Thursday, October 9, 2008

Putting the Baby on a Diet Before It's Even Born

Two of the most important questions in the "fat women should gain less weight in pregnancy" movement are:
  1. Exactly what means should be used to achieve that smaller weight gain (i.e. do they recommend hypocaloric diets to obese women in pregnancy)

  2. What will providers do to enforce a particular weight gain if a fat woman starts to gain more than allowed despite normal nutrition
The answers to these questions are very important.

Normal Eating vs. Hypocaloric Diets

When advising their obese patients to aim for a smaller weight gain in pregnancy, some care providers simply mean "Eat healthy and normally, exercise regularly, and if you don't gain much weight, that's fine."

There's nothing wrong with this approach. As we have established, many larger women don't gain as much weight in pregnancy regardless of what they eat. It's not outside the range of normal. As long as they are eating healthfully and not restricting calories, whatever they gain (or don't gain) is fine.

[Of course, part of the problem with some doctors is their assumption that fat women OBVIOUSLY eat poorly so therefore eating healthy must represent a major change in intake and lifestyle and so they won't gain much weight at all. I can't tell you how much those assumptions irritate me. But I digress.]

But when some doctors advise gaining less weight in pregnancy, they mean manipulating their clients' food intake in order to achieve a lower weight gain. They're not just talking about eating healthfully and normally, they basically mean prescribing hypocaloric diets in pregnancy.

And if their clients start to gain more than what is "allowed," some doctors use scorched-earth techniques to limit that gain.

This is why the movement to limit weight gain in pregnant obese women is most alarming. This is the course of action that is dangerous and must be questioned.


What Is Normal Caloric Intake in Pregnancy?


Of course, a discussion of all this depends on what you think is a normal caloric intake in pregnancy.


Most sources just say it's 200-300 calories beyond your normal intake in the 2nd and 3rd trimester. Many don't specify a total number, but simply note that 200-300 calories extra is all you need and that doesn't take much extra food.

The sources that specify caloric intake say slightly different things:

  • The National Institute of Diabetes and Digestive and Kidney Diseases says that normal pregnancy caloric intake can vary from 1900-2500 calories, depending on your activity level, height, and energy needs
  • The RDA/DRI for pregnancy is usually cited as 2400-2500 calories in books

  • The American Dietetic Association says that most pregnant women need 2200-2900 calories during pregnancy
So even "official" sources differ somewhat in the total calories needed during pregnancy but let's assume around 2400 calories; a bit less if you are not very active.

Calorie Intake for Obese Pregnant Women

But if women of average size are "supposed" to eat somewhere around 2400 calories, give or take a bit, how many are fat women supposed to have?

Well, few sources will tie themselves to recommending that fat women only eat "x" calories in pregnancy....most just strongly imply that fat women should be eating far less than the norm.

What happens most often is that doctors and pregnancy books tell women they should NOT gain much weight in pregnancy.....and then they leave it up to the mother to deduce how to achieve such a limited gain.

So even if a care provider doesn't directly say, "Eat only xxxx calories," the advice to strongly limit weight gain indirectly is going to lead to hypocaloric intakes in many women.

Some sources are not afraid to come right out and recommend caloric restriction to women of size. For example, fat women with diabetes or gestational diabetes are routinely advised to restrict their calories because borderline starvation has been shown to lower blood sugar. So there are some studies that show that women have slightly lower blood sugar if they are given hypocaloric diets.....but is this really harmless to the baby?

The degree to which obese pregnant women with diabetes or GD should be restricted is controversial. Many programs limit obese women to somewhere around 1400-1600 calories. Some have limited women to as few as 1000-1200 calories.

Non-obese pregnant women with diabetes/GD, on the other hand, usually are given at least 2000 calories and often more like 2400-2500.

Please note---that's 500 - 1000 calores less per day!

My question is....why would it take fat pregnant women less calories to grow a baby than average-sized women? Isn't the actual caloric/energy cost of growing a healthy baby going to be similar among women of all sizes?

Sure, obese women have fat stores already and so we don't need extra calories for building up fat stores. So I could buy a few less calories per day.....but 500-1000 less calories per day?

That is a lot more than the difference between a bit of extra fat stores or not. With that kind of restriction it's difficult to believe the mother is getting all of what she optimally needs nutritionally.

But it's not just GD mothers that are getting hypocaloric advice. Although such drastic cuts are by no means universally advised, it's still not uncommon for women of size to be given hypocaloric diets in pregnancy.

Here's a website....from a registered dietician no less!.....that recommends that obese women select her 1500-1700 calorie plan, while overweight women get to whoop it up on her 1800-2000 calorie plan. Whooohooo.

And it really isn't all that uncommon for obese women to be told to limit her calorie intake to somewhere in the 1500-1800 calorie range.

Real-Life Dietary Advice

But is this kind of restriction just the result of a few raving lunatics here and there, or is this kind of advice really common?

Here is a sampling of just a few of the emails I've seen over the years, documenting reduced caloric diet advice during pregnancy:

  • When I was pregnant with my first, [the doctor] had me on a 1800 calorie diet
  • My [relative] will be having her baby [soon]. They just tested her a few weeks ago and she says her sugar is "borderline." They put her on a 1500 calorie diet.
  • [At 22 weeks pregnant], the OB told me I probably had gestational diabetes. [He] suggested I go on a 1500 calorie diabetic diet.
  • While [pregnant] with *twins*, the nutritionist put me on an *1800* calorie diet
  • At our first meeting the nutritionist very patronizingly recommended we all eat as much aspartame as possible before introducing us to our new diet, one that I would later calculate to add up to roughly 1300 calories per day.
  • My fat-phobic OB...put me on an 1000-1100 calorie a day diet with baby #4

Although 1500 and 1800 calorie diets in pregnancy are most common, I have read studies (yes, recent ones!) where they had PREGNANT fat women on 1200 calorie diets! It's not common but unbelievably, it does still happen.

WHAT are they thinking?

The Scorched-Earth Approach

And the further question is, if women gain more weight than their doctor tells them they may gain....what then?

[Note: Some of these stories have been mentioned before, but they bear repeating in this context.]

Is she going to be harassed every time she gets weighed at the doctor's?

  • Although my OB is a decent man, he constantly hammers me about my weight (I've lost 3 lbs. during this pregnancy so far), and I am scared to death to step on the scales at my appointments

Is she going to be sent to Weight Watchers or Jenny Craig in an effort to keep her weight gain down?

  • [The nurse-midwives at the birth center] sent me to Weight Watchers and told me not to gain weight or they wouldn't be able to keep me.
  • After meeting with the OB nurse, she said that I could go back to WW.
  • I am 9 weeks pregnant and [my midwife] said I need to go on a diet. She said I can go back to Jenny Craig, like I was doing before I was pregnant.

Is she told to diet during the last trimester of pregnancy when the baby is really developing neurologically?

  • I was told not to gain any more weight when I reached about 7½ months with my first 2 pregnancies. So I’d try to starve (and not succeed) during the 8th & 9th month when my little guys were trying to grow their brains
  • I have gained 18 pounds so far..[the doctor] had a fit. She told me...I had better lose weight. I asked, "Do you mean not gain any more?" and she said, "NO, you need to LOSE weight.”
  • [The doctor] said I mustn't gain more than 20 lbs., 15 was even better, because I was overweight. If I gained more, he'd put me on a diet...I left the doctor when I was 5 months pregnant. [My] cousin stayed, and obeyed. When she reached her weight limit he [did] put her on a diet.

Is she going to be told to go to extremes in order to limit weight gain?

  • [The OB told me, while pregnant with twins, to drink Slim-Fast in order to keep down my weight gain.]

This is one of the most critical questions. What interventions are going to be used to curtail or prevent an "excessive" weight gain? And how can we be sure they are not doing more harm than good?

Conclusion

Let's be fair. Most doctors these days do not advise fat women to diet during pregnancy, but there is a movement afoot return to this, and some doctors (and even some midwives) are advising reduced caloric diets.

Furthermore, the common advice for obese women to gain minimally during pregnancy means that many of them will adopt reduced calorie diets during pregnancy in order to achieve that goal.

And if the Institute of Medicine (IOM) revises its weight gain guidelines (as they are currently considering doing), many doctors (and even midwives) will see this as a justification to put more and more obese women on reduced calorie diets.

And this sort of thing has the potential for far-reaching consequences.

You know that the obesity hysteridemic in this country is way out of control when they are, in effect, promoting putting the baby on a diet before it's even born.

Next: The potential effects of fetal undernutrition

Monday, October 6, 2008

A Little Historical Perspective on Weight Gain in Pregnancy

Preventing Pre-Eclampsia and Big Babies

Years ago, doctors regularly advised women to strictly limit their weight gain in pregnancy. They viewed this as a way to prevent pre-eclampsia (high blood pressure issues in pregnancy) because one of the symptoms of pre-eclampsia is a high weight gain from retaining fluids.

They decided that the large weight gain must be causing the pre-eclampsia, and therefore, preventing a large weight gain would help prevent pre-eclampsia.

They also wanted to prevent women from having large babies, so they strongly counseled women of all sizes to limit weight gain in order to get a smaller baby.

[Not only did they restrict weight gain, they also advised women to smoke to keep down their weight gain and fetal size, or to use diuretics to prevent fluid retention, both of which were later discovered to cause serious problems in pregnancy. Doh!]

All this was in the name of a worthy goal----preventing pre-eclampsia, which can be a very serious complication of pregnancy, and which is potentially deadly to both mother and baby. Their hearts were in the right place, but their methods were ill-considered and extreme.

Furthermore, the safety of this approach had not been established before it was adopted, as is unfortunately common in obstetrics. (Think of all the babies damaged when their mothers' doctors prescribed DES.)

Unforseen Consequences: Underweight Babies

What they found out later was that these extreme approaches actually CAUSED more harm then they averted. Many babies were born too small or very stressed; some no doubt died as a result of these interventions.

We also know that babies born underweight or "small-for-gestational age" (SGA) have more health problems later in life so the consequences of restricted fetal growth go far beyond problems at birth.

This is why the Institue of Medicine (IOM) adopted new weight gain guidelines in 1990, raising the recommended weight gains in pregnancy. They noted years of research that showed that low weight-gain in pregnancy caused an increase in SGA babies....in women of all sizes.

They also noted that in the 70s, when weight gain restrictions began easing up, there was a strong reduction in the occurrence of SGA babies.

So they raised the guidelines, and then began the big job of trying to get doctors to believe in this new system of weight gain guidelines. It was a difficult job.

Current IOM Weight Gain Guidelines

The old weight gain recommendations vary by source and by decade to some extent, but generally they fell somewhere between 10-20 lbs. By the 1970s, several organizations set a desirable range of around 20-25 lbs. or so.

The IOM raised these guidelines...but not across the board. They differentiated weight gain recommendations by BMI. Their guidelines were:

  • "Underweight" women: 28 - 40 lb. weight gain
  • "Normal" Weight women: 25 - 35 lb. weight gain
  • "Overweight" women: 15 - 25 lb. weight gain
  • "Obese" women: at least 15 lb. weight gain

The reason they had different weight goals by BMI was because weight gain's effect on fetal size varies by pre-pregnancy BMI.

The highest risk for SGA babies was in underweight women who didn't gain enough weight in pregnancy. Research clearly shows that gaining more weight can prevent many SGA babies in this group, so they raised the upper limit in this group to 40 lbs.

The effect of greater weight gain in preventing SGA babies is less pronounced as maternal size goes up; thus they felt that smaller gains were justifiable in the other groups. Still, women of "normal" size were now allowed to gain up to 35 lbs., which was a little more lenient than in the past.

The effect of weight gain on SGA babies is least strong in overweight and obese women, so therefore they felt only a small weight gain was appropriate in this group.

However, they did note that very small weight gains/losses caused increases in SGA babies across the board, even in obese women, and therefore they were not comfortable in recommending <15>This has been very controversial; many doctors still believed that obese women should gain little or nothing in pregnancy. They believed a larger gain in fat women would lead to a stronger risk of....ta da!!....pre-eclampsia. And big babies. And cesareans. And would result in more obesity after the pregnancy because of retained weight. So they've been chafing under these "guidelines" ever since.

Pressure to Revise the Weight Gain Guidelines

This chafing over guidelines has reached fever pitch now as a result of the obesity hysteridemic. More and more are pressing for lower weight gain goals.

Recently, a number of doctors have banded together to pressure the IOM to revise its guidelines on weight gain in pregnancy, and in particular to lower the guidelines for obese women.

They are hawking the same old concept again, namely: Large women have a higher risk for pre-eclampsia and big babies, so if we prevent a large weight gain in them, we'll lower the risk for pre-eclampsia and get smaller babies!! And prevent further obesity afterwards!!

Know what guidelines they are proposing for obese women?

  • Class I obese women (BMI 30-34.9): 10 - 25 lbs. gain
  • Class II obese women (BMI 35-39.9): 0 - 9 lbs. gain
  • Class III obese women (BMI >40): 0 - 9 lbs. loss
That's right, they are proposing that some fat women BE REQUIRED TO LOSE WEIGHT DURING PREGNANCY.

Alas, their P.R. campaign is working; the IOM has begun meetings to discuss revising weight gain guidelines again.


Coming Soon: Deconstructing the research being used to justify lowering these cutoffs.

Monday, September 29, 2008

Suicide by Pregnancy?

I recently received yet another story of tremendous size bigotry from an OB, who basically tried to scare this poor woman to death about being pregnant at her size, and who more or less told her she had committed suicide by daring to be pregnant at her size.

I can't tell you how much stories like these infuriate me; NO ONE should have to put up with this kind of bullsh*t treatment. People in the healthcare professions should be ASHAMED that this kind of medical bullying occurs. Yet sadly, it is all too common with women of size, especially in obstetrics.

I have permission to quote her email; I have edited it slightly.

I am 31 years old and I weigh 400 pounds. The last time I was pregnant, which sadly ended in miscarriage, I weighed 350 pounds...I've overcome as best as I can and I want to try for a baby again.

My current OBGYN says he can get me and my baby safely through pregnancy, and that he has lots of history with obese women and pregnancy. I want to believe him, but I worry because of what another doctor told me.... and because of what I've been brainwashed for years to believe.

Anyway, when I was pregnant, I went to a doctor who CONDEMNED me the moment I walked into the office. He told me that I wasn't going to make it alive through my pregnancy and that they would "have to take drastic measures to try save me before they would even attempt to save my baby" etc.

He kept saying I shouldn't have gotten pregnant, that I had in a sense, committed suicide! He told me that my heart was going to give out, or that I was going to stroke out while attempting to push my LARGE baby out, therefore I was going to have a c-section. He told me that I was going to have massive blood clots in my legs and severe pre-eclampsia.

I left his office completely panicked and in tears. I was shaking so bad I could hardly walk and all he did was look at me and said in a cold voice with no emotion at all, "It's really scary, isn't it."

I regretted all the years of trying and numerous fertility treatments (I have PCOS) to get pregnant. It was 4 days later that I lost my very much-loved baby. I believe it was a good part due to the stress and fear that he caused me.


I'm sorry; this kind of treatment is INEXCUSABLE.

Yes, statistically there are more risks in pregnancy with obesity, and yes, these risks probably do go up somewhat as BMI increases, but at NO point do they reach 100% or even remotely close. Being at increased risk for a problem does not mean you will inevitably experience it, and in the meantime there are proactive things you can do to lessen your risks for problems. Even if you do experience a problem, most of the time there are treatments that will help. Most of the time things are fine.

Let me say it once again. MOST women of size have healthy babies just fine.

"Even" in the 400 lb. size range, I know of a NUMBER of women who have had healthy pregnancies and babies. Most in that size range are not "allowed" to labor (or the doctors induce their labor early and then they end up with a cesarean) so the cesarean rate in this group is very high....but I DO know women of that size range who have had vaginal births too. None that I have known have died or even come close. None have stroked out during labor or birth; none have had heart attacks or any of the other dire things this doctor said would surely come to pass.


The largest-sized woman I have come upon so far in case reports in the medical literature was around 500 lbs. She did NOT experience gestational diabetes, she did NOT experience blood pressure issues, she did NOT have blood clots, or any of the other terrors this doctor would have said she obviously would get. The only complication she had was asthma, and she and baby were just fine. As is so common with obstetrics, they did pressure her to have a cesarean, and surgery on a person of that size is more difficult and challenging.....but it went just fine. There were no complications at all.

Although certainly there is more risk for complications, it is NOT a bygone conclusion that bad things will happen, even in women of very large sizes.

Medical bullying is a blight upon the profession. That's not to say that doctors and midwives cannot share that obese women are at increased risk for some complications; they would not be doing their jobs adequately if they didn't share these possible concerns. However, HOW you discuss these things makes all the difference in the world.

You can present possible risks without implying that they no doubt will happen; it's important to present the risks in proper perspective. The truth is that they do NOT happen to the majority of women of size, and the worst-case scenario very rarely happens. You can also present them in a neutral way, without the judgment and harshness and condemnation so often used on women of size.

Furthermore, you can present ways to be proactive that can help lessen the risks for complications. Excellent nutrition (not dieting) and regular exercise go a long way towards lessening the risks, and for women at particular risk, there are other options too, such as using metformin prophylactically or considering low-dose aspirin (with medical supervision). These are all things that can be discussed calmly and reasonably, without having to resort to hyperbole and scare tactics.

The kind of over-the-top BULLYING shown above is a total exaggeration of the risks, and basically amounts to trying to scare women of size out of having babies rather than giving her reasonable counseling about possible risks. It is a unique and insidious form of bullying and eugenics and IT MUST STOP.

Sunday, September 21, 2008

My Own Experience With Hypothyroidism

Previously, I wrote about hypothyroidism issues in pregnancy in general. Now I want to write a little bit about my own experiences with hypothyroidism. It's a widely varied journey, but one with lessons for others who think they might have thyroid issues, so I want to share it.

Hypothyroidism Begins with a Roar

When I was younger, everyone always considered me "overweight" and I had lots of pressure to diet, but I wasn't really "obese" at that point. Then the PCOS and hypothyroidism really hit.

Starting at about age 16, I began skipping periods. Scared me to death, but it didn't happen that often and I knew periods could be variable, so I figured I was just one of those people who was a bit irregular.

Then around age 17 I began gaining weight and lots of it. I had been on a diet recently so I just figured it was re-gain (and I'm sure some of it was). Looking back now, though, I think much of it was also the big gain that often accompanies the double-whammy of PCOS and hypothyroidism.

Between 17 and 21, I gained about 100 lbs. That's right, a hundred pounds. [Wow, it's upsetting even writing that; I can still hardly wrap my mind around it.] It happened without changing any of my food habits or anything else significantly. It was devastating. But I couldn't seem to stop it, no matter what I did........and I did a lot.

I fought it with everything I could think of. I cut back on food......but I kept gaining. I thought maybe it was dorm food, so I moved out of the dorm and started cooking for myself.....but still kept gaining. I went to Weight Watchers again......but kept battling crazy fluctuations of weight. I signed up for a college fitness class and spent an extreme semester exercising like crazy.....yet I gained 25 lbs. in that semester alone, WHILE doing all that exercise and being on Weight Watchers. (And no, that was definitely not muscle gain.) The coach thought I was lying and that I must be a binge eater....but I wasn't.

Dealing with Doctors: Round One

During this time period, I went to the doctor a couple of times and they tested my thyroid levels. I was told they were always "normal" or "a little on the low/borderline side, but nothing that needs treatment." So we concluded that thyroid wasn't an issue for me, despite the tremendous weight gain I was experiencing.

Now, of course, I wish I had the exact results from those tests to look at. Back then, the ranges considered "normal" were much wider, and I suspect strongly that I fell into a gray area, where TSH tests are within normal limits as they were defined then but would now be considered abnormal by many endocrinologists.
[So lesson #1: Always get your exact test results and know the range the lab used to define "normal," and then keep those results so you can track them over time.]

I finally got so desperate about the weight gain that I signed up with a radical commercial diet center. 500 calories a day, plus vitamin/mineral supplements. Seriously. I did that for 6 months. I lost 50 lbs. all right, but it was NOT a "good" or "healthy" loss. I'm lucky I didn't seriously damage my body. That was the turnaround that began my fat-acceptance journey.

I ended that diet for many reasons, but in particular because by the end of 6 months, I began gaining weight on 500 calories per day. Yes, GAINING weight on 500 calories a day.

That's when I realized that the whole "calories in/calories out" mantra was full of crap, and that there must be something more to all this. The math didn't add up; there must be more variables than doctors realized.

I also began realizing that the whole dieting thing was taking me places mentally and emotionally that I didn't want to go, and I felt for my own health and sanity I had to stop. So I did. (Smartest thing I ever did.)

For the time being, I gave up on seeing doctors and concluded I must not have any thyroid issues. I knew something was going on, but figured that yo-yo dieting had screwed everything up. I gave up on trying to find answers and tried to concentrate on stabilizing my weight.

Dealing with Doctors: Round Two

Fast forward a few years. I was married and working at a career, but seeing more and more signs of problems. I was skipping periods again, I had many other symptoms that were bothering me, and I was constantly fighting my weight. I finally decided I had to go consult an endocrinologist because I just knew something was wrong.

We had just moved to a new town so we picked an endocrinologist from the phone book. I went there and filled out all the paperwork, extensively describing my symptoms and history. The doctor didn't even really look at it. He was very disdainful, very dismissive. He didn't take my concerns seriously at all.

He told me I was just looking for an excuse for being fat.

I was devastated and didn't go back to a doctor for several years. I continued to skip periods and to experience other worsening symptoms, but I couldn't see going back to a doctor and being dismissed like that again. So I only kept getting worse.
[Lesson #2: Don't give up if you can't find a doctor who will take your concerns seriously; don't let a fat-phobic doctor keep you from getting the care that you need. Find a new doctor!]

Dealing with Doctors: Round Three

Finally a friend gave me a book about thyroid issues. I read it and went, wow, that's me. I got a basal body thermometer and starting taking my basal body temps (BBTs) and sure enough, they were in the basement, and I had so many of the other symptoms they listed too.

This friend recommended a doctor to me who was trained in complementary medicine as well as traditional medicine, and who might be more inclined to listen to what I said. I was dubious.....complementary medicine?......but decided to give it a shot.

This doctor was SUCH a breath of fresh air. He was so nice, and he really listened to me. He didn't discount what I said just because I was fat and therefore "must" be lying about food. He asked me lots of questions and took a lot of time with me. He wasn't a whacked-out hippie; he knew his science and used traditional treatments, but he also kept an open mind to the possibility that traditional views of medicine might be missing some things. He was a gem.

My blood tests were nominally in the "normal" range. However, he said that my symptoms certainly pointed to hypothyroidism and he took all the BBT data I brought seriously. He suggested a "trial of meds"----putting me on a low dose of thyroid meds (Armour thyroid) for a short period of time to see what happened, re-doing the blood tests, and then re-evaluating at that point.

WOW, what a difference. I felt SO much better, so quickly. I had energy again, my periods became regular again, my weight dropped without any change of habits, my skin was no longer like a lizard's.....I felt like a new person.

We tested my levels again after a few weeks on the thyroid meds, and my levels were much better within the normal range instead of at the edges of normal. He felt that if I truly didn't have hypothyroidism, the meds would have made my TSH levels go into the abnormal range, when what they actually did was get them into a better range. So he felt that this (plus the symptom improvement) merited a diagnosis of hypothyroidism. We continued my medication.

Dealing with Doctors: Round Four

A few years later, my insurance changed and this doctor was no longer "in-network." So I switched to an internist closer to home, thinking it wouldn't make that much difference.

Unfortunately, he insisted I switch to Synthryoid instead of Armour Thyroid for meds, and I never quite had the same level of benefit again. But I guess I should count my blessings that he kept me on some form of thyroid meds; some doctors might have taken me off them completely.
[Lesson #3: Not all doctors are equally knowledgeable and willing to work with you on your thyroid issues. It's worth it to hold out for a good one.]
My Experiences with Pregnancy and Thyroid Issues

After that, we moved and I began my family. I am so relieved that I didn't start a family before my hypothyroidism was discovered and treated....who knows how things would have gone without it!

I think having my thyroid levels normalized helped me conceive without any problems (despite my age and size) and it helped me keep my pregnancies normal. We tested my levels periodically in my pregnancies and they never went haywire at all, so I was lucky in that way.

However, after baby #4, I did experience postpartum thyroiditis. I never experienced the hyPERthyroidism that often accompanies this, but boy howdy, did I experience the hypo part! I gained a lot of weight postpartum (normally I lose weight postpartum while breastfeeding), I was exhausted, I was cold all the time, and my skin started looking lizardy again. Yet even with all my years of experience with hypothyroidism, I didn't recognize that my thyroid had gone whacko until many many months later, in retrospect. I just failed to see the patterns.
[Lesson #4: A history of thyroid issues means you may be particular vulnerable to thyroid wackiness during vulnerable times such as pregnancy, postpartum, menopause, and advanced age.]

I'd had my thyroid levels tested at about 4 months postpartum, as part of my yearly thyroid tests. My TSH came back higher than usual, but still well within normal so they didn't adjust my dosage. Now, we don't know how much it fluctuated before and after that; my personal opinion is that it was probably bouncing all over the place and we just didn't know it because we only tested once.
[Lesson #5: If you suspect your thyroid is out of whack, you may need to test multiple times over a short period of time to catch the variations.]

Fine-Tuning Thyroid Meds

Over the years, with much experimentation, I have found that I feel best when my TSH levels are between 1.0 and 1.5, and any even small deviation over that really affects how I feel, the stability of my weight, and skin etc. symptoms. So even though my TSH postpartum had come back "normal," it wasn't normal for me and where I feel best.
[Lesson #6: Some people are exquisitely sensitive to even small changes in TSH levels, and even when levels test "normal," they may not be optimal for that person.]

I also found that I feel better with a combo of both T4 and T3 meds; if I take only Armour, my TSH may be fine but my T3 numbers are too high. If I take only T4 meds (Synthroid and its equivalents), I don't feel as well. It's a combo of a little of both that seems to keep me closest to normal. Makes for twice the prescription co-pay, but it's worth it.

[Lesson #7: Many people feel better when using alternatives to Synthroid, or combos of T3 and T4 meds. However, it's important to track not only your TSH but also your T3 and T4 numbers, as these may be out of whack even when the TSH is fine.]

After going on thyroid meds, I never skipped a period again. EVER. Many of the skin problems I'd experienced (cystic acne, boils etc.) lessened significantly. I was no longer gaining weight uncontrollably. Keeping a stable weight was still a struggle, but not a losing struggle anymore. And I just felt so much better, in so many ways.

Now, I have to be honest.....I didn't experience a total resolution of all my symptoms. I still have some of them.....even after fiddling with my dosage, even after getting meds with both T3 and T4 in them, even after doing all the things I'm "supposed" to do.

There may still be something out there to try yet, or there may be some other problem complicating full resolution......but I also have to concede the possibility that hypothyroidism may be more complex than we think, and even with thyroid meds my symptoms may never be fully resolved. I hope doctors will keep researching hypothyroidism and its implications because there are a lot of people out there like me that experience help but not full resolution of symptoms with treatment.

But the improvement I have experienced has been remarkable in so many ways that I am grateful that I persevered in getting diagnosed and treated. It has absolutely been worth the time and trouble.

[Lesson #8: Not everyone gets full remission of symptoms even with best current treatment, but perhaps as they learn more about hypothyroidism and its co-morbidities, treatment will get even more effective. Partial remission of symptoms is far better than no remission at all.]

Hypothyroidism Needs to be Taken More Seriously

My experience (and the similar experience of many others) tells me that many symptomatic people with "borderline" TSH readings actually benefit significantly from treatment to optimize their thyroid levels, yet there is a great deal of resistance to this in the medical community.

Although more study is needed, some research does seem to indicate that people of size and those with PCOS do tend to have thyroid issues (especially the "borderline" kind) more frequently. People in these categories should have their thyroid levels tested regularly throughout their life, as a precaution, and especially before pregnancy.

Yet it's still so hard to get doctors to take "borderline" TSH readings and symptoms seriously, or to get newer diagnostic standards widely accepted by most doctors and labs. Far too many people are still being told they are "fine" when they are not, or are not being tested at all.

This is a story that is so common among people of size. We tell doctors over and over that something is wrong, that something is "off" and we just don't feel right. And over and over, we are not taken seriously, or it's all blamed on being fat.

The tremendous resistance to our experiences and concerns seems to come from the belief among some healthcare professionals that fat people are "just looking for an excuse for being fat" and you can't really trust what they say. And that if they'd just get off their butts and lose weight, all these issues would be resolved.

For a while, there was some headway on this problem, but now I see the pendulum swinging back again towards blaming and closed minds. If you protest that something else besides "calorie math" must be going on, they think you are making excuses for yourself, lying about what you actually eat, or are simply in denial.

Healthcare professionals simply MUST start stepping outside the paradigm that obesity itself is the main cause of all problems in fat people, and that weight loss is the only way to really deal with these issues.

They must consider the possibility that obesity may sometimes simply be a symptom of other issues, instead of the cause of them. They must recognize that permanent weight loss is difficult and not just a matter of willpower. They must start recognizing that this focus on weight loss at all costs often causes more problems than it fixes. And they must start looking for ways to improve symptoms and quality of life in people of size that don't necessarily involve weight loss as the "fix."

And they simply must lose the judgmental attitudes that fat people are always simply looking for an excuse for being fat.

Final Advice to Those with Hypothyroidism

If you suspect you may have hypothyroidism, or if you have already been diagnosed and are working with a healthcare professional, inform yourself as much as possible about thyroid issues. Find a healthcare professional who listens to your concerns, will work with you to find the best possible meds and dosage, and keep reading the research.

There are good, decent healthcare professionals out there that will take your concerns seriously; it's really worth finding them. But the first step is informing yourself and becoming an advocate for your own needs.

Sunday, September 14, 2008

Hypothyroidism and Pregnancy

Over at the blog, the-f-word, the author has had a series of recent posts discussing hypothyroidism. This is a topic of special importance when discussing pregnancy and postpartum issues so I thought I'd highlight it here too.

[There's no need to repeat all her information, so we'll just mention a few points particularly pertinent to pregnancy and postpartum, and then tell you to GO READ IT. ]

Many fat folk have undiscovered or undertreated hypothyroidism. Doctors often do not take hypothyroidism concerns seriously in fat people, thinking they are trying to excuse their supposed eating problems. So it can be difficult to find a care provider who is willing to take these concerns seriously or test them in any meaningful way.

Furthermore, exactly what TSH levels should be used to diagnose hypothyroidism is controversial. Newer diagnostic cutoffs favored by some medical groups tend to diagnose and treat more people; the older cutoffs miss a lot of borderline or "subclinical" cases. Yet these folks often experience typical hyothyroidism symptoms like:
  • obesity/unexplained weight gain/difficulty losing weight
  • tiredness/fatigue
  • very dry or cracked skin
  • menstrual problems/irregularity
  • dry/brittle hair and nail changes
  • muscle or joint aches and pains
  • feeling cold a lot/intolerance to temperature variations
  • depression issues
  • "brain fog"
  • constipation
  • fertility issues
If you have a combination of these symptoms you might want to consider thyroid testing. However, if you do have thyroid testing, BE SURE TO GET YOUR EXACT RESULTS AND THE DIAGNOSTIC CUTOFFS USED TO DEFINE "NORMAL." Compare your exact results to the levels considered "normal" and see where your levels fall.

Too often, people are told their results are "normal" when in fact, closer examination may show that their results are borderline (and should be watched and retested later) or are actually abnormal when using the newer, lower cutoffs.

[I really can't stress this enough. Do NOT just accept a "normal" or "abnormal" on lab tests; actually get the numerical results, the range the lab used to determine "normal" and compare them. Then request a copy of your lab results and keep a record of them so you can track them over time. Remember, lots of people who may have been diagnosed as "normal" in the past might now be considered to have "abnormal" results now under revised guidelines.]

Thyroid Tests and Pregnancy Concerns

If you are considering pregnancy at any time in the near future, you might want to have your thyroid levels checked as a precaution beforehand, even if you don't suspect a problem.

Some doctors these days recommend that ALL women have their thyroid levels checked before or during pregnancy, but it's not certain whether this broad a testing distribution is really justified by research. More study is needed before such widespread testing is implemented.

However, for women of size (and especially those with PCOS), it probably is sensible to have the thyroid levels checked before pregnancy. Although not all research agrees, some research suggests that obese people tend to have higher rates of both overt and subclinical (or "mild") hypothyroidism. Other research suggests that women with PCOS also have more subclinical hypothyroidism. Therefore, it probably makes sense for women in these two groups to have their thyroid levels checked carefully, preferably well before conception.

For some women, it also makes sense to check thyroid levels during pregnancy as well. If you have had thyroid issues in the past (or suspect them), are being treated currently for hypothyroidism, or if you have a strong family history of hypothyroidism, you should have your levels monitored regularly during pregnancy.
Even if your hypothyroidism was well-controlled beforehand, it may not stay that way during pregnancy, and can change fairly quickly. Therefore, periodic testing during pregnancy is a must for those with hypothyroidism.

Your levels should be measured about every trimester, on average. However, some women need to increase their thyroid medication dosage even early in the first trimester. If your thyroid levels historically have bounced around a lot, you may be particularly susceptible to early problems and should be closely monitored. If you haven't seen your midwife or OB yet, your family doctor/GP can help you get the tests you need until you have a care provider for your pregnancy.

Does Hypothyroidism Make a Pregnancy High-Risk?

Some women with hypothyroidism have been told that their hypothyroidism makes them "high risk" and so they are not good candidates for a birth center or home birth, or that they should only see an OB or even a perinatologist during pregnancy.

However, it's only UNTREATED or INADEQUATELY TREATED hypothyroidism that is really a risk. As long as thyroid levels are tested periodically and treated adequately, women with hypothyroidism don't need to be treated as "high-risk." Most women with adequately-treated hypothyroidism have normal, healthy pregnancies and babies. (I did, four times, and so have many other women with hypothyroidism that I know.)

Unless thyroid levels are particularly difficult to keep under control, women with hypothyroidism can see any type of provider they wish...nurse-midwife, homebirth midwife, family doctor, or OB.

Nurse-midwives and doctors all can order thyroid tests and adjust prescriptions as needed; homebirth midwives often can order lab tests and work with consulting doctors to make prescription adjustments if needed. Any of these types of care providers can provide care for a pregnant woman with hypothyroidism.
Some women prefer to be followed by both a pregnancy care provider and an endocrinologist, as they feel their endocrinologists may pay closer attention to smaller changes in their thyroid levels. Others do not feel the need for care beyond their normal provider.

Hypothyroidism does not preclude you from birthing at home or at a birth center, nor does it necessitate a high-risk provider. Choose whatever provider you feel most comfortable with. However it's a good idea to ask your care provider about his/her plan for monitoring your thyroid levels during pregnancy; some care providers are more knowledgeable about thyroid concerns than others. Be sure they also have a plan for checking your levels postpartum.

Postpartum Thyroid Issues

After the baby is born, many women experience thyroid difficulties. Even if you've never had thyroid issues in your life, were fine during pregnancy, or were totally fine in all previous pregnancies, you may still develop postpartum thyroiditis. It is important to watch ALL women carefully for thryoid symptoms after birth.

Postpartum thyroiditis classically involves a period of hyPERthyroidism (thyroid is overactive) followed by hyPOthyroidism (thyroid is underactive). However, be aware that some women skip straight to the hypothyroidism part and never experience any real signs of hyperthyroidism first.

About 5-10% of all women develop postpartum thyroiditis, but the incidence is higher in women with a history of thyroid or autoimmune issues. Doctors often miss postpartum thyroiditis since they usually only see you briefly several weeks after the baby is born. And with a new baby, many moms tend to dismiss symptoms or don't take time to have them investigated. So postpartum thyroiditis tends to be underdiagnosed and the incidence may be higher than generally acknowledged.

Women experiencing difficulty with breastmilk production should have their thyroid levels tested (as well as testing for anemia etc.), because this can affect milk production. There are many other possible causes of low milk production, of course, but this is one that is often missed. And because thyroid levels can fluctuate widely after childbirth, repeated testing may be needed. Although most women with a history of thyroid issues can breastfeed without problems, they should be particularly watchful for possible thyroid issues.
Women who gain a lot of weight in the months after giving birth (despite normal intake and despite breastfeeding) may also be experiencing postpartum thyroid issues and should be checked.

Women who experienced severe bleeding during and after birth should also be aware of a potential for thyroid problems. Sometimes severe hemorrhage can damage the pituitary gland, which in turn can lead to hypothyroidism. This is called Sheehan's Syndrome. As one website notes:

Rarely, hypothyroidism after childbirth is caused by Sheehan's syndrome, also called postpartum hypopituitarism. This condition may occur in women who have severe blood loss during childbirth resulting in damage to the anterior pituitary gland.

Finally, women who experience thyroid issues during and after pregnancy should also be warned to watch for possible recurrence of thyroid issues during perimenopause and menopause. Advanced age is another period of time when women are particularly vulnerable to hypothyroidism too. Thus, periodic thyroid tests should become part of women's life-long care.

Thyroid Medicine and Supplements

Hypothyroid medications are generally considered safe during pregnancy and breastfeeding. Remember, these medications are simply putting back into your body what should already be there. Babies are at far greater danger from untreated hypothyroidism than they are from typical hypothyroid medications. Just make sure to monitor your thyroid levels periodically.

I know of no "official" correlation between hypothyroidism and vitamin D levels, but it's my observation that many folks with hypothyroidism also have chronically low vitamin D levels as well. Whether there's a causal connection is debatable, but they often do seem to go hand in hand. So while you are at the doctor's having your TSH etc. checked, consider asking them to run Vitamin D levels as well.

Finally, remember that many things interfere with absorption of thyroid medicines. In particular, thyroid meds should NOT be taken at the same time as prenatal vitamins. (Many doctors don't know this; mine didn't.) Iron and calcium in particular interfere with absorption of thyroid medications, and prenatals are full of iron and calcium. Take your thyroid meds and your prenatals at least 2-3 hours apart instead.

Take your thyroid meds as consistently as possible. Thyroid meds are most effective taken in the morning, on an empty stomach, with plenty of water. Avoid eating for about an hour afterwards if possible. Do not take with any other meds or vitamins, and if possible, take them about the same time each day.

Conclusion

Although most women will not have problems with their thyroid during their pregnancies or postpartum, the frequency with which it occurs (even in women with no prior thyroid issues) merits close attention from birth attendants.
However, because not all birth attendants are fully aware of hypothyroidism issues in pregnancy, women need to be proactive about informing and advocating about this issue for themselves, particularly women of size.

Saturday, September 6, 2008

Metformin and B Vitamins?


Many people of size take metformin (a.k.a. Glucophage). They might take it for insulin resistance/PCOS issues, or they might take it for blood sugar issues....or both, since the two are often related.

This post is of particular concern to those women of childbearing age who take metformin, but anyone on metformin should know about it.

I recently ran across some research linking metformin with low levels of B vitamins, particularly vitamin B12 and Folic Acid.

Although the worst effects seem to happen with years of treatment and higher dosages, even short-term treatment (16 weeks) reduced the levels of folate and B12.

These lowered levels of folate and B12 also seem to be linked to an increase in homocysteine levels, which is commonly seen after metformin is started. Now, what significance this has, if any, is still being debated. In terms of general health, homocysteine levels may be tied to heart health; high levels are considered a risk factor for cardiovascular disease. There is some research indicating that administration of B-group vitamins reduces homocysteine levels in non-pregnant PCOS patients treated with metformin. But we don't really know yet if lowering homocysteine levels results in any meaningful reduction in long-term endpoints like decreased heart attacks or mortality.

However, we do know that some people on metformin do develop megoblastic anemia at some point during treatment. So certainly, it's seems like it's something that anyone on metformin should be aware of and monitored for periodically.

It might even be sensible to take extra B vitamins (B group complex, presumably) while on metformin, although formal studies on the value of that seem to be lacking so far. There is also one study that found that supplemental calcium may help blunt or reverse B12 malabsorption with metformin.

Implications for Pregnancy?

All this information about metformin impacting B12 and folic acid levels makes me wonder if there are special implications for women of childbearing age. We know that folic acid levels are important for preventing birth defects like neural tube defects (NTDs, like spina bifida or anencephaly). If a woman with PCOS has been on metformin for years and her folic acid levels are chronically low when she conceives, does this increase her risk for NTDs?

As far as I can tell, no one knows. There doesn't seem to be any increase in birth defects in women on metformin so far, but research is limited. Because preliminary research on metformin in pregnancy indicates that it cuts the risk for miscarriage and gestational diabetes in women with PCOS, it's likely to be used more and more often in the future, provided the research continues to be supportive.

So the question becomes, should women on metformin who are considering conceiving (or who are of childbearing age at all) be supplemented with extra folic acid and B12 (or B vitamins in general)? And if so, by how much? What about calcium, if it helps reverse the malabsorption of B12? Should levels of B12 be monitored during pregnancy?

At this point, I don't think anyone knows for sure. Anecdotally, many women on metformin do seem to be taking additional folic acid at least. Consult your care provider about this topic and what dosages might be appropriate beyond a normal prenatal vitamin. (And if you do decide to take supplemental vitamins in addition to metformin, you should probably take them at different times of day.)

Friday, August 29, 2008

In Memory Of

About one year ago, the young son of a friend of ours died. He was 4 years old and adorable. This post is in his memory.

To protect their privacy, I won't give his name or exact details of his death, but he died accidentally, just kids being kids. No one really at fault, just a freak accident, a bolt out of the blue. It was unexpected and devastating.

This death affected me so strongly; I'm not quite sure why. Obviously there is tremendous sadness and empathy for parents whenever a child dies; it's just something that seems so wrong and so contrary to what the natural order of things should be. And who could be unaffected by the pain of parents losing a child? Yet it seemed to have deeper echoes for me.

Intellectually, I know the fact that it fell near the first anniversary of the death of a member of our own extended family amplified the sorrow I felt. I was already raw and bracing myself for the anniversary of that death; to suddenly have this death happen so close to that was even more overwhelming.

And because our school is a very small, closely-knit community, this death echoed more deeply than it might have elsewhere. This child had older siblings who are in classes with my own children. I've worked with these siblings in special activities. We see them at school functions constantly.

In fact, we saw them the night before the accident at a school function, and I think that amplified the sudden nature of it all. We had just seen him happy and playing and romping about like everyone else the night before, only to get a call the next morning that he was dead.

The timing of it all just emphasized the fickleness of fate and how quickly things can change at any time, for anyone. As parents, we try to live in denial of that---an understandable coping mechanism---but this brought home that lesson very quickly and very hard, and made us all feel that much more insecure in our own lives.

Perhaps the strongest factor in my own grief was the fact that I too have a little one, not quite the same age as this boy but close enough. In fact, they might have been classmates eventually. Losing him was like vicariously losing my own youngest and most vulnerable child. It ramped up my fears and made me paranoid, wondering what unavoidable disaster was around the corner, waiting for my little one, waiting to break my heart. The grief and fear of that still lives with me, even now.

And oh, the sadness of it all was so hard. We went and sat with the family the next day, visiting with them, bringing them food for the freezer, etc. The issue of pictures really hit me the night of his death.....Oh my God, they now have all the pictures of this beloved child that they will EVER have.....so I spent a bunch of time searching out any images of this child from our own photos, enlarging and framing them for the family. They were only images from the backgrounds of other photos, nothing really good, but I figured if it were me I'd want ANY image I could get, anything more to remember him by.

One of the most heart-wrenching things was sitting with the mother, going through all her pictures of her little one. We were smiling over some of the pictures, reliving some happy moments, when she said sadly that she kept looking at pictures of him over and over again, trying to remember what he looked like in life instead of what he looked like in death. She was the one who held him in her arms as he died, and she said that all she could see now when she thought of him were all his injuries and what he looked like with them. She hoped that someday, if she looked at enough pictures of him from life again, she'd remember those healthy-and-alive images instead of the images of blood and trauma. Oh God, that just broke my heart. Imagine having trouble remembering your child whole.

So I write this in memory of this little boy, to honor him and everything his family has gone through. I honor the fact that they have made it through the first year, despite a health crisis in the father, difficult moments for all the siblings, and such soul-crushing loss for the mother that she almost seemed to waste away in front of our eyes for a while.

I am pleased that they are beginning to regain some sense of balance again, though I know their grief will always be with them and there is still much work to do. Sometimes the second year is harder than the first, because the denial and the shock and the magical thinking start to wear off and you are only left with the stark realities of the loss. We will do all we can to be there for them, but in the end of course, no one can walk this journey for them. They must find the way themselves, their own unique way of grieving, their own way of honoring and remembering this precious little boy.

I woke up early this morning, unable to sleep for thinking about this. It was a year ago it all happened, and we will be going to a memorial/celebration of his life this weekend, so I'm sure that's why it's so on my mind. But also, I recently ran across a post at the blog, The True Face of Birth, linking to an essay about death and loss by Robbie Davis-Floyd, a birth activist and author. It certainly echoed and focused the thoughts that were already on my mind as we approached this anniversary.

Davis-Floyd's own daughter, her eldest child, died just short of her 21st birthday. She died in a car accident on her way home to celebrate her birthday with her family. Davis-Floyd wrote this essay several years after the loss to describe her own perspectives on birth and death and on living with loss.

Twenty years and 361 days later, after diapers and walking, blissful breastfeeding, chauffering her to gymnastics and dance lessons, and sharing her joys and sorrows late at night while she poured out her heart to me from behind the shower curtain, I stood by her body in the hospital room, surrounded it with my arms, and poured out my own heart to her corpse. She had been dead for 22 hours, but my mother’s heart could not believe that I could not call her back until I tried. I talked, I screamed, I sobbed, I begged her to live and breathe again. I told her I could not live without her. I touched every part of her body and begged the skin to twitch, the head to turn, the legs to move--anything to show me that this wasn’t reality, that this inert but gorgeous body lying in front of me was not really lifeless, that those stunning dancer’s legs were never going to plié again, that those graceful hands would never again arc, that those lips would not move to kiss mine or to smile, that her voice would never again say, "Mommy."

...I have been happy all my life, living out of a deep wellspring of joy bubbling up within me. When Peyton died, I lost that deep bubbling happiness--it comes back now only in fleeting moments all the more precious for their scarcity. I have a wonderful son, many friends, and a fulfilling career. But I have lost the very most precious thing in my life, and no platitudes about how I will see her again in heaven, or we will be united past this life, or she is always with me in spirit (which I know to be true) can alleviate for more than a little while the exquisite agony I always feel about her death. I thought I knew the meaning of suffering before she died--I had already experienced a good deal of pain and loss in my life--but I had absolutely no clue what real suffering was.



The rest of Davis-Floyd's essay can be found here. I highly recommend reading it, but you should know ahead of time that it's a hard read. She graphically describes seeing her daughter's body after the car accident, spending time with its wounds, washing the body and cleaning it up, but she also describes the things that she and others did that helped her along her way in those first days of shock and grief.

As painful as this essay is, it's also powerful and even healing. I sobbed and had to take a few breaks to get through it, but it was profound and deeply-affecting reading. I know that many people will not follow the link and read it (and if you are in a fragile or vulnerable place, feel free not to), but I hope some people will go there and check it out, because really, who among us will not experience the death of a loved one at some point? Or the death of a friend's loved one?

It's an amazing essay, gut-wrenching but also thoughtful and ultimately affirming. She concludes:
When I gave birth to my son at home, I learned the power of surrender to the tremendous force of life. Now I am learning the power of surrender to the tremendous reality of death. May these two kinds of surrender balance and sustain me, teach me to let go of my fight to understand, and embrace the paradoxes my life encompasses. Like a mother who has just had the courage to give birth without knowing who her child will become, I am here, not knowing who I will become, but open, cracked wide open, to whatever life may bring.

There is a saying that is passed around so often on the internet that it has become trite and mundane, yet there's a reason why it's become so well-circulated---it speaks to a universal truth. I am reminded of it in this situation:
"Making a decision to have a child- it's momentous. It is to decide to have your heart go walking around outside your body." Elizabeth Stone

Yup, it really is like that. You feel THAT vulnerable. And yet, think of all the beautiful and wonderful things you would have missed had that child not been a part of your life. It is the greatest blessing that can be given to us, which is why it can be the greatest grief that happens to us too.

The capacity for joy is also the same capacity for loss, and it's so hard to acknowledge that double-edged sword. It's why pregnant women feel so vulnerable, it's why we check our baby's breathing 4,972 times a night, it's why reading about other people's losses is difficult, and it's why watching another family go through your greatest fear is so incredibly hard.

God grant strength and healing to our friends who are mourning their little boy this week, God grant peace to all families who have experienced such a loss, and God grant strength and wisdom to all of us who fear such a loss and must watch others endure it.

Thursday, August 21, 2008

So Why the BMI Restrictions in Waterbirth?


Waterbirth offers unique advantages to women in labor. According to http://www.waterbirth.net/,

Lying in warm water increases venous pressure so that veins can return blood to the heart more efficiently and your baby receives more oxygen. It enhances cardiac action and slows the pulse rate. Total relaxation in the warmth and comfort of the water helps the uterus to contract more effectively. Water also counteracts the force of gravity and any pressure a woman feels inside her body, so there is a further pain relieving effect. Water helps the woman surrender to the birth process and it creates a feeling of tranquility to the whole birth experience.
However, as we discussed previously, some birth facilities have restricted fat women from having access to water during labor and/or birth.

On the other hand, some facilities are very supportive of it, even in very large women. It all depends on the facility and the provider.

However, with the increasing trend towards seeing fat women's pregnancies as extremely "high risk" (regardless of whether they actually experience complications), I anticipate that we will see more and more BMI restrictions against waterbirth and other "alternative" birth modalities take root.

But are they justified?


So Why Not Have Waterbirth Access for Fat Women?


The following are some of the reasons typically given for restricting fat women's access to waterbirth, along with an analysis of the attitudes and reasoning behind them.

Waterbirth Is Only For "Low-Risk" Women

Of the hospitals that have embraced waterbirth, some have embraced it tepidly, with many restrictions. In particular, hospitals that are tentative about waterbirth usually restrict its use to "low-risk" patients only.

Since fat women are automatically seen as "high-risk" by many doctors (even when they have not developed any complications at all), some hospitals have BMI cutoffs, above which waterbirth is not an option anymore.

Applying the "high risk" label (and accompanying restrictions) across the board to all women of size is ridiculous. If a fat woman has had a healthy pregnancy, developed no complications, and is a reasonably active and mobile person, there is no justification for keeping her from resources in labor (like walking, immersion in water, a birth ball, position changes, etc.) that just might help her labor progress more "normally" and avoid an unnecessary cesarean.

The Ticking Time Bomb Theory

Another reason some hospitals restrict waterbirth in women of size is the perception of all obese women as having blood pressure issues (latent or overt), and therefore being at risk to stroke out at any moment during labor. This is a direct result of hyperbole about the perceived risks of obesity and increasing promotion of the idea that a fat woman's pregnancy is ultra high-risk.

Ironically, research shows that being immersed in water actually tends to lower blood pressure, and may actually be a good way to help prevent such an issue. Although it's not true that fat women are ticking time bombs just waiting to stroke out in labor, if it were, hospitals might actually be preventing these women from one intervention likely to help them KEEP normal blood pressure. Talk about short-sighted!

The Shoulder Dystocia Fear

Another concern is shoulder dystocia (baby's head is born but the shoulders get stuck on the way out). Fat women are perceived to be more at-risk for shoulder dystocia, and doctors are afraid that taking time to get the mother out of the water might delay emergency measures needed to get the child born safely.

However, several studies have shown that when baby size and diabetes are controlled for, obese women are no more likely to experience shoulder dystocia than women of average size. Just being fat does NOT increase the risk for shoulder dystocia, and forbidding waterbirth on that basis alone is illogical and unfair.

However, fat women do tend to have bigger babies, on average (although it should be noted that even so, MOST fat women do not have big babies). Because bigger babies have higher rates of shoulder dystocia, many healthcare providers fear having ANY fat woman birth in the water.

Their concern is that being in water might cause a delay in the maneuvers that may be needed to relieve shoulder dystocia. But healthcare providers experienced in waterbirth know that shoulder dystocia may be less likely in waterbirth because of the mother's ability to shift position easily and open up more space in the pelvis by being off the tailbone. One study found a shoulder dystocia in waterbirth rate of 0.16%, hardly a raging epidemic.

Experienced waterbirth providers point out that when they have encountered a shoulder dystocia in the water, often all that needed to be done was have the mother shift to hands and knees, or to stand up in the water with one leg on the side of the tub, creating an asymmetrical space in the pelvis that helps free up the baby's shoulders.

If that didn't work, they note that the process of helping the woman get out of the tub was usually enough to rotate the mother's pelvis around baby's shoulders and get the baby out without further maneuvers. And if it was not, the birth attendant can then do all of the usual maneuvers once the woman is out of the water.

Most providers who are experienced in waterbirth do not believe that potential shoulder dystocia concerns are a reason for forbidding waterbirth.

The Fear of a Getting a Fat Woman Out of Water

Probably the biggest reason why women of size are restricted from waterbirth is the fear of a fat woman passing out or having a medical emergency while in the water, and what might be necessary to deal with that. Because they see fat women as SO high-risk, they view this as a likely possibility, and are acting accordingly.

Although one can understand how a hospital might be concerned about how they would get such a large person out of the water or initiate emergency treatment quickly, we must remember that such a medical emergency is rarely instantaneous and there are almost always warning signs that suggest a change in laboring location and closer monitoring.

The nightmare scenario they fear is extremely unlikely (especially in a spontaneous labor with no drugs or medications, which is what a waterbirth should be). To restrict ALL fat women based on such an unlikely scenario is an extremely unfair balancing of the risks/benefits ratio.

However, let's be frank....the hospital's administration is also worried about potential workmans' compensation claims if a worker injured his/her back trying to get a woman of size out of the water during an emergency. These are understandable concerns from a hospital's risk management point of view, but Barbara Harper (director of Waterbirth International) addresses this below. The long and the short of it is that they may actually put their workers at greater risk by making supersized women birth outside the water, especially since immersion in water tends to make obese women more mobile and easier to help maneuver.

The Solution: Individualize Waterbirth Decision-Making Instead

Barbara Harper suggests that instead of facilities instituting across-the-board BMI restrictions on access to water, they should make case-by-case judgments, taking into account the mother's blood pressure status, her fitness, her general mobility, and whether there there have been any complications during the pregnancy.

Instead of forbidding waterbirth to all women of size, decision-making could be individualized to acknowledge the differences in the spectrum of fat women giving birth. This is a common-sense approach that makes a LOT of sense.

Finally, an important question is whether such BMI restrictions on waterbirth are justified by actual research, or just hospital administrators' fears of risk. Doctors and hospitals are striving to become more evidence-based in their practices; what does the evidence say here?
I wrote to Barbara Harper and asked her this question, and this was her reply:

Thank you for writing in your question about waterbirth studies and policies concerning BMI restrictions for women wanting waterbirths.

I am very much in opposition to such practices, but acknowledge that they do exist in many hospitals and some birth centers.

The water is THE VERY BEST PLACE for an overweight parturient woman. She can move in the water, control her body, respond better to the movements of the baby and feel much better physically after the birth because of the buoyancy effect on her muscles and cardiovascular system.

I don't see why every hospital isn't seeing that they could save hundreds of cesareans on plus-size women by PUTTING them in water as an intervention.

But, the great liability monster raises its ugly head and the hospital then becomes fearful of employees hurting their backs if they had to get a woman out of the water during an obstetric emergency. Thus the development of policies to protect the hospital against workers compensation cases.

When I teach the professional Waterbirth Credentialing workshop I do address BMI weight restriction policies and insist that hospitals treat each woman individually and not restrict the woman who presents in labor at 250 pounds who has gained 60 pounds during her pregnancy, just on the basis of the final number. I implore them to look at activity levels and pre-pregnancy weight and pre-pregnancy activity levels.

I have been successful in having the BMI policies removed from some hospital protocols, but not with others.

There is no available scientific evidence one way or the other, with the exception that we did a search both in the US and in the UK to find workers compensation cases for back injuries in labor and delivery settings. There were some, but none related to water. Holding the leg of a 300 pound woman while she is pushing is much harder than helping her in and out of the bath.

--Barbara Harper, RN, CLD, CCE
Founder/Director of Waterbirth International
www.waterbirth.org

Waterbirth IS a Reasonable Choice for Fat Women

Waterbirth is a very viable choice for women of size. Although it offers advantages for all women, it offers additional advantages for women of size, ones which might help improve birth outcomes in this group.

If doctors and hospitals really are interested in lowering the rate of cesareans and other complications in women of size, waterbirth is one more important tool to have in their toolbox. It shouldn't be automatically removed from the equation, based simply on size.

Although some fat women are discouraged from waterbirth, rest assured that many women of even very large sizes have labored and even birthed their babies in the water. If this is something YOU are interested in, it IS still a choice. As a woman of size, you might have to work harder in order to access this choice than a woman of average size, but it IS still a choice.


Some birth centers have waterbirth options. Some of these may have BMI restrictions, but some do not. Some may be amenable to negotiation about these restrictions; some may not. It can't hurt to ask. If they won't permit waterbirth in a woman of size, take your business elsewhere.


Most hospitals these days offer the option to at least labor in water. Again, some deny this to obese women, but many do not. However, if you encounter a hospital that won't allow you even to labor in water simply because of size, it's likely that they are not size-friendly in many other ways either, and you should strongly consider another birth place if at all possible.


Although waterbirth (actually pushing out the baby in water) is not as common in US hospitals as it is in European hospitals, there ARE a number of hospitals that do offer it. If you prefer to birth in a hospital, you can check with Barbara Harper to see if there are any in your area that are open to waterbirth. She keeps a list of waterbirth-friendly hospitals.

Additionally, Barbara's organization, Waterbirth International, has worked in the past with hospitals who have a "no waterbirth" policy. If you give plenty of advance notice so they can review this policy, if you have a provider supportive of the idea of waterbirth, and if you are willing to act as a strong advocate with the hospital, they may be able to help you establish waterbirth policies in that hospital, or to at least allow an exception to the rule for you as an individual. They do ask that you join Waterbirth International and make a donation to help cover their costs while doing this, but they say they are able to work with many hospitals and find an acceptable compromise.


And of course, waterbirth is always a choice at home, and homebirth is a more reasonable option than most people think. Many homebirth midwives offer waterbirth services (often including rental of a waterbirth tub, or information on other waterbirth choices) as part of the spectrum of their care. Many of the women of size that I have known who have actually given birth in water have done so at home. It's where I had my own waterbirth.....and it was an AWESOME experience.

Wherever you choose to give birth, waterbirth remains a possibility.....and it may be especially advantageous in women of size. It's definitely something for you to further research if you interested in it. I also urge hospitals, birth centers, and birth professionals to work to keep immersion during labor and waterbirth itself an option for women of ALL sizes.

*The waterbirth photo at the top of the entry is of a "morbidly obese" medical professional who gave birth to her third child in the water at home.

There is also a lovely waterbirth video at:http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MrbXXZ2Fqg0

Monday, August 18, 2008

General Information about Waterbirth


In previous posts, we have been discussing BMI restrictions on laboring and birthing in water, and whether by restricting waterbirth in women of size, they are depriving fat women from an option likely to improve birth outcomes.

The first question that has to be addressed is why waterbirth isn't more common for ALL women, regardless of size. If it's so advantageous, why the resistance to waterbirth in general in the United States? And I'm sure many readers from the fatosphere have some basic questions about waterbirth in general.

So today's post contains basic information about waterbirth and addresses the typical concerns people might have about waterbirth.

In another post soon, we will discuss why some birth facilities have BMI restrictions on who can labor and birth in the water, and whether those restrictions really have any merit or not.

Why the Resistance to Waterbirth?

If laboring in water could help a woman have a shorter, less painful labor, lessen the chances of an episiotomy, and help her be more mobile during the birth......all without the significant risks of epidurals and pain medications...........shouldn't doctors and hospitals be interested in such a low-risk intervention?

You would think doctors and hospitals would be falling all over themselves to embrace waterbirth........but the sad truth is that they're not. Some are still stuck in the technological model of birth, resistant to information about the efficacy and safety of waterbirth.

The following are the main concerns about waterbirth usually brought up by doctors and hospitals, along with research showing lack of harm from these issues, and how they can be dealt with proactively and safely.

How Does The Baby Breathe?

The first concern usually raised is that the baby born in water might inhale the water with its first breath and drown. This concern is addressed in detail at the waterbirth FAQ from Waterbirth International's website. According to them:

There are four main factors that prevent the baby from
inhaling water at the time of birth:

1. Prostaglandin E2 levels from the placenta which cause a slowing down or stopping of the fetal breathing movements. When the baby is born and the Prostaglandin level is still high, the baby's muscles for breathing simply don't work, thus engaging the first inhibitory response.

2. Babies are born experiencing mild hypoxia or lack of oxygen. Hypoxia causes apnea and swallowing, not breathing or gasping.

3. Water is a hypotonic solution and lung fluids present in the fetus are hypertonic. So, even if water were to travel in past the larynx, they could not pass into the lungs based on the fact that hypertonic solutions are denser and prevent hypotonic solutions from merging or coming into their presence.

4. The last important inhibitory factor is the Dive Reflex and revolves around the larynx. The larynx is covered all over with chemoreceptors or taste buds. The larynx has five times as many as taste buds as the whole surface of the tongue. So, when a solution hits the back of the throat, passing the larynx, the taste buds interprets what substance it is and the glottis automatically closes and the solution is then swallowed, not inhaled.

As long as the baby is not in distress and as long as the baby is brought to the surface in a timely manner, research shows that waterbirth is safe. After all, babies were in a liquid in-utero environment already; being born in water simply eases the transition from the uterus to the outside world.

Concern about Infection

Some doctors are concerned about potential risk for infection, even though research shows no greater risk for neonatal infection or maternal infection in waterbirths.

Proper hygiene measures are vital of course, but as long as these are followed, there is no increase in the risk of infection.

Lack of Access to the Perineum

Some doctors object to anything impeding their view of (and access to) the perineum at birth. Of course, less access to the perineum means less chance to cut episiotomies, which is one of the major advantages of waterbirth.

Because they have been trained to be very "hands-on" during delivery, less access to the perineum tends to make doctors feel less in control, and this makes them nervous. But once doctors become experienced in attending waterbirths, they adjust to this approach just fine. It's all a matter of willingness to learn a new approach.

Difficulty of Evaluating Blood Loss During Waterbirth

The difficulty of evaluating blood loss during waterbirth is a legitimate concern. In all births, care providers must watch mothers carefully to be sure they are not bleeding excessively after the placenta detaches. Care providers learn how to estimate blood loss in land births, but this is more difficult in water because the water dilutes the blood. As a result, some hospitals forbid waterbirth altogether, while others require women to get out of the water after the baby is born and to birth the placenta on dry land.

However, this is not necessary....most providers learn how to estimate blood loss in waterbirths over time. As with every other obstetric skill, it is acquired through teaching from other experts, observation, and practice. As they learned to estimate blood loss in land births, so they will learn to do so with waterbirths. Again, it simply requires the willingness to learn.

Cost of Facilities

Costs of facilities is another potential concern as well. However, costs of adding permanent waterbirth facilities could be easily accounted for by charging extra for access to them. In addition, waterbirth is immensely popular as a concept; having these facilities and promoting their use should bring extra business to the hospital, thus helping to pay for themselves in time.

However, if the capital outlay for permanent waterbirth tubs is too high, portable pools can be rented by parents instead and brought into the hospital; many companies carry them. With these, a hospital incurs no capital outlay at all.

Conclusion

While many doctors have professed concern about waterbirth due to worries about newborn breathing, infection, lack of immediate access to the perineum, difficulty in evaluating blood loss, and cost of facilities, research has shown that each of these concerns can be addressed. When approached with attention for hygiene and appropriate care guidelines, waterbirth is a safe and reasonable choice.

Waterbirth: A Choice Whose Time Has Come!

More and more hospitals are beginning to embrace the use of water in birth. Many hospitals now offer access to tubs for labor, although they still make the mother get out once she starts pushing. Others have waterbirth "suites" where women can both labor and birth in water.

Waterbirth is increasingly popular particularly in European countries, and can be found as well in many Canadian, Australian, and New Zealand hospitals. In the U.K., the majority of hospitals are reported to have water immersion options, and the government has recommended that all hospitals provide women with the option of a birthing pool. Some third-world countries also have options for waterbirth, particularly in specialty birthing clinics.

Although slower to catch on in the U.S. than abroad, waterbirth has been added to a number of U.S. hospitals as well. Monadnock Community Hospital in Peterborough, New Hampshire was the first hospital in the United States to install a permanent waterbirth pool in 1991. Many other hospitals have followed suit since then.

If your local hospital does not have waterbirth choices available, Waterbirth International can work with you to try and change their policy. They have been successful in a number of facilities already. And of course, you always choose waterbirth at home if your hospital is not amenable.

For more information about waterbirth in general, see the following sites:

There are many other online resources about waterbirth available. Do a simple search and you will find many. If you would like to see what waterbirth might look like, "Birth Day" is a lovely waterbirth video of a Mexican midwife giving birth to her own baby in water with her family nearby. YouTube has a number of brief waterbirth videos as well. And stay tuned to this blog for more pictures of women of size laboring and giving birth in water!!