand the blood volume, and to help with uterine muscle growth.In a 2005 article,"Eating for two, gaining too much", Jacqueline Stenson quotes Dr. Michael Nageotte, then-president of the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine:
Doctors and midwives will often suggest a diet which provides plenty of protein (90-100g) but only 1500-2000 calories. Reasoning that the woman is eating a high protein diet, midwives may dismiss a woman’s diet as a causative factor when she develops toxemia [pre-eclampsia] or premature labor…Women must eat enough calories and protein from nutrient-rich sources to meet their particular requirements.
Though very low weight gain in some women may cause a baby to be underweight, even babies born to mothers who’ve endured famine have fared well, he says. “The fetus, being a very efficient parasite, if you will, is able to survive and get what it needs from the mother,” Nageotte says.This is a dangerous assumption. Although babies born during famine usually survive, they usually do so at a price. "Fetal origins" research clearly shows that many of them are at increased risk for diabetes, hypertension, insulin resistance, obesity, and heart disease later in life. That is hardly faring "well." Clearly, undernutrition in utero has serious potential consequences and should not be shrugged off so casually.
Furthermore, it is questionable whether the fetus is truly getting everything it needs from its mother. Jeremy Appleton, ND, writes:
Evidence clearly contradicts the idea that a fetus can protect itself nutritionally when the mother is fasting or dieting. Although we know that a fetus can draw on maternal stores even when the mother is deficient, the extent to which this can occur is unknown. Data collected during the Dutch famine suggest that a malnourished mother protects her own body stores of nutrients at the expense of the fetus. During the famine, mothers lost proportionately less body weight (2% loss) than their fetuses (10% loss). Optimum fetal growth occurs only when the mother is able to gain a crucial amount of extra body weight during pregnancy. For this reason, pregnant women should not diet.Naeye did a study that surveyed pregnancy outcome by weight gain over a group of over 50,000 women in 12 hospitals and found:
The fetus is exceptionally dependent on maternal nutritional reserves when mothers have very low weight gains…The quantity and balance of amino acids and other nutrients supplied from such maternal reserves may not be as favorable to the fetus as those largely deprived from dietary intake. Even large stores of depot fat do not seem to ensure an optimal outcome of pregnancy when weight gains are very low or mothers lose weight.I think the assumption that babies will just take their nutrition from the mother's stores ─ and that this is just as good as getting it from dietary intake ─ has not been proven at all. An "over-nutritioned" mother still needs fresh foods, adequate calories, adequate protein levels, and a wide variety of nutrients from dietary intake, just like any other mother.
Do Women of Size Really Have Extra Nutritional Reserves?
Furthermore, research shows that many people of size actually have nutritional deficits in things like iron, B-12, folate, and other areas.
For example, Schweiger 2010 recently found the following nutritional deficiencies in "morbidly obese" people just before they underwent weight loss surgery:
The prevalence of pre-operative nutritional deficiencies were: 35% for iron, 24% for folic acid, 24% for ferritin, 3.6% for vitamin B12, 2% for phosphorous, and 0.9% for calcium, Hb and MCV level was low in 19%...Patients with BMI [greater than or equal to] 50 kg/m(2) were at greater risk for low folic acid (OR = 14.57, 95% CI:1.4-151.34).
Similarly, Aasheim 2008 found a number of nutritional deficiencies in "obese" patients:
Low concentrations of vitamin B-6, vitamin C, 25-hydroxyvitamin D, and vitamin E adjusted for lipids are prevalent in morbidly obese Norwegian patients seeking weight-loss treatment.One author summed it up when he stated:
Though commonly considered a state of “overnutrition”, obesity has increasingly been recognized as a risk factor for several nutrient deficiencies, including lower levels of antioxidants and certain fat-soluble vitamins.
Doctors should not assume that if you are carrying "extra" weight, you automatically have plenty of extra nutrients available for baby. Many women of size actually do not.
Other Concerns
In addition, there are other concerns with placing mothers on restricted calorie diets during pregnancy:
- If the "obese" mother does not have good nutritional reserves, a restricted calorie diet makes it difficult to get the full range of nutrients needed for both the mother and the baby
- If the mothers' caloric intake is insufficent for her needs, fat stores will be burned and ketones will be spilled as a side effect, which may impair cognitive development of the fetus (as we've discussed before)
Conclusion
While I think THIS doctor in THIS comment was probably just trying to find a polite way to reassure the mom about her lack of gain, many doctors have said something similar but meant it to justify restricting "obese" women's intakes in pregnancy.
Those doctors believe that the baby will draw any needed energy and nutrients from the mother's fat reserves and therefore it's fine to place the mother on highly restricted calorie diets in pregnancy.
THAT I have a problem with.
Although doctors think they are doing fat women a favor when they put them on restricted diets/weight gains, it is more likely that they are doing far more harm than good.
Monday, November 29, 2010
Failure to Wait
New research is showing what many critics have been saying for years ─ that too many cesareans performed for "failure to progress" in labor are actually cesareans for "failure to wait."
In other words, some doctors don't wait long enough for labor to progress on its own before declaring that a cesarean is needed.
The problem of "failure to wait" cesareans is often particularly prevalent in women of size and may be one reason for a higher rate of cesareans in "obese" women.
A Lack of Patience for Women of Size
Since "failure to wait" is especially common in induced labors (recent research shows that "half of cesarean[s] for dystocia in induced labor were performed before 6 cm of cervical dilation"), and since women of size are induced at far higher rates than other women, discussions about "failure to wait" cesareans in this group are very important.
Adding into this is the fact that labors tend to be longer in women of size, perhaps reflecting more malpositioned babies or induction for longer gestations (i.e., bodies not quite ready for labor yet).
If labor tends to be longer in women of size and caregivers do not allow for that, more "failure to wait" cesareans are going to occur.
For example, Pevzner 2009 found that induced labors took longer and required more induction drugs in "obese" women. Even when controlled for induction, Nuthalapaty 2004, and Hamon 2005 showed that "obese" women had longer labors, especially in the first stage.
In addition, Vahratian 2004 showed that the slower duration was concentrated around 4-6 cm of dilation, exactly when most "failure to wait" cesareans are performed. They concluded:
Another classic example of "failure to wait" is found in the first VBAC study on "obese" women, which is often cited as a reason not to let very fat women try to VBAC. The study found only a 13% success rate in this group, and so it was widely concluded by many authors that very fat women were not appropriate candidates for VBAC. (Don't worry; later studies have found much higher success rates.)
A closer look at the study reveals that there were only 30 women in the trial of labor (TOL) group, certainly not a large enough sample size on which to make sweeping policy decisions for a whole demographic group. The study also showed that, of these women, 57% had their labors induced, which research clearly shows lowers the rate of VBAC success. (In the 13% VBAC study, none of the women who had their labors induced had a VBAC; all the VBACs went into labor spontaneously.)
Most tellingly, the average dilation at the time of the decision for repeat cesarean during labor was 4.5 cm. This shows that these women of size were not really given an adequate chance at labor, and were sectioned far too early, as is so common in the labor management of "obese" women.
Is it any wonder that the women in this study only had a 13% VBAC success rate? Their doctors clearly did not believe that very fat women could give birth vaginally on their own, and so induced more than half of them, despite all the evidence showing induction lowers VBAC success rates. Furthermore, they gave up on the trial of labor very early, before the women had really even reached the active stage of labor.
Although I'm sure the physicians justified intervening earlier in order to avoid difficult and risky emergency surgery later on, it shows a troubling pattern in not letting fat women even have an adequate trial of labor before jumping to a surgical conclusion.
Conclusion
Yes, surgery in very fat women is harder and takes longer, so it is understandable that doctors don't want to wait until there is an emergent situation before intervening. But more and more, they are moving towards only giving "obese" women a token trial of labor (if they let them labor at all), and moving prematurely to a surgical solution if the baby doesn't practically fall out. This is not a reasonable alternative.
Given the increased risks of surgery in women of size and the long-term implications of surgical births, I would argue that the better solution is not to section fat women prematurely, but instead to give fat women every chance to deliver vaginally by awaiting spontaneous labor whenever possible, and to apply a tincture of patience, knowing that labor may simply take a little longer in women of size.
As long as mother and baby are doing well, a tincture of patience is the best option for long labors in many women, and may be particularly appropriate in women of size.
"Failure To Progress" cesareans are far too often "Failure To Wait" cesareans, and especially so in women of size.
Here's the abstract of that new study:
Zhang J et al. The Consortium on Safe Labor. Contemporary Patterns of Spontaneous Labor With Normal Neonatal Outcomes. Obstet Gynecol. 2010 Dec;116(6):1281-1287.
OBJECTIVE: To use contemporary labor data to examine the labor patterns in a large, modern obstetric population in the United States.
METHODS: Data were from the Consortium on Safe Labor, a multicenter retrospective study that abstracted detailed labor and delivery information from electronic medical records in 19 hospitals across the United States. A total of 62,415 parturients were selected who had a singleton term gestation, spontaneous onset of labor, vertex presentation, vaginal delivery, and a normal perinatal outcome. A repeated-measures analysis was used to construct average labor curves by parity. An interval-censored regression was used to estimate duration of labor, stratified by cervical dilation at admission and centimeter by centimeter.
RESULTS: Labor may take more than 6 hours to progress from 4 to 5 cm and more than 3 hours to progress from 5 to 6 cm of dilation. Nulliparous and multiparous women appeared to progress at a similar pace before 6 cm. However, after 6 cm, labor accelerated much faster in multiparous than in nulliparous women. The 95 percentiles of the second stage of labor in nulliparous women with and without epidural analgesia were 3.6 and 2.8 hours, respectively. A partogram for nulliparous women is proposed.
CONCLUSION: In a large, contemporary population, the rate of cervical dilation accelerated after 6 cm, and progress from 4 cm to 6 cm was far slower than previously described. Allowing labor to continue for a longer period before 6 cm of cervical dilation may reduce the rate of intrapartum and subsequent repeat cesarean deliveries in the United States.
PMID: 21099592
In other words, some doctors don't wait long enough for labor to progress on its own before declaring that a cesarean is needed.
The problem of "failure to wait" cesareans is often particularly prevalent in women of size and may be one reason for a higher rate of cesareans in "obese" women.
A Lack of Patience for Women of Size
Since "failure to wait" is especially common in induced labors (recent research shows that "half of cesarean[s] for dystocia in induced labor were performed before 6 cm of cervical dilation"), and since women of size are induced at far higher rates than other women, discussions about "failure to wait" cesareans in this group are very important.
Adding into this is the fact that labors tend to be longer in women of size, perhaps reflecting more malpositioned babies or induction for longer gestations (i.e., bodies not quite ready for labor yet).
If labor tends to be longer in women of size and caregivers do not allow for that, more "failure to wait" cesareans are going to occur.
For example, Pevzner 2009 found that induced labors took longer and required more induction drugs in "obese" women. Even when controlled for induction, Nuthalapaty 2004, and Hamon 2005 showed that "obese" women had longer labors, especially in the first stage.
In addition, Vahratian 2004 showed that the slower duration was concentrated around 4-6 cm of dilation, exactly when most "failure to wait" cesareans are performed. They concluded:
Labor progression in overweight and obese women was significantly slower than that of normal-weight women before 6 cm of cervical dilation. Given that nearly one half of women of childbearing age are either overweight or obese, it is critical to consider differences in labor progression by maternal prepregnancy BMI before additional interventions are performed.In other words, doctors need to wait a little longer in women of size to give labor every chance to progress further before performing a cesarean.
Another classic example of "failure to wait" is found in the first VBAC study on "obese" women, which is often cited as a reason not to let very fat women try to VBAC. The study found only a 13% success rate in this group, and so it was widely concluded by many authors that very fat women were not appropriate candidates for VBAC. (Don't worry; later studies have found much higher success rates.)
A closer look at the study reveals that there were only 30 women in the trial of labor (TOL) group, certainly not a large enough sample size on which to make sweeping policy decisions for a whole demographic group. The study also showed that, of these women, 57% had their labors induced, which research clearly shows lowers the rate of VBAC success. (In the 13% VBAC study, none of the women who had their labors induced had a VBAC; all the VBACs went into labor spontaneously.)
Most tellingly, the average dilation at the time of the decision for repeat cesarean during labor was 4.5 cm. This shows that these women of size were not really given an adequate chance at labor, and were sectioned far too early, as is so common in the labor management of "obese" women.
Is it any wonder that the women in this study only had a 13% VBAC success rate? Their doctors clearly did not believe that very fat women could give birth vaginally on their own, and so induced more than half of them, despite all the evidence showing induction lowers VBAC success rates. Furthermore, they gave up on the trial of labor very early, before the women had really even reached the active stage of labor.
Although I'm sure the physicians justified intervening earlier in order to avoid difficult and risky emergency surgery later on, it shows a troubling pattern in not letting fat women even have an adequate trial of labor before jumping to a surgical conclusion.
Conclusion
Yes, surgery in very fat women is harder and takes longer, so it is understandable that doctors don't want to wait until there is an emergent situation before intervening. But more and more, they are moving towards only giving "obese" women a token trial of labor (if they let them labor at all), and moving prematurely to a surgical solution if the baby doesn't practically fall out. This is not a reasonable alternative.
Given the increased risks of surgery in women of size and the long-term implications of surgical births, I would argue that the better solution is not to section fat women prematurely, but instead to give fat women every chance to deliver vaginally by awaiting spontaneous labor whenever possible, and to apply a tincture of patience, knowing that labor may simply take a little longer in women of size.
As long as mother and baby are doing well, a tincture of patience is the best option for long labors in many women, and may be particularly appropriate in women of size.
"Failure To Progress" cesareans are far too often "Failure To Wait" cesareans, and especially so in women of size.
Here's the abstract of that new study:
Zhang J et al. The Consortium on Safe Labor. Contemporary Patterns of Spontaneous Labor With Normal Neonatal Outcomes. Obstet Gynecol. 2010 Dec;116(6):1281-1287.
OBJECTIVE: To use contemporary labor data to examine the labor patterns in a large, modern obstetric population in the United States.
METHODS: Data were from the Consortium on Safe Labor, a multicenter retrospective study that abstracted detailed labor and delivery information from electronic medical records in 19 hospitals across the United States. A total of 62,415 parturients were selected who had a singleton term gestation, spontaneous onset of labor, vertex presentation, vaginal delivery, and a normal perinatal outcome. A repeated-measures analysis was used to construct average labor curves by parity. An interval-censored regression was used to estimate duration of labor, stratified by cervical dilation at admission and centimeter by centimeter.
RESULTS: Labor may take more than 6 hours to progress from 4 to 5 cm and more than 3 hours to progress from 5 to 6 cm of dilation. Nulliparous and multiparous women appeared to progress at a similar pace before 6 cm. However, after 6 cm, labor accelerated much faster in multiparous than in nulliparous women. The 95 percentiles of the second stage of labor in nulliparous women with and without epidural analgesia were 3.6 and 2.8 hours, respectively. A partogram for nulliparous women is proposed.
CONCLUSION: In a large, contemporary population, the rate of cervical dilation accelerated after 6 cm, and progress from 4 cm to 6 cm was far slower than previously described. Allowing labor to continue for a longer period before 6 cm of cervical dilation may reduce the rate of intrapartum and subsequent repeat cesarean deliveries in the United States.
PMID: 21099592
Wednesday, November 24, 2010
Third Annual Turkey Awards: Jumping To Conclusions
Well, it's that time of year again.....time for my Annual Turkey Award!
This is an award I created to annually "honor" fat-phobic healthcare providers everywhere. And believe me, there are plenty of them...a veritable cornucopia of turkeys to choose from for this delightful award.
This year, I want to highlight the caregivers who have made the leap of logic that if a fat woman is at increased risk for a complication, that means there's a GUARANTEE that she will experience that complication.
Like the recent commenter to my blog who was told that at her size, she WOULD have a deformed baby. Not a reasoned discussion about possible increases in risk for birth defects or ways to possibly lower that risk, but the doctor telling her that she WILL experience a "deformed" baby, simply because of her size. Never mind that the chance is actually quite low in terms of actual numbers, the doctor just concluded that it WOULD happen because of her weight.
Or another reader who recently sent me an email about her first pregnancy appointment, where she was lectured about her fat and basically informed she "should neither expect or deserve to have a healthy baby."
Or there are the the doctors who tell fat pregnant women that they WILL get pre-eclampsia or they WILL get gestational diabetes during their pregnancies. No discussion of actual numerical risks (which show that the risk, while increased, is still relatively low), no discussion of things they might do to help mitigate that risk ─ just the assumption that these complications WILL occur in all women of size.
[Yes, there are increased rates of PE and GD in women of size, but there is NO study that shows a 100% rate of pre-eclampsia or gestational diabetes in "obese" women, "morbidly obese" women, or even "super-obese" women.....not even close.]
Or there's the recent spate of doctors telling "obese" women that if they try to have a VBAC (Vaginal Birth After Cesarean), they, their baby, or both WILL die (or have a very low chance of survival). Never mind that there's NO actual evidence to support an increased risk for maternal or fetal death among fat women trying for a VBAC; who needs evidence? They just know that it's far too dangerous for fat women to even try and therefore fat women shouldn't even be allowed the choice.
This is one of the major problems with over-emphasis on the risks of "obesity" in public health campaigns. People begin getting a distorted picture of the actual numerical risk.
In time, a numerically-low-but-somewhat-increased-risk for a complication somehow gets transformed into a widespread perception that ALL fat people will experience that complication and eventually the perception develops that DEATH will be the inevitable result.
This exaggerated ramping of risk perception occurs even among healthcare providers, who really ought to know better, and in the end, results in people's choices and autonomy being taken away from them.
It's not that we cannot discuss possible risks. Of course we can; that's an important part of the healthcare conversation. However, public health discussions about "obesity" have gone from discussing possible risks realistically and without judgment, to making sweeping generalizations and exaggerations of risk in the public's mind, to scapegoating, barbaric scaremongering, and suspension of basic rights by healthcare professionals.
You know things have gone too far when even healthcare professionals are believing the scaremongering sensationalism that goes against every bit of science and reason that they should have been trained to employ, and when they suspend every sense of medical ethics they have been taught.
*Turkey image from Wikimedia.
This is an award I created to annually "honor" fat-phobic healthcare providers everywhere. And believe me, there are plenty of them...a veritable cornucopia of turkeys to choose from for this delightful award.
This year, I want to highlight the caregivers who have made the leap of logic that if a fat woman is at increased risk for a complication, that means there's a GUARANTEE that she will experience that complication.
Like the recent commenter to my blog who was told that at her size, she WOULD have a deformed baby. Not a reasoned discussion about possible increases in risk for birth defects or ways to possibly lower that risk, but the doctor telling her that she WILL experience a "deformed" baby, simply because of her size. Never mind that the chance is actually quite low in terms of actual numbers, the doctor just concluded that it WOULD happen because of her weight.
Or another reader who recently sent me an email about her first pregnancy appointment, where she was lectured about her fat and basically informed she "should neither expect or deserve to have a healthy baby."
Or there are the the doctors who tell fat pregnant women that they WILL get pre-eclampsia or they WILL get gestational diabetes during their pregnancies. No discussion of actual numerical risks (which show that the risk, while increased, is still relatively low), no discussion of things they might do to help mitigate that risk ─ just the assumption that these complications WILL occur in all women of size.
[Yes, there are increased rates of PE and GD in women of size, but there is NO study that shows a 100% rate of pre-eclampsia or gestational diabetes in "obese" women, "morbidly obese" women, or even "super-obese" women.....not even close.]
Or there's the recent spate of doctors telling "obese" women that if they try to have a VBAC (Vaginal Birth After Cesarean), they, their baby, or both WILL die (or have a very low chance of survival). Never mind that there's NO actual evidence to support an increased risk for maternal or fetal death among fat women trying for a VBAC; who needs evidence? They just know that it's far too dangerous for fat women to even try and therefore fat women shouldn't even be allowed the choice.
This is one of the major problems with over-emphasis on the risks of "obesity" in public health campaigns. People begin getting a distorted picture of the actual numerical risk.
In time, a numerically-low-but-somewhat-increased-risk for a complication somehow gets transformed into a widespread perception that ALL fat people will experience that complication and eventually the perception develops that DEATH will be the inevitable result.
This exaggerated ramping of risk perception occurs even among healthcare providers, who really ought to know better, and in the end, results in people's choices and autonomy being taken away from them.
It's not that we cannot discuss possible risks. Of course we can; that's an important part of the healthcare conversation. However, public health discussions about "obesity" have gone from discussing possible risks realistically and without judgment, to making sweeping generalizations and exaggerations of risk in the public's mind, to scapegoating, barbaric scaremongering, and suspension of basic rights by healthcare professionals.
You know things have gone too far when even healthcare professionals are believing the scaremongering sensationalism that goes against every bit of science and reason that they should have been trained to employ, and when they suspend every sense of medical ethics they have been taught.
*Turkey image from Wikimedia.
Monday, November 22, 2010
Open Thread Ranting: Obesity Journalism Clichés I Could Do Without
Oy. I've had a heck of a month so far, with medical crises in 3 of 4 children that included an MRI, MRA, and neurological testing in one child, several weeks of missed school and minor surgery in another child, and an ultrasound, hospital visit, and possible major surgery (not needed in the end) in another child. Not to mention all the GAZILLION doctor appointments that went with all of this. Oh, and a bunch of meetings at school to develop a plan get various medical needs met.
So I'm definitely feeling stressed out, and that's why there haven't been any major posts in a while.
The good news is that in the end, these were only minor blips on the scale of Things That Could Go Wrong, so I'm counting my blessings even as I acknowledge the stress and its toll. At least most of this stuff ended up being relatively minor, thank goodness.
And since things tend to come in threes, I'm reassuring myself that this means I'm done. Child #4 is under strict instructions that he does NOT need to complete the set and make us four for four. We've had our three bad things, now we're done and can move on, thank you very much. (I'll just plug my ears, sing la-la-la loudly, and ignore the fact that ski season is looming.)
The bad news is that I'm behind in my blogging. I have a number of major posts in the works but they are research-heavy and so need some real dedicated TIME to finish, time which has been spent in doctors' offices, at the hospital, and in meetings recently. So please, keep checking back. There's lots more to come, once people stop being sick long enough for me to finish it.
In the meantime, in the interest of at least posting something, here's a mini-rant about "obesity journalism" clichés that's been brewing in my mind for a long time. Feel free to rant along.
MY RANT: Whenever I read journalistm stories about the "obesity epidemic," I am appalled at all the tacky clichés used. Journalists are supposed to avoid clichés ─ but somehow editors look the other way when it comes to "obesity" stories. (Apparently, rules of good writing are not needed when discussing obesity?)
For example, I would love to banish the phrase, "packing on the pounds." Yeah, sure, it's alliterative, but it's insulting and inflammatory. Same with the phrase, "ballooned up to.....xxx pounds." Both are overused and not very imaginative ─ just lazy journalism.
I'm sure if I sat down and thought about it for a while, I could come up with a lot more clichés....but I'll let you do that for me.
Which "obesity journalism" clichés drive you nuts? Do you have other pet peeves about the writing style and content of these types of "obesity epidemic" stories?
Open Thread Ranting starts now.
So I'm definitely feeling stressed out, and that's why there haven't been any major posts in a while.
The good news is that in the end, these were only minor blips on the scale of Things That Could Go Wrong, so I'm counting my blessings even as I acknowledge the stress and its toll. At least most of this stuff ended up being relatively minor, thank goodness.
And since things tend to come in threes, I'm reassuring myself that this means I'm done. Child #4 is under strict instructions that he does NOT need to complete the set and make us four for four. We've had our three bad things, now we're done and can move on, thank you very much. (I'll just plug my ears, sing la-la-la loudly, and ignore the fact that ski season is looming.)
The bad news is that I'm behind in my blogging. I have a number of major posts in the works but they are research-heavy and so need some real dedicated TIME to finish, time which has been spent in doctors' offices, at the hospital, and in meetings recently. So please, keep checking back. There's lots more to come, once people stop being sick long enough for me to finish it.
In the meantime, in the interest of at least posting something, here's a mini-rant about "obesity journalism" clichés that's been brewing in my mind for a long time. Feel free to rant along.
MY RANT: Whenever I read journalistm stories about the "obesity epidemic," I am appalled at all the tacky clichés used. Journalists are supposed to avoid clichés ─ but somehow editors look the other way when it comes to "obesity" stories. (Apparently, rules of good writing are not needed when discussing obesity?)
For example, I would love to banish the phrase, "packing on the pounds." Yeah, sure, it's alliterative, but it's insulting and inflammatory. Same with the phrase, "ballooned up to.....xxx pounds." Both are overused and not very imaginative ─ just lazy journalism.
I'm sure if I sat down and thought about it for a while, I could come up with a lot more clichés....but I'll let you do that for me.
Which "obesity journalism" clichés drive you nuts? Do you have other pet peeves about the writing style and content of these types of "obesity epidemic" stories?
Open Thread Ranting starts now.
Friday, November 12, 2010
Size Bias in British Obstetrics
I received the following email recently, describing the poor treatment one pregnant woman of size received from the British healthcare system. (I have edited it a bit for clarity.)
Kmom's Follow-up Note: I was able to put this mother in touch with a couple of Independent Midwives in Britain so at least she has some better emotional support and a chance at other care. Thank you to those who have helped me find other resources for this mother.
As for British policy, I'm sure the attitude varies from consultant to consultant, but I'm hearing more and more stories of egregious size bias in the UK system. If you are a British woman of size and encounter this kind of treatment, I would remind you of the option of Independent Midwives. Yes, you'd have to pay out of pocket, but that's better than being subjected to crappy treatment and the risks of a cesarean you don't really need. And besides, many independent midwives will work with you to find a way to afford their care.
The same is true in the USA and Canada. Don't forget the choice of birth center or homebirth midwives. Yes, there are people who truly cannot afford that and have fewer choices, but too many people write it off as something they cannot possibly afford when there often ARE ways to make it work. Most midwives will find a way to help you afford it via sliding scale fees, payment plans, bartering, etc., and some insurances that say they "do not" cover homebirth actually do (mine did). Explore the possibilities thoroughly before you decide .
If at all possible, don't let cost keep you from having real childbirth choices and truly supportive care. It's priceless.
I am a 'plus-size' mum...or extra-morbidly obese as my paperwork says. I am British and living in the UK...We have free health care, which I have always been very grateful for and happy with. However, new government policies over the last few years have made being even over-weight and pregnant a problem, let alone as large as I am! (I'm a UK size 22/24.)
For example...anyone who is deemed overweight when they 'present as pregnant to their GP' is now offered a strict diet program overseen by weight watchers or slimmers world, or a termination 'until weight is acceptable'.
Those of us that go against GP advice are ostracised and treated as both unworthy and stupid. My current treatment includes being 'seen' by my GP in a corridor whilst people walk past, rather than in the privacy of an office; and being blatantly lied to about statistics (I was actually told it was physically impossible to give birth vaginally after a c-section, as the baby would 'go the wrong way'!).
My consultant told me I was so fat it made the radiographers sick to have to perform a scan on me...The same consultant insisted I have huge stitches after my C-section, and refused to allow me anything other than normal paracetamol [kmom note: Tylenol] as painkillers after the spinal block wore off to 'teach' me a lesson!
When I refused to have a coil fitted as contraception, I was told 'Well, you probably don't need anything, there can't be many men desperate enough to have sex with someone your size'...in a room with 3 other mums.
The alternative to that? Well, there isn't really one...I have 'opted out of care'...basically no-one sees me, so there isn't anyone to make the comments! I've had 3 antenatal appointments so far, and am under 'GP care', but as he won't see me in his office and I don't feel comfortable discussing my pregnancy or ailments in a corridor for all to hear, I basically don't see him either.
Now all this would be bad enough with a 'normal' pregnancy, but this is my 7th baby...of my last 3 pregnancies, one was a messy late miscarriage, the other two were c-sections (I'd managed normal births until then).
The first [c-section] was as my son was breech (obese women can't deliver breech babies naturally apparently!), the second c-section gave me one 7 week premature daughter and a still-born son...so not exactly 'perfect' births...then there's my BP (normally high, but I'm currently proud of the level I am managing to keep it at!)....and the added bonus, that if I step into the hospital prior to the baby actually crowning I will have to have another C-section, and likely a hysterectomy, as is hospital policy on third C-sections....
I spoke to an independent midwife over the phone at the beginning of my last pregnancy, and she told me that it was a load of rubbish about the 'too fat for a breech' and 'one c-section means always a c-section'. Without her encouragement I wouldn't have had the guts to stand up to the midwives and doctors as much as I have so far, and she also told me to demand a 30 week scan and to avoid induction as that can increase the chance of a scar rupture. Unfortunately, I couldn't afford a private midwife and as that pregnancy ended in a late miscarriage, I lost contact with the midwife who I'd spoken to over the phone.
My GP said after 2 C-sections I have a high risk of dying during labour. [Kmom note: This is totally bogus and not supported by the research at all.]
Aside from worrying about the labour going wrong, I have to admit this is a nice pregnancy---no rushing around for weekly antenatal appointments, no fortnightly blood tests to seen if my organs are failing, no monthly scans and far fewer lectures from 'professionals'!
I just wish people realised that just because I got this big my brain hasn't shrunk. I'm not stupid and I do have feelings. If belittling me or telling me obvious things like 'you need to lose weight' seriously helped the situation, I'd have been a size 0 years ago! I know I'm fat, I do have mirrors in my house and have to walk past shop windows during my week!
I have my scan for abnormal placenta (placenta previa and placenta [accreta], I believe) in 6 weeks, and then that's me back on my own until I give birth. We planned this pregnancy and it didn't seem so scary then, but now I have re-occuring nightmares.
Kmom's Follow-up Note: I was able to put this mother in touch with a couple of Independent Midwives in Britain so at least she has some better emotional support and a chance at other care. Thank you to those who have helped me find other resources for this mother.
As for British policy, I'm sure the attitude varies from consultant to consultant, but I'm hearing more and more stories of egregious size bias in the UK system. If you are a British woman of size and encounter this kind of treatment, I would remind you of the option of Independent Midwives. Yes, you'd have to pay out of pocket, but that's better than being subjected to crappy treatment and the risks of a cesarean you don't really need. And besides, many independent midwives will work with you to find a way to afford their care.
The same is true in the USA and Canada. Don't forget the choice of birth center or homebirth midwives. Yes, there are people who truly cannot afford that and have fewer choices, but too many people write it off as something they cannot possibly afford when there often ARE ways to make it work. Most midwives will find a way to help you afford it via sliding scale fees, payment plans, bartering, etc., and some insurances that say they "do not" cover homebirth actually do (mine did). Explore the possibilities thoroughly before you decide .
If at all possible, don't let cost keep you from having real childbirth choices and truly supportive care. It's priceless.
Tuesday, November 9, 2010
Breastfeeding Lowers the Risk for Diabetes And Other Maternal Disease Later In Life
There's an interesting new study out on breastfeeding and later diabetes in the mother.
It found that breastfeeding for at least one month lowered the mother's risk for developing diabetes later in life, even after controlling for many confounding factors such as physical activity status, BMI, etc.
Interestingly, women who had given birth but not breastfed for at least a month were at greater risk for diabetes later on than women who had never given birth at all. That was a surprising finding.
According to a discussion of the study at the Breastfeeding Medicine blog:
That means the study had only 1024 women who breastfed 1 month or longer, and while that's nothing to sneeze at, you really need a bigger data set, looking at a longer duration of breastfeeding, to prove population-wide effects most clearly.
Sadly, only 56% of the women in the study had breastfed their children for more than one month, another limitation of the study. This very low rate almost certainly reflects the age of the women in the study (40-78) and the active discouragement of breastfeeding many of the older women encountered.
Still, the study reports a striking finding and yet another reason to pursue breastfeeding.
It also points out what a disservice doctors did to women years ago when they actively discouraged breastfeeding, and the dangers of sweeping health policies that interfere with the way our bodies were designed to undergo pregnancy, birth, and postpartum.
Previous research on Breastfeeding and Later Diabetes
Some previous research has also tied length of breastfeeding to a lower risk for later diabetes in mothers.
A Chinese study (Villegas 2008) found that breastfeeding modestly lowered the risk for later diabetes in women followed for just under 5 years. They reported:
Keep in mind that this study also reflected our society's tendency towards short breastfeeding periods. They traced a woman's lifetime exposure to lactation (how long she breastfed all her children cumulatively), and their highest category was "greater than 23 months."
Greater than 23 months over your lifetime? Heck, I breastfed every single one of my kids at least that much each time, so how does that affect my risk for type 2 diabetes? My total lifetime exposure to lactation is right around 10 years. Does each additional cumulative year above 23 months help lower my risk that much more? The Chinese study cited above seems to suggest so, but its maximum lifetime exposure category was greater than or equal to 4 years.
I would love to seen the JAMA researchers collect information about a far greater lenth of total lactation in U.S. women than 23 months, but the fact is that our long-term breastfeeding rates in this country are so poor that they probably would have had trouble finding enough women to make such a sub-analysis statistically meaningful. How sad is that?
The study did have a small subanalysis on how lactation affected risk for diabetes in women with significant risk factors, like women with high BMIs, women who had gestational diabetes during pregnancy, etc. They found:
Regardless, breastfeeding is always worthwhile because of the tremendous immunological benefits and superior nutrition that breastmilk provides to the baby. Furthermore, there is research that suggests that breastfeeding is protective against the baby developing diabetes later in life. For example, Pettitt 1997 found that breastfed infants of Pima Indians (a group at very high risk of diabetes) had less than half the risk for diabetes later in life compared to those who had been bottlefed:
Another interesting finding was that the longer the period of exclusive breastfeeding, the greater the effect against diabetes. As the authors noted in their discussion:
However, on a personal note, despite research showing that long-term breastfeeding decreases the risk for type 2 diabetes, I still think there's a very strong possibility that I will get it at some point, despite my 10 years of breastfeeding exposure. PCOS reflects an underlying metabolic abnormality that no one knows how to "fix" at this point, and breastfeeding's improvements in insulin sensitivity and glucose tolerance probably only end up delaying the progression of that metabolic abnormality, not fixing it permanently.
Still, the less time you have diabetes, the less cumulative damage there is from it to your body, so even a delaying effect could have considerable impact on your long-term health. I hold that thought close. And of course I do what I can to lower my risk in other ways.
What About Other Maternal Diseases?
Findings from other studies show that longer breastfeeding duration is not only protective against diabetes, but also against hypertension, high cholesterol, and heart disease. In Schwarz 2009, for example, data from the large Women's Health Initiative study found that longer breastfeeding was associated with lower risk factors and less cardiovascular disease:
It found that breastfeeding for at least one month lowered the mother's risk for developing diabetes later in life, even after controlling for many confounding factors such as physical activity status, BMI, etc.
Interestingly, women who had given birth but not breastfed for at least a month were at greater risk for diabetes later on than women who had never given birth at all. That was a surprising finding.
According to a discussion of the study at the Breastfeeding Medicine blog:
The study included 2,233 women between the ages of 40 and 78 who were members of a large integrated health care delivery organization in California. Strikingly, one of every four mothers who had never breastfed had developed type 2 diabetes.
Mothers who had not breastfed were almost twice as likely to develop diabetes as women who had breastfed or women who had never given birth. These long-term differences were notable even after considering age, race, physical activity and other factors which affect risk of diabetes such as alcohol and tobacco use...
In other words, breastfeeding is part of the way mothers’ bodies recover from pregnancy. When this process is interupted, and an infant is fed something other than...mother’s milk, a mother’s body suffers.The authors did control for BMI and physical activity in the analysis, among other things. According to the study's abstract:
Multivariable logistic regression was used to control for age, parity, race, education, hysterectomy, physical activity, tobacco and alcohol use, family history of diabetes, and body mass index while examining the impact of duration, exclusivity, and consistency of lactation on risk of having developed type 2 diabetes.A couple of limitations of the study are its fairly small size --- 2233 women total, only 1828 of whom were mothers --- and its low threshold for length of breastfeeding (greater than or equal to 1 month of breastfeeding).
That means the study had only 1024 women who breastfed 1 month or longer, and while that's nothing to sneeze at, you really need a bigger data set, looking at a longer duration of breastfeeding, to prove population-wide effects most clearly.
Sadly, only 56% of the women in the study had breastfed their children for more than one month, another limitation of the study. This very low rate almost certainly reflects the age of the women in the study (40-78) and the active discouragement of breastfeeding many of the older women encountered.
Still, the study reports a striking finding and yet another reason to pursue breastfeeding.
It also points out what a disservice doctors did to women years ago when they actively discouraged breastfeeding, and the dangers of sweeping health policies that interfere with the way our bodies were designed to undergo pregnancy, birth, and postpartum.
Previous research on Breastfeeding and Later Diabetes
Some previous research has also tied length of breastfeeding to a lower risk for later diabetes in mothers.
A Chinese study (Villegas 2008) found that breastfeeding modestly lowered the risk for later diabetes in women followed for just under 5 years. They reported:
Women who had breastfed their children tended to have a lower risk of diabetes mellitus than those who had never breastfed [relative risk (RR)=0.88; 95% CI, 0.76-1.02; p=0.08]. Increasing duration of breast-feeding was associated with a reduced risk of type 2 diabetes mellitus. The fully adjusted RRs for lifetime breast-feeding duration were 1.00, 0.88, 0.89, 0.88, 0.75 and 0.68 (p trend=0.01) for 0, 0 to 0.99, 0.99 to 1.99, 1.99 to 2.99, 2.99 to 3.99, and greater than or = 4 years.One of the largest studies on breastfeeding and maternal diabetes was published in The Journal of the American Medical Assocation (Steube 2005). It used large datasets from the Nurses Health Study (121,700 women from 11 states) and the Nurses II Health Study (116,671 women from 14 states) to study the effect of lifetime duration of breastfeeding on later risk for diabetes. They found:
Among parous women, increasing duration of lactation was associated with a reduced risk of type 2 diabetes. For each additional year of lactation, women with a birth in the prior 15 years had a decrease in the risk of diabetes of 15% (95% confidence interval, 1%-27%) among NHS participants and of 14% (95% confidence interval, 7%-21%) among NHS II participants, controlling for current body mass index and other relevant risk factors for type 2 diabetes...
Longer duration of breastfeeding was associated with reduced incidence of type 2 diabetes in 2 large US cohorts of women. Lactation may reduce risk of type 2 diabetes in young and middle-aged women by improving glucose homeostasis.So there's a study with a very large dataset that found that breastfeeding -- the longer the better -- lowered the risk of mothers developing type 2 diabetes later on.
Keep in mind that this study also reflected our society's tendency towards short breastfeeding periods. They traced a woman's lifetime exposure to lactation (how long she breastfed all her children cumulatively), and their highest category was "greater than 23 months."
Greater than 23 months over your lifetime? Heck, I breastfed every single one of my kids at least that much each time, so how does that affect my risk for type 2 diabetes? My total lifetime exposure to lactation is right around 10 years. Does each additional cumulative year above 23 months help lower my risk that much more? The Chinese study cited above seems to suggest so, but its maximum lifetime exposure category was greater than or equal to 4 years.
I would love to seen the JAMA researchers collect information about a far greater lenth of total lactation in U.S. women than 23 months, but the fact is that our long-term breastfeeding rates in this country are so poor that they probably would have had trouble finding enough women to make such a sub-analysis statistically meaningful. How sad is that?
The study did have a small subanalysis on how lactation affected risk for diabetes in women with significant risk factors, like women with high BMIs, women who had gestational diabetes during pregnancy, etc. They found:
In the NHS II cohort, higher BMI at age 18 years was associated with shorter duration of breastfeeding, and in both cohorts, duration of lactation was inversely associated with family history of diabetes. Gestational diabetes was not associated with duration of lactation. Nevertheless, adjustment for family history and BMI at age 18 years did not substantially diminish the inverse association between lactation and risk of type 2 diabetes, suggesting that the association we observed was not an artifact of pregravid or pregnancy obesity and its associated insulin resistance. However, stratification by history of gestational diabetes revealed that in this high-risk group of women, lactation did not affect risk of subsequent type 2 diabetes.While it was encouraging that the protective effect of breastfeeding was present for women of size too, it was certainly discouraging that the protective effect did not seem present in women with gestational diabetes. However, a recent smaller tudy (Gunderson 2010) found a lower rate of metabolic syndrome in women with GD who breastfed longer, so further study seems to be indicated.
Regardless, breastfeeding is always worthwhile because of the tremendous immunological benefits and superior nutrition that breastmilk provides to the baby. Furthermore, there is research that suggests that breastfeeding is protective against the baby developing diabetes later in life. For example, Pettitt 1997 found that breastfed infants of Pima Indians (a group at very high risk of diabetes) had less than half the risk for diabetes later in life compared to those who had been bottlefed:
The odds ratio for NIDDM in exclusively breastfed people, compared with those exclusively bottlefed, was 0.41 (95% CI 0.18-0.93) adjusted for age, sex, birthdate, parental diabetes, and birthweight.One important question is how long the maternal benefits of breastfeeding last. The JAMA study did find that as time went on, the protective effects of breastfeeding against maternal diabetes began to fade. They noted:
In these analyses of 2 large prospective cohorts, we found that duration of lactation was inversely associated with risk of type 2 diabetes in young and middle-aged women, independent of other diabetes risk factors, including body mass index, diet, exercise, and smoking status. This association appeared to wane with time since last birth.Perhaps long-term breastfeeding has more of a delaying effect than a prevention effect on diabetes, especially in women with very strong risk factors for the disease.
Another interesting finding was that the longer the period of exclusive breastfeeding, the greater the effect against diabetes. As the authors noted in their discussion:
Our data on exclusive breastfeeding and duration stratified by parity suggest that the length and intensity of breastfeeding with each pregnancy affect the association with diabetes risk. We found that each year of exclusive breastfeeding was associated with a greater risk reduction than total breastfeeding. This may reflect the greater metabolic burden imposed by exclusive breastfeeding.
We also found that longer durations of breastfeeding per pregnancy were associated with a greater benefit, with 1 year’s lactation for 1 child resulting in a 44% reduction in age-adjusted risk, compared with 1 year’s lactation between 2 children resulting in a 24% reduction in risk.
It appears from our analysis of primiparous women that the beneficial association begins to accrue after 6 months of lactation. These data suggest that sustained lactation-associated metabolic changes have more profound effects on diabetes risk.This was an encouraging study because it shows in yet another way just how important breastfeeding is --- not just for the baby, but also for the mother.
However, on a personal note, despite research showing that long-term breastfeeding decreases the risk for type 2 diabetes, I still think there's a very strong possibility that I will get it at some point, despite my 10 years of breastfeeding exposure. PCOS reflects an underlying metabolic abnormality that no one knows how to "fix" at this point, and breastfeeding's improvements in insulin sensitivity and glucose tolerance probably only end up delaying the progression of that metabolic abnormality, not fixing it permanently.
Still, the less time you have diabetes, the less cumulative damage there is from it to your body, so even a delaying effect could have considerable impact on your long-term health. I hold that thought close. And of course I do what I can to lower my risk in other ways.
What About Other Maternal Diseases?
Findings from other studies show that longer breastfeeding duration is not only protective against diabetes, but also against hypertension, high cholesterol, and heart disease. In Schwarz 2009, for example, data from the large Women's Health Initiative study found that longer breastfeeding was associated with lower risk factors and less cardiovascular disease:
Dose-response relationships were seen; in fully adjusted models, women who reported a lifetime history of more than 12 months of lactation were less likely to have hypertension (odds ratio [OR] 0.88, P less than .001), diabetes (OR 0.80, P less than .001), hyperlipidemia (OR 0.81, P less than .001), or cardiovascular disease (OR 0.91, P=.008) than women who never breast-fed, but they were not less likely to be obese. In models adjusted for all above variables and BMI, similar relationships were seen...
Over an average of 7.9 years of postmenopausal participation in the Women's Health Initiative, women with a single live birth who breast-fed for 7-12 months were significantly less likely to develop cardiovascular disease (hazard ratio 0.72, 95% confidence interval 0.53-0.97) than women who never breast-fed...
Among postmenopausal women, increased duration of lactation was associated with a lower prevalence of hypertension, diabetes, hyperlipidemia, and cardiovascular disease.These findings were echoed in another large study (Steube 2009) that found that women who had a lifetime breastfeeding exposure of at least 2 years had lower risk for heart attacks/cardiovascular disease than parous women who had never breastfed.
Compared with parous women who had never breastfed, women who had breastfed for a lifetime total of 2 years or longer had 37% lower risk of coronary heart disease (95% confidence interval, 23-49%; P for trend less than .001), adjusting for age, parity, and stillbirth history. With additional adjustment for early-adult adiposity, parental history, and lifestyle factors, women who had breastfed for a lifetime total of 2 years or longer had a 23% lower risk of coronary heart disease (95% confidence interval, 6-38%; P for trend = .02) than women who had never breastfed.These findings mean that there's a lot of potential room for prevention (or or at least delaying) of diabetes, heart attacks, and other health issues, just by promoting higher rates of breastfeeding....and in particular, promoting breastfeeding for longer durations.
Thursday, November 4, 2010
Drowning in Fat Pregnant Women?
'Not waving but drowning': a study of the experiences and concerns of midwives and other health professionals caring for obese childbearing women. Schmied VA, Duff M, Dahlen HG, Mills AE, Kolt GS. Midwifery. 2010 Apr 6.
School of Nursing and Midwifery, College of Health and Science, University of Western Sydney, Building EB, Parramatta Campus, Locked Bag 1797, Penrith South DC, NSW 1797, Australia.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: to explore the experiences and concerns of health professionals who care for childbearing women who are obese.
BACKGROUND: obesity is increasing nationally and internationally and has been described as an epidemic. A number of studies have highlighted the risks associated with obesity during childbirth, yet few studies have investigated the experiences and concerns of midwives and other health professionals in providing care to these women.
DESIGN: a descriptive qualitative study using focus groups and face-to-face interviews to collect data. Interviews were audio recorded and transcribed verbatim. Data were analysed using thematic analysis.
SETTING: three maternity units in New South Wales, Australia.
PARTICIPANTS: participants included 34 midwives and three other health professionals.
FINDINGS: three major themes emerged from the data analysis: 'a creeping normality', 'feeling in the dark' and 'the runaway train'. The findings highlight a number of tensions or contradictions experienced by health professionals when caring for childbearing women who are obese.
These include, on the one hand, an increasing acceptance of obesity ('a creeping normality'), and on the other, the continuing stigma associated with obesity; the challenges of how to communicate effectively with pregnant women about their weight and the lack of resources, equipment and facilities ('feeling in the dark') to adequately care for obese childbearing women. Participants expressed concerns about how quickly the obesity epidemic appears to have impacted on maternity services ('the runaway train') and how services to meet the needs of these women are limited or generally not available.
CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: it was clear in this study that participants felt that they were 'not waving but drowning'. There was concern over the fact that the issue of obesity had moved faster than the health response to it. There were also concerns about how to communicate with obese women without altering the relationship. Continuity of care, training and skills development for health professionals, and expansion of limited services and facilities for these women are urgently needed.
PMID: 20381222
*Comments? Reactions? Suggestions?
School of Nursing and Midwifery, College of Health and Science, University of Western Sydney, Building EB, Parramatta Campus, Locked Bag 1797, Penrith South DC, NSW 1797, Australia.
Abstract
OBJECTIVE: to explore the experiences and concerns of health professionals who care for childbearing women who are obese.
BACKGROUND: obesity is increasing nationally and internationally and has been described as an epidemic. A number of studies have highlighted the risks associated with obesity during childbirth, yet few studies have investigated the experiences and concerns of midwives and other health professionals in providing care to these women.
DESIGN: a descriptive qualitative study using focus groups and face-to-face interviews to collect data. Interviews were audio recorded and transcribed verbatim. Data were analysed using thematic analysis.
SETTING: three maternity units in New South Wales, Australia.
PARTICIPANTS: participants included 34 midwives and three other health professionals.
FINDINGS: three major themes emerged from the data analysis: 'a creeping normality', 'feeling in the dark' and 'the runaway train'. The findings highlight a number of tensions or contradictions experienced by health professionals when caring for childbearing women who are obese.
These include, on the one hand, an increasing acceptance of obesity ('a creeping normality'), and on the other, the continuing stigma associated with obesity; the challenges of how to communicate effectively with pregnant women about their weight and the lack of resources, equipment and facilities ('feeling in the dark') to adequately care for obese childbearing women. Participants expressed concerns about how quickly the obesity epidemic appears to have impacted on maternity services ('the runaway train') and how services to meet the needs of these women are limited or generally not available.
CONCLUSION AND IMPLICATIONS FOR PRACTICE: it was clear in this study that participants felt that they were 'not waving but drowning'. There was concern over the fact that the issue of obesity had moved faster than the health response to it. There were also concerns about how to communicate with obese women without altering the relationship. Continuity of care, training and skills development for health professionals, and expansion of limited services and facilities for these women are urgently needed.
PMID: 20381222
*Comments? Reactions? Suggestions?
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)



