Thursday, September 23, 2010

Prenatal Weight Gain: When the Conclusion is Made Ahead of the Results

Several people wrote me last year to send me the link to the New York Times article, "New Goal for the Obese: Zero Gain in Pregnancy."

Believe me, I'd already seen this article and others similar to it. There are SO many things to object to object to or comment on, it was hard to know where to start and I've been spinning my wheels for a long time, trying to find a way to communicate my concerns effectively without a giant rambling reply. 

But darn it, this sort of thing needs to be challenged, and currently very few people in the media, the fatosphere, or the birth world are even questioning strict limits on pregnancy weight gain in "obese" women. 

So I'm going to ramble away, because this sort of thing must be challenged.  Here are a few of my concerns with this specific study and so many of the others like it.

Publicizing the Outcome Before The Study Even Begins

I think the thing that bothers me most in this Kaiser study is that the results are a foregone conclusion.

It floors me that these researchers published an article ---in the New York Times, no less---essentially promoting a conclusion they hadn't even studied yet.

It's not like these researchers had already done the study and concluded from data that gaining no weight in pregnancy was best for obese women.

No no no!! They were just starting the study....so why were they already publicizing their conclusions?

The problem is that these doctors have already made up their minds that little or no weight gain leads to the healthiest outcomes in obese mothers, and that this was the message that needed to be pushed to consumers and other doctors.

It's marketing this message that is their main concern. Why else would they be publicizing their uncompleted research like this?

There is an army of OBs out there who have reverted to the old teachings about the "dangers" of too much weight gain in pregnancy and have a TREMENDOUS agenda to promote extreme restriction of weight gain (or even weight loss) in "obese" women in pregnancy.

These OBs have been aggressively marketing the idea to the press that fat women gain "too much weight" in pregnancy and that restricting such weight gain can improve outcomes. Over and over, we have seen them pushing this agenda with the press.  This is just the latest salvo in their campaign.

The phrasing of the NYT article (just look at the title...."New Goal for the Obese: Zero Weight Gain in Pregnancy") also bothers me because many people will scan the article and conclude that the study has already been done and that gaining no weight in pregnancy is best.

In fact, all the article is doing is telling people that they were starting a study to see whether gaining no weight improves outcomes......but many people (including many doctors) probably read the story and believed that gaining no weight is now the standard of care.

These researchers are trying to create an expectation in the public and among birth attendants that this no-gain policy is the new standard of care for obese women, that any gain must be prevented for women of size....and perhaps even that weight loss during pregnancy is the most optimal course of all.

This is what I'm hearing from women of size now....that they are being told to gain little to no weight in pregnancy, and many more are now even being told to lose weight during pregnancy.

In fact, THIS IS NOT THE STANDARD OF CARE AT ALL, nor should it be.  There are significant reasons for concern with a policy like this.

Prenatal Weight Gain Politics


The IOM (Institute of Medicine) came out with revised guidelines earlier this year, recommending a new pregnancy gain of 11-20 pounds in obese women.

This is down from a previous recommendation for obese women to gain "at least 15 pounds" (often misreported as "no more than 15 pounds"), but the news wasn't all bad.

The good news was that the IOM resisted pressure to lower the guidelines to NO gain (or even weight loss) for "morbidly obese" women, saying there was not enough evidence in that group to make a decision.

The bad news is that now we are going to see a plethora of studies, intervening and trying to keep "morbidly obese" women from gaining any weight in pregnancy....and no doubt coming to their conclusions ahead of time, just like this study.

My concern is that the studies we will see on this topic will not be fair, rigorous, or powerful enough to really make any decisions about the best course of action.....but that it won't matter, because The Powers That Be have already made up their minds about what's best, and will use bad science to try and push their agenda as part of their "war on obesity." 

And I'm afraid of what the price will be for women of size and their babies.

Details on the Study

Here are more details about the study from the Kaiser press release on October 21, 2009.
Kaiser Permanente is launching the first clinical trial to help obese women control their weight during pregnancy. The “Healthy Moms” study, funded by a $2.2 million grant from the National Institute of Child Health and Human Development, will begin recruiting this month.

“The goal of the study is to keep obese pregnant women from gaining weight. We believe they can safely maintain their pre-pregnancy weight and deliver healthier babies,” says Kim Vesco, MD, MPH, a practicing OB/GYN and researcher at the Kaiser Permanente Center for Health Research, who will direct the study.

This is the first study to test a weight maintenance program for obese pregnant women, and the first to use weekly support groups as part of the intervention. A small study in Denmark did limit excess weight gain in obese pregnant women, but they still gained an average of 14.5 pounds. Two other larger studies failed to prevent excessive weight gain in obese and overweight pregnant women.

“It may seem counterintuitive to suggest that women control their weight during pregnancy, but these women are already carrying between 50 and 100 extra pounds — and for them any more weight gain could be very dangerous,” said Vic Stevens, PhD, principal investigator who has studied weight loss and weight maintenance for more than 30 years...

The “Healthy Moms” trial will enroll 180 obese pregnant women from Washington and Oregon who are members of the Kaiser Permanente health plan: half will receive one-time dietary and exercise advice; the other half will attend two individual counseling sessions and then weekly group counseling for the remainder of their pregnancy. Women who attend the sessions will be weighed and encouraged to keep and turn in daily food and exercise diaries. Professional weight counselors will facilitate the groups and help motivate the women with behavior change techniques.

The study will follow women throughout their pregnancies to find out how much weight they gain, how large their babies are, and how much weight they retain one year after they give birth. It will also look at birthing complications, the baby’s growth and feeding practices, and whether the mother continues with dietary changes after the baby is born. The study will recruit women for 18 months, and preliminary results are expected in three years.
Thoughts on the Kaiser Study

First off, I should note that I don't object to everything in the study, contrary to what many of the Obesity Mafia would expect.

I think it's very important for women to exercise in pregnancy, and I agree it's good to discourage consumption of things like sweetened drinks and junk food. I don't have a problem with recommending those, and I have no doubt that these interventions probably will be associated with lower risks of some complications in pregnancy.

Nor do I think that obese women gaining little weight is automatically dangerous. I personally had a net gain of about 5 pounds in my pregnancies (lost 10 lbs., then gained back 15)...not because I was trying to limit my gain, was eating "better" than usual, or because I had a lot of nausea, but simply because pregnancy revs up my metabolism in a major way.

I know from personal experience that you can have a perfectly healthy pregnancy with a very small gain. Some fat women do gain very little in pregnancy, not because they have "healthier" nutrition than those who do gain, but simply because pregnancy changes their metabolism more.

My concern is promoting no weight gain as a goal for ALL obese women, and using potentially draconian means to get it.  Many women can't achieve null weight gain without drastically limiting calories and thereby nutrients. In what way is that healthy? 

The research (in other weight-limitation studies) shows that many "obese" women have difficulty meeting weight gain limits of 15 lbs. already.  Not because they are pigs and can't lay off the french fries and bon-bons, but simply because most pregnant women, including fat women, gain at least the weight of the baby, placenta, and extra fluids in pregnancy. 

In addition, many women of size who are chronic dieters or who have lost weight before pregnancy gain more during pregnancy because their bodies compensate physiologically to have enough energy for birth and breastfeeding.  The body thinks it's starving, so it becomes more efficient and stores up more fat for reserves, even with normal eating.

So is it really realistic and fair to make fat women gain NO weight in pregnancy and to make them feel guilty if they do gain weight, despite eating well?  I don't think it is. I think it sets them up for failure, for feeling guilty, and for disordered eating.

I think it puts the goal on the surrogate target of weight gain, when it really ought to be putting the target on the real goal...healthy nutrition, healthy baby, and healthy mommy.

If Only....

Wouldn't it be nice if this study had a Health At Every Size (HAES) component to it? If they had a group where increased exercise and reasonable eating guidelines were promoted, yet the emphasis was simply on really excellent nutrition and exercise, regardless of actual gain? 

Wouldn't it be nice if there were a group where women weren't made to feel like failures if they gained pregnancy weight despite doing everything "right"? 

And wouldn't it be great if they compared long-term maternal and fetal outcomes, long-term healthy eating practices, and long-term weight outcomes from each program to see which had the best results? 

I have a hunch the results would be similar to the U.C. Davis HAES study, which found that emphasizing healthy habits along with body acceptance resulted in better long-term health outcomes than emphasizing weight loss. 

I know, I know....it's a pipe dream.  When doctors are convinced that strictly limiting weight gain is the "magic bullet" to preventing complications in the pregnancies of women of size and preventing obesity in their offspring, it's too much to hope for that they could mentally uncouple healthful habits from restricted gain.  They simply cannot separate one goal from the other; in their minds, the two are always connected. 

But very low weight gains are already difficult for many women to achieve; lowering the bar to even more restrictive gain is not going to be any more effective or achievable.  Furthermore, weight gain is a poor surrogate for fetal outcome in most cases, so making that the focus does little to promote fetal health.

Perhaps what they should be doing instead is emphasizing healthy habits and long-term outcomes...healthy nutrition, healthy baby, and healthy mommy...over actual numbers on a scale.

Next up:  Study Design Issues and Long-Term Safety Concerns in these "restrictive weight gain" studies.

Thursday, September 16, 2010

"Catch-Up Fat" and Metabolic Issues

This sounds like a really interesting paper. Here's the abstract and a link to the full text.  Obviously, emphasis is mine.

Pathways from weight fluctuations to metabolic diseases: focus on maladaptive thermogenesis during catch-up fat.  Dulloo AG, Jacquet J, Montani JP. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord. 2002 Sep;26 Suppl 2:S46-57.

Department of Medicine/Physiology, University of Fribourg, Switzerland.

Abstract

It has long been known that obesity is a high risk factor for cardiovascular diseases. In more recent years, the analysis of several large epidemiological databases has also revealed that, independently of excess weight, large fluctuations in body weight at some point earlier in life represent an independent risk factor for type 2 diabetes and hypertension-two major contributors to cardiovascular diseases.

High cardiovascular morbidity and mortality have indeed been reported in men and women who in young adulthood experienced weight fluctuations (involving the recovery of body weight after weight loss due to disease, famine or voluntary slimming), or when weight fluctuations occurred much earlier in life and involved catch-up growth after fetal or neonatal growth retardation.

This paper addresses the pathways from weight fluctuations to chronic metabolic diseases by focusing on the phenomenon of accelerated fat recovery (ie catch-up fat) after weight loss or growth retardation. Arguments are put forward that, during catch-up growth or weight recovery on our modern refined foods, the mechanisms of adaptive thermogenesis that regulate catch-up fat are pushed beyond the limits for which they were meant to operate and turn maladaptive.

The consequences are enhanced susceptibilities towards skeletal muscle insulin resistance and overactive sympathetic activity, both of which are major contributors to the pathogenesis of chronic metabolic diseases.

Since weight fluctuation earlier in life (independently of excess weight later in life) is an independent risk factor for metabolic diseases, the mechanisms by which body fat is acquired would seem to be at least as important as the consequences of excess fat per se in the pathogenesis of diabetes, hypertension and cardiovascular diseases.

PMID: 12174328

Free full text available at:  http://www.nature.com/ijo/journal/v26/n2s/pdf/0802127a.pdf

Interesting quote:

"Several lines of evidence suggest that the process of recovering body weight is itself an independent risk factor for the development of cardiovascular diseases."

Tuesday, September 14, 2010

Being Fat in an Emergency

We recently discussed Community Emergency Response Training (CERT), how I took CERT training this year, and what an excellent program it is. 

However, I also wanted to share one negative realization I had, not about the program, but from the program.  And that was how fat people might get discriminated against during an emergency.

In an emergency, some rescuers might be less likely to help us, based on our size alone.  Or we might be seen as less likely to recover and so moved down the priority list for treatment. Or, like during Hurricane Katrina, "caregivers" might be unwilling to evacuate us and maybe even willing to do worse. 

I saw this lesser willingness to help fat people among some people in our CERT class.  Not all, but some, and it really shocked me.  Call me naive, I guess, but it was a surprising lesson for me.

It's also a lesson I've debated blogging about, but in the end decided it was better to open a dialogue about it than to let the incident pass without remark.

Too Fat To Deserve Help?

During our second-to-last class, we did a paper simulation of a disaster as practice for the real-time simulation the following week. We divided the class into two groups, set up our organizational structures, and then pretended to be the Command Center for organizing emergency response to a flood. They gave us index cards with emergency scenarios on them and we had to decide how to prioritize assigning help, how to manage volunteers, and how to get/distribute emergency equipment needed.

In one of those index-card scenarios, a downed tree blocked road access to a 300 lb. man having a heart attack. An ambulance was on its way to him but couldn't get through.

Can you guess how the Incident Commander responded?

Yup. She completely wrote him off and sent the ambulance somewhere else rather than have a volunteer go over with a chainsaw and cut away the tree. She didn't say it literally but basically implied that it was survival of the fittest at that point.

I was so angry I could hardly see straight. As soon as she heard his weight, she wrote him off and didn't even try to brainstorm ways to help him. Augh.

This was not an obnoxious fitness fanatic, mind.  She was just an ordinary person, a little plump herself, with her own physical challenges from past injuries.  I would have thought she would have been more empathetic, not less --- but she completely wrote off this man without even trying to find ways to work the problem.

If it had been a matter of saving greater numbers of people, I would understand not making this man a priority. In an emergency, you have to help the most people possible, and a scene involving many victims in mortal danger is going to get priority over a scene involving only one victim in mortal danger.

But most of the multiple-victim events we were given were not life-threatening, this was clearly one of the most life-threatening events presented, and there was plenty of volunteer help to go around.

It was clear that she didn't choose to abandon him because he was only one person or because we had limited resources; she chose to abandon him because he was fat.

If it was simply a matter of not being able to lift him, I would even understand that up to a point too. Larger people are harder to lift and can injure their rescuers. In a really pressing, life-and-death, every-second-counts evacuation situation, hard choices might have to be made about who could be most easily transported and saved. While I wouldn't like it, there are some physical limitations that can cause hard choices to have to be made under the most pressing circumstances.

But this wasn't one of those. All that had to be done was to send someone over to cut away the tree. It would only take up the time of one or two volunteers, and chainsaws were available for use in our scenario. 

Ordinary volunteers would not have to lift this man because an ambulance was almost to his location.  Most ambulance crews have equipment and experience in dealing with larger patients. They do it frequently enough that they have learned how to do it as safely as possible.  It's not their ideal but they generally have experience with it. And unless he had passed out, the patient probably would have been able to help; many heart attack victims can move around to some extent. Furthermore, the crew was already almost there -- they just needed help to get the last couple of blocks there.  It's not like extraordinary measures would have to be taken to get to him or to get him into the ambulance.

I pointed all these things out during our paper simulation and fought for this theoretical guy's life....to no avail. I argued several times.....she wouldn't listen. Her mind was made up when she heard "300 lbs." As soon as his weight was said, she had an audible negative reaction and immediately decided not to send help. 

The ironic thing was, the patient wasn't all that large.  Yes, 300 lbs. is no lightweight but the public has a distorted view of what "300 lbs." looks like.  They think of the headless fatties photos in the media, or they think of the "super-super-obese" person who is bedridden and can't get out their door. In reality, they probably know several 300 lb. people but have no idea that these acquaintances weigh about that much.  Their view about what 300 lbs. "must" look like distorts their judgments about helping.

My husband is about the size of the man in the scenario, but he is tall, built like a linebacker, and carries it well enough that most people would never guess he weighed that much.  I wonder if our Incident Commander realized that someone else sitting in that very classroom was that size, and she was basically denying help to one of her classmates?  I thought about telling her that in essence, she had just decided to let my husband die, but in the end I decided that was too potentially embarrassing for my husband and son to bring that up, so I didn't.

In the end, I had to remember my CERT training, which is that sometimes you have to go along with a decision you don't agree with when you are not the one in command. If I'd created a big argument, needed help would have gone unassigned while people bickered, and theoretical victims might have died in the interim. I had to look at the big picture and move on, but I made sure she knew I disagreed first.

(In a real scenario, I hope I would've found a way to get this guy help even if I had to take the damn chainsaw and go myself.)

Post-Incident Reflections

When we discussed our decision-making process afterwards, no one else protested denying help to the person of size.  I mentioned my disagreement but didn't make a huge deal of it because it would lead to unpleasant places I knew my husband and son weren't ready for.  (No one is as easily embarrassed as a teenaged boy whose mother is putting up a fuss, and my husband wasn't really ready to have his weight discussed in a public forum like that.)

In retrospect, I wish I had been more vocal in pointing out the discriminatory nature of her decision.  I feel I dropped the ball by not making it an opportunity for dialogue, and I'm still kicking myself over that.

The supervisor did note another alternative no one had thought of -- instead of trying to get the ambulance to the heart attack victim, we could have tried getting the heart attack victim to the ambulance. The big guy's loved ones could have put him in a rolling chair and rolled him down the street to the ambulance. That wouldn't have needed any volunteers assigned to the case and wouldn't have required special equipment other than a rolling chair (which many people have in their home offices).  Its success would have depended on the condition of the roads but it was worth giving a shot. He said rolling chairs are excellent alternatives that are often overlooked in emergency scenarios.

However, I still felt like this was a clear case of discrimination. If the patient had been average-sized (or no specified weight), the Incident Commander would have found a way to get a volunteer with a chainsaw to the tree and gotten that ambulance to the victim. She was working the problem till the moment she heard his weight.

The one bright spot in this was that the bias wasn't universal.  The other team made the big guy a priority and he was one of the first people they helped. Weight didn't seem to influence their decision process.

It was good to know that not everyone would discriminate against larger patients during an emergency....but it was quite upsetting to realize that some would, even when there was a relatively easy fix.

Closing Thoughts

At this point, I should remind folks again that the CERT class was excellent.  In no way did it promote discriminating against fat people, and the skills it taught would be very valuable to people of any size.  It is certainly a class well worth taking, for people of all sizes.

But the "community" nature of the program means that the community responders may reflect many of the biases of society. Some of those people might see fat people as less worthy of saving than others, or as too much trouble to waste resources on.  It was frustrating to see that in action, even if it was "just" a theoretical scenario. 

The lesson I took from this disturbing incident was not to specify someone's weight in an emergency call unless it's really relevant (i.e. special equipment is needed), and to know that I, as a person of size, might have to be more assertive about getting myself or other fat loved ones equal care.

*Comments?  Thoughts?  Experiences?

Thursday, September 9, 2010

CERT - Community Emergency Preparedness

One of my projects for the past summer was to sign up for a "CERT" class.  It really was an excellent experience and I highly recommend it to others.

CERT stands for Community Emergency Response Training.  The idea is that if there is a serious emergency, police, firefighters, and EMTs will be overwhelmed and won't be able to get to all the people who need help in a very timely manner.  They will have to prioritize and go to the most critical locales first, places where the maximum amount of lives can be saved, or places critical to the community (like schools, hospitals, etc.).  Therefore, the chances of them responding to you in your neighborhood --- or at your workplace -- are small in the immediate hours after an emergency.  That means you could be a long time on your own before help arrives.

To help fill the gap, the government created a program to help train community responders to supplement the efforts of professional first responders.  Community responders would help their own families first, then respond to others in an expanding circle around their location, helping out until first-responders could get there to take over. 

CERT team members would help organize interim medical care, do light search and rescue, and do basic safety procedures (turning off the gas if it's leaking, operating fire extinguishers for small fires, find a safe location for victims, etc.)  CERT members would also do basic triage --- separating the wounded into different groups based on seriousness of the injuries --- so that when first responders arrive (or when transport is available), the most serious cases can get help more quickly.  Until first responders arrive or patients are transported, CERT members also provide as much medical care to victims as circumstances and their skills allow. 

I'd heard about the CERT classes in our area for several years, but never felt I could take time for the class.  I had small babies at home that I could not easily leave, or was responsible for the care of ill family members whose needs were too unpredictable for committing to a class series.  But finally, I decided the time was right and made it my goal to get this training going this summer.

I had to drag my husband and my oldest son to the class, kicking and screaming the whole way.  We've all had First Aid/CPR classes, my husband was an Eagle Scout, and my son has had e-prep (emergency prep) as part of his path towards becoming an Eagle too.  Both of them thought that this class series would be just more of the same stuff they already knew.

They were wrong, and at the end of the class, they admitted so to me.  (Yes!)  The classes went way beyond what they'd already learned, complemented the skills they already had, and took their preparations much further.  Now they are CERT converts, and we want to spread the word to others in the community as well. 

About CERT Classes

A CERT class is FREE; it doesn't cost you a penny to take the class. You can find out more about CERT here, and you can search for classes in your local area here. Or you can just google "CERT classes" and the name of your city or area to see if there is a CERT website specifically for your area. 

A CERT class is usually 6-8 weeks long, depending on your location, and 2-3 hours each session. However, many large employers arrange to have longer classes done in 2 work days for their employees, so getting it through your work is also an option if you don't want to commit to a 6-8 week session. CERT often also does 2-day training with local school districts; you might be able to get the class that way.

Bonus: You often get free "goodies" at the end of the class. The class is sponsored by grants from FEMA and other government agencies, so money is available for emergency coordinators to buy limited amounts of basic safety equipment for participants. What you get will vary from location to location, but our class gave us hard hats, high-visibility safety vests, tools for turning off gas and water, work gloves, eye protection, a waterproof book with all the CERT information summarized in it, and several other small little "door prizes." I packed these (plus a few other items, like nitrile gloves, flashlights, duct tape, etc.) into a backpack and now carry it with me at all times in my car for quick access in case of an emergency.

Here is some information about CERT classes from the official CERT website:
CERT is about readiness, people helping people, rescuer safety, and doing the greatest good for the greatest number. CERT is a positive and realistic approach to emergency and disaster situations where citizens will be initially on their own and their actions can make a difference. Through training, citizens can manage utilities and put out small fires; treat the three killers by opening airways, controlling bleeding, and treating for shock; provide basic medical aid; search for and rescue victims safely; and organize themselves and spontaneous volunteers to be effective...

The Federal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) recognizes the importance of preparing citizens. The Emergency Management Institute (EMI) and the National Fire Academy adopted and expanded the CERT materials believing them applicable to all hazards.
What Does The Class Cover?

The CERT class series usually covers seven sessions/topics.  Some class series compress these into six sessions or expand them into eight, but basically there are seven sessions, summarized here from the website:
  • Session I, DISASTER PREPAREDNESS: Addresses hazards to which people are vulnerable in their community. Materials cover actions that participants and their families take before, during, and after a disaster. As the session progresses, the instructor begins to explore an expanded response role for civilians in that they should begin to consider themselves disaster workers. Since they will want to help their family members and neighbors, this training can help them operate in a safe and appropriate manner. The CERT concept and organization are discussed as well as applicable laws governing volunteers in that jurisdiction.
  • Session II, DISASTER FIRE SUPPRESSION: Briefly covers fire chemistry, hazardous materials, fire hazards, and fire suppression strategies. However, the thrust of this session is the safe use of fire extinguishers, sizing up the situation, controlling utilities, and extinguishing a small fire.
  • Session III, DISASTER MEDICAL OPERATIONS PART I: Participants practice diagnosing and treating airway obstruction, bleeding, and shock by using simple triage and rapid treatment techniques.
  • Session IV, DISASTER MEDICAL OPERATIONS, PART II: Covers evaluating patients by doing a head to toe assessment, establishing a medical treatment area, performing basic first aid, and practicing in a safe and sanitary manner.
  • Session V, LIGHT SEARCH AND RESCUE OPERATIONS: Participants learn about search and rescue planning, size-up, search techniques, rescue techniques, and most important, rescuer safety.
  • Session VI, DISASTER PSYCHOLOGY AND TEAM ORGANIZATION: Covers signs and symptoms that might be experienced by the disaster victim and worker. It addresses CERT organization and management principles and the need for documentation.
  • Session VII, COURSE REVIEW AND DISASTER SIMULATION: Participants review their answers from a take home examination. Finally, they practice the skills that they have learned during the previous six sessions in disaster activity.
As you can see, some of the class was review of First Aid skills we already knew, but it was still useful because it was more advanced.  For example, a lot of current First Aid classes don't teach you things like splinting broken bones anymore, because first responders can get there so fast and do a more reliable job. But in an extended emergency, you better believe that knowing how to splint bones (or how to deal with penetrating wounds) will come in handy.  Plus it's good to learn how to quickly evaluate and prioritize ("triage") wounds so you can deal more effectively with a large volume of patients.

The class also covered stuff I've never had before -- like Search And Rescue (SAR).  It showed us how to "crib" --- use wood and other materials you can scavenge from your area to lift heavy things off of people safely --- so you can get victims out of damaged buildings and into medical care. It was truly fascinating to see how putting physics to use in a practical way could help you rescue people you might otherwise not be able to help. (We lifted a giant van off of a crash dummy for our practice, something most of us would not have been able to do without knowing cribbing.) We discussed various ways of moving people and how to protect yourself when doing so, all very practical and useful skills.

The class gave us hands-on practice in putting out minor fires with fire extinguishers (which is how I convinced my teenage son to go to the class!).  That was fun.  Even though fire extinguishers are easy to use, there's more to consider than you might realize, so the hands-on practice was really useful.  Frankly, a small home fire is one of the emergencies you are more likely to encounter in your life, so although fire extinguisher practice is a really basic skill, it may well have been one of the most useful things we worked on. 

One of the best things the class taught us was the best way to organize others in an emergency, how to lessen the risk for rescuer injury, and how to document details of the situation to ease transition with first responders.  There are organizational structures that lead to more efficient rescues, and this leads to better outcomes than a lot of people doing free-lance vigilante rescues and possibly getting injured too.  Knowing how to set up an efficient organizational structure, knowing what safety hazards to look for, and knowing what information and on-ground organization would be most useful to first-responders when they DO arrive was incredibly valuable. 

And of course, the class also promoted getting yourself prepared for an emergency.  I'm more prepared than many folks because I at least have an emergency kit, but even I had a fair amount of work to do (and am still working on re-organizing things more efficiently). 

As I've mentioned before, some years ago I lived near an area that had a major earthquake, and I will never forget the news coverage of the aftermath.  Many areas really did have to fend for themselves for a while, people had to rely on each other for rescue and initial medical help, and people had to do without power, water and food for some time.  Are you prepared to do something like that?  Could you keep your family warm, hydrated, and fed if the power grid went down for days, weeks, or more?  Could you provide help if a loved one was injured in a disaster? This class helps you figure out what's most important to have in an emergency kit, where to get supplies, how to afford building a kit a little at a time, and how to organize it. 

At the end of the class, everyone had to participate in a simulated emergency so they could practice using the skills we learned.  That was really an eye-opening experience.  You think you've learned everything really well, but to actually put those skills to use in a safe test environment leads to insights and improvements you wouldn't have gotten otherwise. 

Our class simulated responding to a school (during extra-curricular activities) after an earthquake.  It was interesting to see which skills held up and which ones didn't, whether we remembered our training, and where the gaps in our learning were.  We ran the scenario twice, and of course the second time we improved our response....but it was really important to be part of that first, not-so-efficient response because that's the one we really learned from.

I was more than a little intimidated by the thought of participating in the simulated emergency....I hate doing a poor job at anything and I was also concerned about whether I could physically handle it......but it was fine. I was able to physically handle it, we all failed to one degree or another in our organizational tasks, and the firefighters who supervised us were pretty good at helping us learn from our mistakes.  That was incredibly useful and is an important part of the program. 

Once you complete the initial training, they also have follow-up training available in specific skills, and periodic emergency drills in the community where you can practice keeping up your basic skills.  Follow-up training and drills are all completely voluntary; you don't have to do anything more than the basic CERT training, but many people like to go further.  I think I will, in time.

What Emergencies Are Likely In Your Area?

It was useful to discuss the most likely emergencies in our area.  The organizers were not survivalists, preparing for the end of the world via nuclear attack by terrorists.  Although possible, that is not as likely an emergency scenario as natural disasters etc. Emergencies happen in all parts of the country, and we spent time discussing which were the most likely emergencies to prepare for in our area and what preparation would be most valuable for those scenarios. 

For example, in some parts of the country, the biggest thing to worry about is tornadoes, in which case search and rescue skills might be especially important. In others, it's hurricanes, in which search and rescue skills and ability to be without power for extended times might be important.  In others, it's wildfires or mudslides or floods, in which having a "grab and go" kit would be important. In others, it's winter storms, in which having a way to stay warm without power for a while and an emergency kit for your car would be important.  In others, it's earthquakes, in which many of the above skills would be needed. 

The key is to familiarize yourself with the most likely scenarios for your area, prepare for those, and then if you want to worry about the less likely things like terrorist attacks or nuclear fallout, you can prepare for those as well.

Can I Handle CERT Training?

One reason I had hesitated to become involved in CERT was because I wasn't sure I was fit enough to handle it.  I injured my knees in a bad car accident a couple of years ago and haven't been able to exercise as much as before, so I wasn't sure if I'd physically be up for what was needed.  Before I signed up, I wrote the emergency coordinator for our city and asked him whether I should take the class.

He replied yes, absolutely.  He noted that they have many people of all different physical abilities and challenges in the program.  Some skills, like search and rescue, need a higher fitness level, it's true.  Unless it was my own kids stuck in the rubble, I probably would not be aggressively going in and doing SAR.  But many jobs are supervisory, organizational, or medical, and I was more than capable of doing those. 

So that's what I did in our disaster simulation; the first time through I helped with the command structure and organizational stuff, and the second time through I helped with the medical treatment areas.  And I was perfectly fine at doing those, even with my physical challenges. 

So don't let being fat or having physical challenges keep you from getting trained.  Yes, there are some jobs you might not be able to do, but we really did have a wide variety of ages and abilities in the class.  Many were seniors; one had broken her leg really badly the previous year and could not help with Search and Rescue either.  So she become Incident Commander on our second run-through, and did a great job. 

The point is that everyone is needed in an emergency, and everyone has a potential role to play in helping others, and there are many jobs available.  Don't let fitness or physical challenges keep you from taking the training.

Wednesday, September 1, 2010

Delaying Routine GYN Care

Aldrich T, Hackley B.  "The impact of obesity on gynecologic cancer screening: an integrative literature review." J Midwifery Womens Health. 2010 Jul;55(4):344-56.

Abstract

INTRODUCTION: Evidence indicates lower rates of breast and cervical cancer screening among obese compared to nonobese women. This integrative review examines the association between gynecologic cancer screening and body weight, as well as potential barriers to screening.

METHODS: A literature search of standard computerized databases was conducted for peer-reviewed articles published between 1950 and January 2009.

RESULTS: Twenty-three studies met the criteria for review. Of the 17 studies that evaluated rates of cervical cancer screening, 13 found obese women significantly less likely than their nonobese counterparts to have had a recent Papanicolaou test, a trend that was stronger in white women when compared to African American women. Eight of the 15 studies examining routine mammography found an inverse association between increasing body weight and recent screening, although findings generally pertained only to women who were white and/or severely obese. Possible barriers to care included embarrassment and perceived weight stigma in the clinical setting, lack of appropriately sized examination equipment, and poor patient-provider communication.

DISCUSSION: Further research is needed to clarify the challenges that obese women face in accessing care and to evaluate strategies such as ensuring the availability of appropriate equipment and supplies, the use of alternative screening methodologies, and more culturally sensitive counseling approaches that may improve screening rates in obese women.

PMID: 20630361

*Have you delayed or avoided gynecologic care because of past size-negative encounters with healthcare providers?  Or because of lack of appropriately-sized equipment?  Or other reasons related to size or weight bias?

Monday, August 30, 2010

Antibiotic Underdosing in "Obesity"

One of the most critical areas of research in improving treatment and outcomes for "obese" people is the issue of weight-based dosing. 

In many drugs, dosages have been determined based on the norm of average-sized people.  This means that people who are significantly under or over this "norm" may not be receiving the dosage most optimal for their size, with lean folk potentially being overtreated and fat folk likely being vastly undertreated. 

Underdosing is of particular concern for "obese" people because it may lead to subtherapeutic concentrations of drugs and deteriorating outcomes over time.

However, deciding on optimal drug dosages is not a simple task.  Concern for obtaining the most effective dose must be balanced against concern over toxicity from a too-large dose. 

In the past, doctors were understandably reluctant to prescribe a very large dose of various medications for people with larger bodyweights because they were concerned about the potential for massive toxicity. 

In fact, doctors sometimes intentionally reduced the dose because they were concerned about greater possible toxicity in "obese" people.

Now, however, there is emerging evidence that in many drugs, outcomes are improved with the larger doses and suboptimal with smaller doses. 

This is one of the most pressing issues in pharmocotherapy because extensive research is needed to determine optimal dosing and which drugs benefit most from weight-based dosing, but this research has been slow to happen.  And even when the research is there, some doctors have been slow to adopt new guidelines. 

Let's look at several critical areas in which underdosing is a major issue.  First up.....antibiotics.

Antibiotic Underdosing

Antibiotic underdosing in "obese" people may be one reason why fat people have poorer outcomes after surgery and/or infections.  Furthermore, underdosing may be a particularly serious problem in very fat people. 

Remember, when you are on antibiotics, you are cautioned to take the entire prescription, not to stop when you start feeling well.  If you stop too soon, the bug may still be there at low levels. Then, when the antibiotics are stopped, the bug may opportunistically spring back to life in a more severe or antibiotic-resistant form. 

A similar effect may happen when "obese" people are underdosed with antibiotics.  The bug may be only partially knocked out, return in time stronger than before, or worse, develop a resistance to the subtherapeutic-level antibiotic.

This may be one reason (among several) why infection is a particular problem for "obese" people after surgery....the antibiotic dosages given to them may not be strong enough. 

Of course, different drugs work by different mechanisms.  Therefore, not all drugs need weight-based dosing because of the unique way they work........but it's clear that some do, and that the importance of this factor is only now becoming more recognized in the medical field. 

For example, even recent research (see study abstracts below) shows that:
  • Many "obese" people are still routinely underdosed with antibiotics, especially "morbidly" and "super-obese" people
  • Revised guidelines for weight-based dosing are underutilized by healthcare professionals
  • Far more research needs to be done into the most effective drug dosages for people of varying sizes, but particularly for very fat people
It's very disappointing that there isn't more definitive information on this topic in this day and age.  You would think that this would have been well-studied by now.....or that there would be a tremendous push for more research on this right now, given recent studies showing the problem. 

Yet there really doesn't seem to be a sense of urgency or priority on this in the research.  There are a number of studies noting the paucity of research on the topic and pointing out the need for more, but there are few studies actually conducting research into this important area. 

[Ironically, what studies there are often are on weight-loss surgery patients. We may finally be starting to get data on drug dosages for very fat people, if only because bariatric surgeons need to improve their surgery stats.]

At the very least, more doctors should be aware of what research and guidelines we do have for more effective dosing...but they apparently aren't because it doesn't seem to be affecting the way many of them prescribe (see vancomycin study below).

You have to wonder how many fat people have died or been gravely ill because their doctors didn't utilize the most effective dosage for them.

This is really a critical area for future research and education among health-care professionals. But until they start paying more attention to this issue, it's up to us, as fat consumers, to push for more action and to advocate strongly for ourselves if we get sick. 

Standardized Dosing

Another problem that commonly leads to chronic underdosing of "obese" people is standardized dosing, where little or no flexibility is offered to the doctors regarding dose size. 

Weight-based dosing is all well and good when it's easy to adjust dosages (as in IV antibiotic therapy in the hospital) but many commonly-prescribed antibiotics are only offered in a "one-size-fits-all" package.

For example, a few years ago, I developed a roaring secondary bacterial infection around a holiday and went to an emergent care center to get quick treatment for it.  They recognized I really needed antibiotics at that point.  I asked them about weight-based dosing, and the doctor admitted that weight-based dosing probably would be more beneficial for someone of my size.  However, he pointed out that he had no choice because the medication only came in one dosage.  It was that or nothing. 

I needed two rounds of antibiotics to beat that bug.  The first one started to knock it out, and then it came back a couple of weeks later, stronger than ever (at which point I started coughing up blood). I'm lucky the bug got wiped out by the second dose of antibiotics. If I had been older or more fragile, that bug might easily have gotten me because it was a really nasty one.

Was my delayed recovery because I was underdosed due to standardized dosing?  Hard to know for sure because I've not found a lot of dosing information about that particular antibiotic, but I suspect underdosing might well have played a role. And how even more undertreated might I have been had I been truly supersized?

Of course, sometimes standardized dosing is logical.  In an emergency, no one has time to stop and figure out weight-based dosing and dispense it.  In situations where time is of the essence (i.e. trauma surgery, emergent cesareans), having standardized doses available makes sense. 

But many surgeries are pre-planned and there is plenty of time to figure out the proper dosage of antibiotic to really lower the chances of wound infection.  Yet, hospital protocol or lack of knowledge/data about weight-based dosing often prevents its use even when time allows for it. 

So although I'm still learning about this topic (and welcome feedback from healthcare professionals who are well-versed in pharmocotherapy), I think it's important to:
  • Start raising awareness among fat people to ask more questions from their healthcare providers about weight-based dosing and when it's needed
  • Ask healthcare professionals to raise their awareness of the issue
  • Start pressuring healthcare researchers to do further study of this important topic
If half of Americans are "overweight" or "obese," then prompt attention to this issue is quite pressing so that outcomes can be improved in this group.

This problem is also pressing to the general public because antibiotic resistance is on the rise. If subtherapeutic levels lead to more antibiotic resistance, then underdosing "obese" people may be adding to the critical public health issue of antibiotic resistance.

Therefore, finding out and promoting the proper dosages for people of size may benefit not only fat people, but society as a whole. 

Research on Antibiotic Underdosing

In the meantime, here are two recent study abstracts on the topic of antibiotic underdosing in "obese" people. I was particularly struck by the vancomycin study. 

Vancomycin is a very strong antibiotic, typically used for severe infections; in the past it was often a drug of last resort.  Therefore, proper dosing of it is critical, especially the initial dose to "knock out" the infection, and then therapeutic dosages to keep the infection down and out afterwards.

Yet in the study, only 1/3 of "obese" patients received an "adequate" initial dose of vancomycin.

If you look at the full text of the study (available here), you see that when they further examined dosage by class of obesity, NONE of the people with BMI greater than 40 received an adequate initial dosage.

Furthermore, less than 1% of the whole "obese" group received the recommended weight-based dose.

They concluded: 
Our results highlight the fact that obese patients may be routinely underdosed as a result of the widespread practice of prescribing fixed-dose vancomycin.
The authors also noted that another study has suggested that dosing intervals may need to be more frequent in the "obese" population in order to maintain minimum therapeutic levels, which is another intriguing consideration. 

Other studies have found that it's not only the dosage of antibiotics that counts, it's also the length of treatment.  "Morbidly obese" people may benefit from a longer course of antibiotics than is standard.

Furthermore, recent studies have found that in particularly infection-prone areas, application of additional topical antibiotics into the surgical incision area significantly reduces the rate of post-operative infection. 

So the the concept of antibiotic underdosing may not just be about how much antibiotics should be given to fat people, but also where they are given, how often they should be given, and for how long. 

I'd love to see more specific studies devoted to these questions.

Final Thoughts

If antibiotic underdosing is so common in people of size, is it any wonder that "obese" patients have poorer outcomes from infections and after surgery? 

Granted, many variables factor into why "obese" people respond less effectively to wounds and infections, and antibiotic underdosing is definitely not the only issue.  It's important to be fair about that.  It's not only about antibiotic dosing.

However, underdosing is quite likely a vastly underestimated reason for poorer outcomes, and one that should be relatively easy to fix, given more awareness of and research into the problem.  We can't do a lot about other factors that cause poorer outcomes and higher infection rates, but dosing is a relatively easy problem to fix.

Therefore, it seems extremely important to me to raise more awareness around this issue and start pressing for more and better research on the topic.


Here are the research abstracts.  (Obviously, highlights and emphasis are mine.)

Multicenter evaluation of vancomycin dosing: emphasis on obesity. Hall RG 2nd, Payne KD, Bain AM, Rahman AP, Nguyen ST, Eaton SA, Busti AJ, Vu SL, Bedimo R.  Am J Med. 2008 Jun;121(6):515-8.

Department of Pharmacy Practice, Texas Tech University Health Sciences Center, School of Pharmacy, Dallas, Texas, USA.

BACKGROUND: There is a paucity of data available regarding the dosing of antimicrobials in obesity. However, data are available demonstrating that vancomycin should be dosed on the basis of actual body weight.

METHODS: This study was conducted at 2 tertiary care medical centers that did not have pharmacy-guided vancomycin dosing programs or other institutional vancomycin dosing policies or protocols. Patients who received vancomycin between July 1, 2003, and June 30, 2006, were stratified by body mass index and randomly selected from the computer-generated queries. Patients greater or equal to 18 years of age with a creatinine clearance of at least 60 mL/min who received vancomycin for at least 36 hours were included.

RESULTS: Data were collected on a random sampling of 421 patients, stratified by body mass index, who met the inclusion criteria. Most patients in each body mass index category received a fixed dose of vancomycin 2 g daily divided into 2 doses (underweight 82%, normal weight 90%, overweight 86%, and obese 91%).

Adequate initial dosing (greater than or=10 mg/kg/dose) was achieved for 100% of underweight, 99% of normal weight, 93.9% of overweight, and 27.7% of obese patients (P less than .0001).

Ninety-seven percent of underweight, 46% of normal weight, 1% of overweight, and 0.6% of obese patients received greater than or =15 mg/kg/dose recommended by several Infectious Diseases Society of America guidelines.

Pharmacists also failed to correct inadequate dosing because only 3.3% of patients receiving less than 10 mg/kg/dose had their regimen changed in the first 24 hours of therapy.

CONCLUSION: In this multicenter pilot study, obese patients routinely received inadequate empiric vancomycin using a lenient assessment of dosing. Greater efforts should be undertaken to ensure patients receive weight-based dosing because inadequate dosing can lead to subtherapeutic concentrations and potentially worse clinical outcomes.

PMID: 18501233   Full text available here. 


Antimicrobial dosing considerations in obese adult patients. Pai MP, Bearden DT.  Pharmacotherapy. 2007 Aug;27(8):1081-91.

Division of Pharmacy Practice, College of Pharmacy, University of New Mexico, Albuquerque, New Mexico, USA.

As obesity continues to increase in prevalence throughout the world, it becomes important to explore the effects that obesity has on antimicrobial disposition. Physiologic changes in obesity can alter both the volume of distribution and clearance of many commonly used antimicrobials. These changes often present challenges such as estimation of creatinine clearance to predict drug clearance.

Although these physiologic changes are increasingly being characterized, few studies assessing alterations in tissue drug distribution and the effects of obesity on antimicrobial pharmacokinetics have been published. The available data are most plentiful for antibiotics that historically have included clinical therapeutic drug monitoring.

These data suggest that dosing of vancomycin and aminoglycosides be based on total body weight and adjusted body weight, respectively. Obese patients may require larger doses of beta-lactams to achieve similar concentrations as those of patients who are not obese. Fluoroquinolone pharmacokinetics are variably altered by obesity, which prevents a uniform approach. Data on the pharmacokinetics of drugs that have activity against gram-positive organisms-quinupristin-dalfopristin, linezolid, and daptomycin-reveal that they are altered in the presence of obesity, but more data are needed to solidify dosing recommendations. Limited data are available on nonantibacterials.

An understanding of the physiologic changes in obesity and the available literature on specific antibiotics is valuable in providing a framework for rational selection of dosages in this increasingly common population of obese patients.

PMID: 17655508

Friday, August 27, 2010

Lazy, Slothful, and Indolent

This study sounds like good source material for those in the fat studies field. 

'Lazy, slothful and indolent': medical and social perceptions of obesity in Europe to the eighteenth century.

Sawbridge DT, Fitzgerald R. Vesalius. 2009 Dec;15(2):59-70.

University of Edinburgh.

Abstract

There is a considerable stigma associated with obesity, among healthcare professionals as well as the general population, which often leads to discrimination and weight bias. But why is there a stigma attached to obesity?

The origin of this stigma has been identified in the 18th century but its roots lie much further back in history. There is some debate about how this negative perception of obesity arose and the role of medical professionals in its creation. This paper examines both positive and negative conceptions by following three major aspects of the modern stigma through from Palaeolithic statues to the medical texts of ancient Greece and Rome, finishing with the medical and literary sources of the 18th century 'Enlightenment'.

The modern perception of obesity originated in the social and scientific climate of the Enlightenment through the combination of three key themes;

  • obesity as conspicuous consumption,
  • associations with suspect morals and excess, and
  • as an outward representation of the soul
The evolution of each of these themes can be clearly identfied in pre-Enlightenment sources. By the eighteenth century, these perceptions became amplified by, and disseminated through, the literary and media boom to create a recognisably modern stigma against the obese.

PMID: 20527324

*Think about the typical "obese" characters on TV or in books, movies, and plays.  Most of them pretty much fit into "obesity as conspicuous consumption," "associations with suspect morals and excess," or "outward representation of the soul," don't they?

Which characters can you think of that fit these stereotypes? 

The one that springs immediately to my mind is the Baron in the Sting movie version of "Dune."  I think he fits all three of those.  Fat Hate Bingo!

Anyone else care to play?

Monday, August 23, 2010

Please Document Your Stories of Mistreatment

For years, I've made it a practice to document stories of fat-phobic treatment and weight bias in fertility, pregnancy, birth, and parenting. 

I do this for several reasons.

First, I find that many health practitioners simply aren't aware of (or don't believe) the extent of discrimination that exists out there towards women of size. Documenting actual stories helps them gain a better understanding of what some women of size have been through and why many are hesitant or negative about seeing a care provider. It also helps hold up a mirror (to medical professionals in general and to maternity providers in particular) to their own attitudes and practices, and helps them understand how bias -- even unconscious bias -- can slip through and how it impacts women.

Second, I think it's important that these experiences be documented simply because all stories of discrimination and bias deserve to be acknowledged.  Fat women should not have to endure egregious treatment like this, and our experiences of discrimination and bias should be heard and honored.  For too long, we've been told that such treatment is our own damn fault, that we're "too sensitive" about these things, or that we shouldn't be questioning it --- it's for our own good because we're so incredibly high-risk.  Documenting these stories makes connections with the discrimination suffered by other groups, shows that discriminatory practices have patterns, and that weight bias is a real form of stigmatization and discrimination.

Finally, I think it's especially important to document stories like this so that the fat-acceptance movement and the birth world start to understand and grapple better with the problem of fat-phobic treatment and discrimination during pregnancy and birth, an issue they tend to ignore.  Surprisingly, over the years I've found more respect and attention to the issue of size discrimination in the birth world than I have in the fat-acceptance world, which I always find puzzling and frustrating. Much of the birth world has a long ways to go, but some segments of the fat-acceptance world (those who don't want/have children, or are young enough that it's not on their radar) have an even longer way to go.  Documenting how egregious the treatment can be in pregnancy and birth is important because it helps establish that there really is a problem here that deserves attention, regardless of whether size discrimination affects you personally and regardless of whether you have (or plan to have) children or not.

More Stories of Mistreatment

A few weeks ago, I re-posted an entry from My OB Said WHAT?!! about a fat woman being told that if she got pregnant, she'd get gestational diabetes, high blood pressure, and would probably "die anyway."  This is just one of several "gems" I've found like that on that site.

I was surprised to get a high number of comments from my readers relating similar discriminatory stories, stories I'd not heard before and didn't have documented. 

While I'm disappointed that these things are still happening in obstetrics and midwifery care even today, I'm glad to be able to document some more of these stories.

But I want readers to go further.  If you have a story like this, I want you to document it thoroughly, in multiple places. 

We must have a record of things like this happening if we ever want to see things change.

How and Where To Document Your Story

So how do you go about documenting your stories? 

First of all, you can always send them to me, at kmom AT plus-size-pregnancy DOT  org.  I like to keep a record of such stories; when sending your story, please give me your permission to use them as needed (i.e. on my blog, on my website, in presentations I make, etc.).  You don't have to use your own name; you can choose to be as anonymous as you wish.  Just remember to give explicit permission to use it.  [If you posted your story in a public forum like my comments section, I consider that explicit permission...you've already made it public.  But I still like to have formal permissions.]

Second, don't forget the blogs at:
The First Do No Harm site documents stories of discrimination against fat people in the healthcare world, but sadly, they have very few entries under pregnancy, reflecting the lack of crossover between the birth world and the fat-acceptance world, I think. The stories here on my blog need to get repeated there. 

The My OB Said What?!? site documents stories of outrageous treatment in the birth world; it's not just limited to fat folk, of course, but it's important that the birth world hear of size discrimination and weight bias and how prevalent it is.  And it's important that they hear about these stories from someone other than just me as well.  I am one of the very few voices out there talking about this; it would be great to have other voices corroborating the stories of weight bias and discrimination out there.

So if you have a story of bias or mistreatment, I urge you to submit your story and document it in multiple places.  There really is a lack of understanding and acknowledgement in both the birth and fat-acceptance worlds that such discrimination really exists and is so common, so be sure to document it in multiple places. 

Documenting our stories is one way to start raising awareness about this problem and start confronting and challenging such treatment.  We don't have to suffer in silence anymore, and by speaking up, we can start changing the status quo.

Here are just a few of the stories from the comments section of my last post, edited for length.  I thank these women for sharing, and highlight a few of their stories here because not everyone reads the comments and might have missed some of these.  [A few have beeen edited or broken into more than one story for the sake of readability.]
  • My last OB told me that I needed to lose 50 lbs during my pregnancy or else she was sure I'd need a c section and then a hysterectomy. I gained 4 lbs total, and my baby was 8lbs 6 oz. I will never see that doctor again. I refused to go to my 6 week check up because of some of the nonsense that went on during my labor/delivery.
  • I was told during my second pregnancy (I was about 6 weeks in) that I would have to have a c-section because I am fat. No ifs or buts, I simply would have to. I ended up having a straightforward natural (2 hour) labour and delivery and without any mention of a c-section.
  • I was told at the beginning of my pregnancy not to gain any weight AT ALL. And in fact to lose weight. When I asked why, he told me because otherwise, I was being selfish and putting my baby at risk. Thing is, I was stuck with him because I had no insurance at the time and the delivery (emergency c-section that I HAD to have) still gives me nightmares.
  • That I must have so much fat inside my vagina that I would not be able to give birth without forceps or more drastic interventions....That my blood pressure would shoot up in the midst of labor (despite having been perfectly normal all through my pregnancy) and I would die without IV drugs. Now, with my kids around me and the bed they were born in just a few steps away, I can laugh about it. Then, not so much.
  • My MIDWIFE told me that she couldn't feel my baby through all of my fat. Which is funny, because she would barely touch me. Her doppler couldn't find the heart rate because I was too fat too. Once she dropped me from her care, I interviewed several other midwives, all of which could feel the baby AND find the heartbeat.
  • I was mostly able to avoid the scare tactics, thankfully, but during my cesarean, after my husband left with the baby, someone said "We should just do some liposuction while we're in here."
  • In my first pregnancy, at 11 wks I started spotting heavily, and my GP sent me for an u/s to see what was happening. I ended up in the imaging department at our local hospital with a sonographer who was visibly put out with having to take care of me. At one point she told me to 'hold all that fat out of the way' so she could do her job, and how she wasn't sure she would be able to 'see anything through all the fat'. Not only was I beyond stressed over the possibilitiy of losing that pregnancy (which I did, sadly), but that 'professional' made me feel awful.
  • I was a virgin at my second gynecological exam requesting birth control for the first time and the doctor told me I needed to lose weight if I ever wanted to get pregnant. She said she would not "let me" get pregnant at my weight and that it would be too difficult for me to carry a child at my weight. I changed doctors when I found out I was pregnant a year later while on the Progestin-only birth control pill she prescribed me (I did research and that pill has a way lower rate of working on bigger women... - she never mentioned that). I was actually in fear that she would suggest an abortion or something drastic because she was so adamant that I not get pregnant at my weight. I think she thought I wasn't going to be having sex anyway at my weight or something like that. I weighed about 290. I am now 38 weeks pregnant at 305 pounds and the baby and I are doing great. No GD, no high blood pressure. We've been fine. Looking forward to a healthy baby later this month.
  • I've got a ton of horror stories. I moved to the SF Bay Area from Seattle when I was 28 weeks pregnant and spent hours on the phone looking for a doctor that wouldn't counsel immediate termination ("You or the baby will die, you are just too fat to carry to term."), "necessary" c-section ("Women of your size never have a natural labor. You will have to have a c-section.") or were anti-VBAC ...("Women with your BMI can't VBAC in our hospital. You won't find a better hospital in the area."). I wound up with a doctor that said she was comfortable VBACing who decided at 38 weeks that I needed an "emergency" c-section and called me in the middle of my grocery shopping about me "dying before the weekend was out" and generally pressured me into yet another c-section. Now I'm being told (by any doctor I can find) that a VBA2C is "impossible" at my size/BMI or at all.
  • I was told by my OB at the first office visit (8 weeks) that I needed to lose 15-20 lbs. When I asked if this would be harmful to the baby, I was told that I could safely LOSE weight during pregnancy and it would have no effect on my baby because I had so much "reserves" the baby could survive from that. Luckily I knew that was BS and ate normally to sustain my energy, stamina, and that of my baby. When he balked about my weight at every subsequent visit, I flat out told him that I KNOW how unstable I feel during dieting, and there's nothing he could say to convince me that would be healthy for my baby, he shut up.
  • On the day of induced delivery, my doctor (who had been cautioning me that I would "most likely" need a C-section because of my size) was afraid to break my water as I neared full dilation and effacement and called in the OB specialist again to perform the procedure. My doctor actually left the room during this procedure to scrub in and ensure there was an operating room available to do an emergency C-section. When the specialist was finished and labor progressed normally, my doctor was shocked. Within three hours, my 9lbs 1oz baby girl was born and proceeded to pee all over the doctor. Instant Karma.....gotta love it.
  • I am pregnant with identical twin girls. I went to the perinatologist and he lectured me for 20 minutes. Telling me I was going to have GD and high blood pressure, and that I needed to lose 20 pounds during this pregnancy.
  • I had an OB tell me (over the phone) that I wasn't "really" pregnant, since my BMI was too high for me to actually be pregnant. Her office then told me that they'd be happy to schedule me for a biopsy to determine what kind of tumor I had. I replied "The kind with two arms, two legs and a head." and hung up. (I was 28-ish weeks pregnant and had a number of ultrasounds under my belt.)
You can read more stories of size discrimination I've documented over the years here.  There are stories of fat women being pressured to abort --- simply because of their size.  There are stories of women being told that they will die if they dare to be pregnant at their size.  There are stories of women pushed to have cesareans they don't need (or intervened right into cesareans). There are stories of draconian diets and mega-interventions and abusive treatment, simply because of weight. 

Of course, not every woman of size encounters such egregious treatment.  Oftentimes the bias is more subtle than that, and sometimes arrives with completely good intentions from the provider....but it's still bias.  I encourage you to share those stories too. 

It's also important to note that some fat women DO receive truly size-friendly treatment during their pregnancies and births; if you are a woman of size already pregnant or just considering pregnancy, please don't despair.  It IS possible to get decent treatment, and of course not all OBs or midwives are horrible people or size bigots.

But size discrimination does occur and I believe it's becoming more and more common as the rhetoric in the "War on Obesity" heats up. So it's important to keep documenting and challenging these incidents, both subtle and overt, as often as possible.

Please, folks, take time to document your stories, in as many places as possible.

Health care professionals and the general public need to become more aware of the scope of the problem of size discrimination.  It's the first step towards change.

Saturday, August 21, 2010

"The Solution Needs to be Complex"

"The solution needs to be complex." Obese adults' attitudes about the effectiveness of individual and population based interventions for obesity.

Thomas SL, Lewis S, Hyde J, Castle D, Komesaroff P. BMC Public Health. 2010 Jul 15;10:420.

Consumer Health Research Group (CHaRGe), Primary Care Research Unit, Monash University, Melbourne, Australia.

Abstract

ABSTRACT: BACKGROUND: Previous studies of public perceptions of obesity interventions have been quantitative and based on general population surveys. This study aims to explore the opinions and attitudes of obese individuals towards population and individual interventions for obesity in Australia.

METHODS: Qualitative methods using in-depth semi-structured telephone interviews with a community sample of obese adults (Body Mass Index greater than or =30). Theoretical, purposive and strategic recruitment techniques were used to ensure a broad sample of obese individuals with different types of experiences with their obesity.

Participants were asked about their attitudes towards three population based interventions (regulation, media campaigns, and public health initiatives) and three individual interventions (tailored fitness programs, commercial dieting, and gastric banding surgery), and the effectiveness of these interventions.

RESULTS: One hundred and forty two individuals (19-75 years) were interviewed.

Participants strongly supported non-commercial interventions that were focused on encouraging individuals to make healthy lifestyle changes (regulation, physical activity programs, and public health initiatives).

There was less support for interventions perceived to be invasive or high risk (gastric band surgery), stigmatising (media campaigns), or commercially motivated and promoting weight loss techniques (commercial diets and gastric banding surgery).

CONCLUSION: Obese adults support non-commercial, non-stigmatising interventions which are designed to improve lifestyles, rather than promote weight loss.

PMID: 20633250

Monday, August 16, 2010

Weight Bias Among Dietetics Students

Puhl R, Wharton C, Heuer C. Weight bias among dietetics students: implications for treatment practices. J Am Diet Assoc. 2009 Mar;109(3):438-44.

Rudd Center for Food Policy and Obesity, Yale University, 309 Edwards, New Haven, CT 06520, USA.

Abstract

BACKGROUND: Several studies have examined attitudes about obesity among food and nutrition professionals, yielding mixed results, and no experimental research has tested the impact of dietitians' attitudes on their treatment practices or health evaluations with obese patients.

OBJECTIVE: This study investigated attitudes of dietetics students toward obese persons and tested whether a patient's body weight influences students' treatment decisions and health evaluations within a randomized experiment.

DESIGN: Between the months of September and December 2007, a convenience sample of 182 dietetics undergraduate students (92% women; mean age 23.1+/-5.4 years) from colleges throughout the United States completed online self-report surveys to assess weight bias (using the Fat Phobia Scale). Participants were also randomly assigned to read one of four mock health profiles of patients who varied only by weight-related characteristics (eg, obese or average weight) and sex (male or female), and asked to make judgments about the patient's health status and participation in treatment.

STATISTICAL ANALYSES PERFORMED: To compare group data, multiple analysis of variance was used to test for an effect of the patient's body mass index on participants' health evaluations and their perceptions of patients in each of the four experimental conditions. Correlations were calculated between mean fat phobia scores and perceptions of patients.

RESULTS: Participants in all conditions expressed a moderate amount of fat phobia (mean=3.7), and students rated obese patients as being less likely to comply with treatment recommendations compared with nonobese patients (P less than 0.05).

Results from multivariate analysis of variance tests showed students also evaluated obese patients' diet quality and health status to be poorer than nonobese patients, despite equivalent nutritional and health information across weight categories for each sex in patient profiles.

In contrast, obese and nonobese patients were rated to be similarly motivated, receptive, and successful in treatment.

CONCLUSION: Implications of these findings for education and intervention in dietetics training are discussed, with emphasis on increasing awareness of weight bias in existing dietetics curricula.

PMID: 19248859

*Comments?  Personal experiences with fat-phobic dieticians? Or size-friendly dieticians?

Tuesday, August 10, 2010

Is Weighing Necessary During Pregnancy?

A while ago, we discussed whether routine weighing at medical appointments is really necessary. 

I reminded people that if weighing bothers them, is triggering to them, or is just against their principles, then routine weighing can be opted out of because you have the right to informed refusal of any test or procedure.  I also reminded people of the times when weighing can be medically necessary versus when it's simply a matter of routine policy, and that the two should be differentiated.

But what about weighing during pregnancy?  Is it really necessary to weigh a pregnant woman at each visit?

Unfortunately, this question is not as simple to answer.  You can make a case both for and against routine weighing at every prenatal appointment.

For the most part, though, the question is moot, because most care providers require weighing at each appointment. You can question its necessity all you want, but most providers are going to require it.

If you are a woman of size who wants to bear children but prefers not to be weighed, the sad truth is that you are either going to have to:
  • find a way to make peace with the weighing requirement, or
  • be prepared to go outside traditional attendants to find those who are more flexible about routine weighings
Weighing = Standard of Care?

Among OBs in the USA, prenatal weighing at every appointment is considered standard-of-care.  If an OB were to not weigh a woman regularly and she later had a problem and sued, that OB could have his/her feet held to the fire in court for not weighing her. 

So, beneficial or not, for most care providers, the "standard of care" argument trumps all the other arguments against routine weighings.  It is simply what is expected medically and legally.

However, it's not "standard of care" in all countries to weigh.  Some doctors in other countries do not weigh pregnant patients at all, even fat ones. Others do not weigh average-sized patients, but will weigh patients regularly who weigh outside the "norm" --- that is, very thin or very fat patients. 

Midwives vary more in whether or not they weigh clients.  Many midwives (especially the ones in hospitals who practice with OB colleagues) do weigh women regularly, but not all do.  I have heard from several hospital midwives in other countries who do not regularly weigh their clients, and I have heard from others that do.  Much depends on the standard of care in that area, and whether or not the midwife practices within the medical model or not. 

Many homebirth midwives here in the USA and abroad do weigh patients routinely, but will let you opt out of it if you prefer.  I found a midwife like this for my fourth pregnancy. (Bless her heart forever). 

But basically, in the U.S., unless you are interested in the homebirth route and have a very flexible midwife, you are almost surely going to be weighed at each prenatal appointment. 

So what are the pros and cons of weighing pregnant women?  Why do it or not do it?

Arguments For and Against Weighing During Pregnancy

There are a variety of reasons providers give for weighing during pregnancy.  Some of them are very legitimate concerns, and some are more dubious.

Monitoring Pregnancy Weight Gain

The reason most commonly given for weighing routinely in pregnancy (and the reason I find least compelling) is to be sure patients don't gain outside the weight gain recommendations.

The main problem with this is that what is considered the "proper" weight gain in pregnancy changes over time. In the 50s, 60s, and 70s, women were told to strictly limit weight gain, to the point that many babies were being born underweight or premature. So then the weight gain guidelines changed, encouraging more weight gain to try and lessen these complications (which they did).

Recently, the more generous weight gain guidelines have been challenged, with many researchers contending that women gain too much weight now, putting themselves at increased risk for a "too-big" baby, a higher rate of cesareans, or retaining too much of the weight after the pregnancy is over. 

Both of these arguments have data to back them up. There is some research that suggests that really large gains are harmful in pregnancy, resulting in extra-big babies and more long-term obesity in the mother.  And there is definitely research that shows that a too-small gain is associated with prematurity and/or too-small babies, even in "obese" women. 

So obviously, a happy medium is the ideal.  But what is considered the "optimal weight gain" is still under debate.  Currently, the latest recommendations from the Institute of Medicine (IOM) are: 25-35 lbs. for "normal" weight women, 28-40 lbs. for "underweight" women, 15-25 lbs. for "overweight" women, and 11-20 lbs. for "obese" women. 

So while what is considered the "correct" weight gain is trendy and changes over time, you could certainly make a case that preventing the extremes of weight gain (too low or too high) might prevent complications, or catch them early enough to intercede. 

On the other hand, weight gain doesn't give much reliable information about a woman's actual nutrition or general health.  Some women have a gain within "normal" limits, yet do so eating mostly junk food.  Some women gain "too much," yet have perfectly good nutrition.  Weight gain as a proxy for a woman's nutritional intake and health is a shaky concept at best.

Furthermore, weight gain doesn't correlate all that well with outcome either.  Some women gain a large amount in pregnancy, yet have perfectly healthy babies and great outcomes.  Some gain less than optimally, yet the outcomes are still good.  Some women gain within the guidelines and have poor outcomes. Pinning too much importance on weight gain amounts is not a reliable indicator of outcome.

Personally, I think far too much importance is placed on the numbers on the scale instead of on the actual nutrition and habits of the woman.  The medical community relies on weight gain as a marker for appropriate nutrition and predictor of outcome, and I think these associations are weak at best. 

However, given the very short appointments most OBs have with patients and the difficulty this can lead to in knowing how a woman is eating, I can understand them wanting some way to monitor the pregnancy's progress.  Not all women are truthful about their nutrition to their providers, and a too-high gain or a too-small gain could be an early warning of someone who is having difficulties managing their food intake.  It could be a marker for the need to intercede early, so I can understand a provider's wish to weigh patients on that level.

Still, isn't the better option the midwifery model of care, which takes more time in each appointment so the care provider knows the client better and understands her particular needs and concerns? 

The midwifery model is the one that takes the time to really emphasize proactive care (including good nutrition) in preventing many complications. It takes time to thoroughly go over general nutritional principles in pregnancy, and it tailors nutritional advice to each woman's individual needs.

While some midwives do weigh their clients routinely to watch for any alarming trends, most de-emphasize the scale in favor of emphasizing the importance of excellent, proactive nutrition and exercise.  To me, emphasizing nutrition seems far more important to me than how much weight a woman actually gains (or not) in pregnancy. 

Most of the time, routine weighings to monitor weight gain as a surrogate for monitoring nutrition or predicting outcome is a weak argument at best, and  besides, judgments of the what is the "proper" amount of weight gain tend to change over time. 

In my opinion, a better approach is to emphasize excellent nutrition and regular exercise and trust the woman's body to gain the amount it needs.

Monitoring Fetal Growth

Another reason many  providers like to weigh women regularly in pregnancy is to monitor fetal growth closely.  As noted, research shows a too-large gain may predict a big baby, and a too-small gain may predict a premature or underweight baby, both of which are associated with risks.

Really large gains can be associated with macrosomia (big baby), and this raises the specter of shoulder dystocia (where the shoulders get stuck).  Although most of the time this is resolved without problems, sometimes this can cause damage to the baby, to the mother, or in rare cases, result in the death of the baby. It is one common reason for lawsuits in obstetrics, which is why doctors worry about it so much.

However, weight gain is only moderately associated with macrsomia. Many women gain average amounts in pregnancy and yet still have "big" babies.  Some people gain a lot in pregnancy and have average-sized babies. Some of us (me!) gain almost nothing in pregnancy and still have big babies.

I am dubious of the idea that weight gain is a really reliable marker for discovering macrosomic babies.  I think research does show that a really high gain increases the number of macrosomic babies but taking a large gain as a guarantee of a big baby amd acting in fear accordingly may cause more problems than it solves.

In fact, monitoring weight gain can backfire because a large gain often triggers an early induction or a planned cesarean for a "big" baby, only some of whom will actually be big, and many of whom will have poorer outcomes because of the interventions.

Research clearly shows that these interventions do not improve outcome and often worsen it, regardless of the size of the baby.....so monitoring weight gain closely and planning interventions based on large gains may actually cause more harm than good in many cases.

On the other hand, weight gain can be a good marker for small-for-gestational-age (SGA) babies.  Research consistently shows that poor weight gain in pregnancy is associated with SGA and/or premature babies.  A very low rate of weight gain, especially in a woman who is already on the thin side, is a marker for strong concern and could be considered a good reason to weigh pregnant women regularly.

However, in "obese" women, the relationship between weight gain and fetal size is more tenuous. Many of us do not gain much weight at all in pregnancy (or even lose a little) and yet still have babies of average or large size.

Yet it's important to remember that even in "obese" women, there is a relationship between low weight gain and SGA/premature babies. It's not as strong a relationship as in smaller women, but it is there.  This is one of the reasons why the push for very little or no weight gain in "obese" women is troubling.

So you could make a case that a woman of size who is not gaining much should have fetal size monitored, just in case.  Chances are that everything is fine in a woman of size with low gain, but it might be helpful to check baby's growth curve periodically, since SGA babies tend to be at higher risk for stillbirth and prematurity.

However, weight is not the only way to monitor fetal growth; measuring the height of the top of the uterus (fundal height) is pretty universal among care providers.  If a problem is suspected via fundal height, then more close supervision of the mother's weight gain might be appropriate, along with other measures of fetal growth. 

Estimating fetal size by ultrasound is also an option.  It's not that accurate at predicting a too-big or too-small baby, but it does fairly well in identifying babies that are average-for-gestational-age.  In other words, it has difficulty accurately identifying all the babies at the extremes of growth, but it's better at ruling out extremes of growth for many babies and reassure everyone that all is well.  This is not a perfect solution, but it is another option.

The argument for weighing women to monitor fetal growth is one that has some merit, but it also carries risks as well as benefits.  If a large gain is used as a marker for more intervention, chances are the risks will outweigh the benefits.  However, if it is used selectively, and particularly to watch for women with too-small babies, the benefits may outweigh the risks.

Pre-Eclampsia

Another major reason for weighing in pregnancy is that a sudden large gain can be a potential symptom of Pre-Eclampsia (PE). In PE, fluid retention is common, and one of the first clues to PE can be a sudden jump in weight gain.

Because PE is a very serious complication of pregnancy and a potential killer, this is one logical reason for monitoring weight gain closely in pregnancy.

The problem with this is that women don't gain weight uniformly each week in pregnancy. Some weeks there are bigger gains, some weeks there is very little gain. Unless there's a huge jump, a bigger gain one week does not necessarily indicate pre-eclampsia.

Yet most doctors measure gains on a diagonal line of "average" gain per week, and some overreact to any deviation from this average...especially in women of size. Realistic providers understand that gain is not always even week to week, yet it's unfortunately very common for women to be hassled about even a small gain above the average "permissable" gain.

While a really big, sudden weight gain jump can be used as a marker to indicate possible PE, even a small gain is often over-reacted to in women of size. Many providers believe that all fat women will develop PE, so they are quick to react to any gain above what they think "should" be taking place. Combine that with the lack of consistency about using a larger blood-pressure cuff in women of size, and many providers are quick to diagnose PE in fat women when there may or may not actually be a problem.

Routine weighing can be advantageous in that it may be one of the first signs that PE is developing, but it also often results in major interventions and hassles, particularly for women of size.

Iatrogenic Harms

What many providers fail to realize is that while regular weighings in pregnancy can sometimes spot complications early on and prevent them from becoming worse, they can also result in unneeded intervention and harm.

In many providers' eyes, a woman with a large prenatal weight gain is a cesarean waiting to happen. They assume that a large gain means a big baby, and so they are more likely to induce labor, do a planned cesarean before labor, or have a very low threshold for proceeding to a cesarean during labor because they are afraid of shoulder dystocia.

In fact research shows that a larger weight gain is associated with a higher risk for cesarean, even when the baby is not big.  Is this because something physical about the bigger weight gain prevents vaginal birth, or is it more about the provider's fear levels and anticipation of trouble?  I think there is a strong case to be made for the latter.

This is one of the problems with monitoring a pregnant women's weight gain closely.  Too often, it's not just neutral information, designed to prevent complications, but instead becomes loaded information used against the woman to instigate interventions at the slightest provocation. 

Are the majority of interventions used around weight gain monitoring really justified?  Do they truly improve outcomes?  Or do many of the interventions put into effect when a woman has a gain outside the norm cause more harm than good?

This is the question that researchers are not examining closely enough.  The medical model is good at helping the small amount of women who truly need assistance during pregnancy, but it is typically very poor at recognizing and changing its own physician-caused (iatrogenic) harms. 

And monitoring weight gain so closely that the care provider freaks out over every little ounce is a very common iatrogenic harm these days.

What If You Prefer Not To Be Weighed In Pregnancy?

Weighing women in pregnancy at every visit is the standard of care in the U.S.A. and in many other countries as well.  Even those places that don't weigh most women may want to weigh women of size regularly in the belief that this might prevent complications (or catch them early). 

Therefore, if you are a person who finds weighing triggering or have a strong philosophical objection to weighing, it can be difficult to find a birth attendant who will honor that objection.

Women of size who wish to avoid regular weighings should look into an alternative-style birth attendant, like a homebirth midwife or a birth center midwife. Although most of these care providers also weigh regularly, they are less likely to be adamant about it and may be willing to work out a compromise position.

Make questions about regular weighings part of your interview process when trying to find a provider.  Share honestly with them the reasons that you prefer not to weigh, and ask them frankly whether or not they could be comfortable avoiding the scale.  Offer to weigh yourself each week and keep track of your own gain, and to let them know if you see a big jump in gain or loss at any point, or if your gain is too low or extremely high overall.  

Reassure them that you care very much about your nutrition, offer to keep food diaries to reassure them that you are getting good nutrition, and note that you will be open to nutrition counseling as needed if it's non-judgmental and reasonable.

Some midwives who normally weigh will be comfortable with avoiding weighing under these conditions.  They just need reassurance that they will be told if there are any disturbing trends in weight gain, and that your nutrition will be consistently good. 

Some midwives will never be comfortable omitting weight gain in prenatal appointments, and in that situation you will have to decide just how important it is to you (or not) to avoid prenatal weighings.

Handling Weighings If Your Care Provider Insists On Them

If you have chosen a high-tech birth attendant who insists on weigh-ins and it bothers you to be weighed, you do have some options. 

Many women find it easier to endure weighings if they take control of the process themselves.  Some choose to turn their backs while being weighed.  Others request that the med tech weigh them without comment and write down the numbers without saying them out loud.

You can share your concerns about regular weighings with the care provider and ask them to let you have some control over the process, or at least to be careful about the kind of comments they make to you about weight gain.

At no time should you ever put up with shaming body talk or critical comments about your results.  Providers who indulge in that kind of talk will not be size-friendly during the birth process and are likely to see you as a disaster waiting to happen.  If you hear negative or shaming comments when weighing or about your weight gain, it's time to find a new provider.

Or you can do what I do when there is a medically-necessary weighing; I don't passively let someone else weigh me, but instead I tell them I can do it myself and they can watch to verify it. I move the scale to about the right number (so there's no long process of over- or under-estimating and adjusting), and I adjust the balance until it's correct.  Somehow it's not so bad or quite so threatening if I do it for myself. 

Sometimes I get a med tech who is very threatened by the idea of me weighing myself (I think they assume I must be trying to fudge the number), but most of the time they are fine with watching me do it.

Mind you, I still hate being weighed by strangers....it reminds me of all those diet program weigh-ins, all the judgment that went with those, and all the living and dying emotionally based on what the scale was doing...but I find it less offensive if I am the one in control of the process. And I never let them make comments about the results.

This was how I handled being weighed in my first 3 pregnancies.  Although I refuse routine weighings when not pregnant, I didn't realize there was any choice when pregnant and so I went along with the weighings the first 3 times.  It wasn't too bad.

Since I'm okay with what I weigh, check myself regularly at home, and don't have an eating disorder (some people with eating disorderes find weighing to be a trigger), I could make peace with the idea of weighing in order to rule out pre-elcampsia or a too-small baby.....but I can't say I ever enjoyed the process.  I just gritted my teeth and got through it. 

Best by far, though, was finding providers who did not require that I be weighed during pregnancy. In my fourth pregnancy, I found birth attendants who were okay with me opting out of weighing. They knew me well enough to realize that they could trust my nutrition and they knew I kept track of my own weight and would report any big gains or losses, and any pre-eclampsia symptoms.

So they were completely fine with me not weighing at ALL in the whole pregnancy, and I have to say, that was SOOOO incredibly freeing! What a breath of fresh air.

They may never realize what a gift they gave me by letting me opt out of that, but blessings on them forever for being flexible that way.

Conclusion

Weighing during pregnancy has many pros and cons. 

On the plus side, it can catch some cases of inadequate weight gain that may lead to a higher risk for a premature or too-small baby, or it may catch an incipient case of pre-eclampsia before it gets too serious.  A too-large gain, caught early, may allow intervention to improve nutrition and perhaps prevent some cases of macrosomia. 

On the minus side, weight gain measurement is often used against women (and especially women of size), leading to more interventions and risky procedures like inductions and cesareans.  Furthermore, it is a poor surrogate for predicting nutritional adequacy or pregnancy outcome. 

A more sensible approach would be to emphasize nutrition over weight gain.  Alas, in today's short appointments, meaningful nutritional counseling is difficult to do and weight gain becomes the stand-in measurement of nutritional adequacy. 

Therefore, to most U.S. maternity care providers, weighing during pregnancy is an absolute requirement. If you have decided to go with a typical OB or hospital midwifery practice, you will almost surely be weighed at every appointment. Find a way to deal with that process proactively so it's not bothersome to you. 

Beware the care provider who is highly restrictive, shaming, or overly-interventive based on your weigh-in results.  That is a classic sign of weight bias and will likely lead to a highly-interventive and high-risk birth.  Better to switch providers than have to put up with that kind of bias during pregnancy.

And if you really object to being weighed during pregnancy, remember that there are some birth attendants who do not require regular weigh-ins. If it's something that really bothers you, you might want to check out one of these providers and see just how freeing it can be.

*I'm interested in hearing YOUR experiences, in or outside the U.S.A.  Where are you from? Do care providers usually weigh women in pregnancy in your area?  Why or why not?  Do they weigh women of size more?  Do they recommend restrictive policies or use shaming comments? Do you think weighing was helpful or hurtful in your case?  How did you feel about being weighed?

If you are a provider, I'm interested in hearing about your reasons for weighing or not weighing, how you monitor nutritional adequacy, and if you weigh, how you help women through an experience many women (of all sizes!) find nerve-wracking.